I’ve been spending too much time at the share your work boards and had some questions.
How much critique do you offer?
How harsh, but fair in your opinion, is it reasonable to be?
Do you only offer detailed criticism to poster you have met in another context or say that they welcome critique?
Do you critique everything you read that falls in the area of books you do read?
If you only have read a bit of the piece, do you comment on that, or only if you have read the whole piece?
Do you only comment if you genuinely loved the piece and saw a few things that could do with improvement?
Sorry if this is the wrong forum to ask, but I’m trying to give myself some sort of mental guidelines for commenting on work on AW. Especially as I have some tendency to give overly blunt comments and would rather not upset anyone.
How much critique do you offer?
How harsh, but fair in your opinion, is it reasonable to be?
Do you only offer detailed criticism to poster you have met in another context or say that they welcome critique?
Do you critique everything you read that falls in the area of books you do read?
If you only have read a bit of the piece, do you comment on that, or only if you have read the whole piece?
Do you only comment if you genuinely loved the piece and saw a few things that could do with improvement?
Sorry if this is the wrong forum to ask, but I’m trying to give myself some sort of mental guidelines for commenting on work on AW. Especially as I have some tendency to give overly blunt comments and would rather not upset anyone.