Query or proposal for a memoir?

ChaseJxyz

Writes 🏳️‍⚧️🌕🐺 and 🏳️‍⚧️🌕🐺 accessories
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 5, 2020
Messages
4,524
Reaction score
6,203
Location
The Rottenest City on the Pacific Coast
Website
www.chasej.xyz
Hello, board, it is me again, your least favorite bird. I have another memoir question.

I was on a panel today about memoirs, and the speakers were literary agents. And they said you write a book proposal for your memoir, like you would any other sort of nonfiction book, that doing queries was a little more "old fashioned." On further discussion, what I gathered is that if your memoir is more "literary," then it should be a query and finished, like a novel. But if it's more "high concept" (the examples given were "ebola doctor" and "female paparazzi")(yes I know there is a specific term for that but shhh) you can do the proposal and then the publisher commissions the book from you.

So I was both surprised and intrigued to hear this. See, what the memoir about is still happening, I have not reached "the end." But I know WHAT the ending is (it's figuring out X, via Y) it's not a vague "and then I learned the power of friendship" type thing. But to do Y, it's going to take a lot of time and effort. And, namely, money. You know how insurance is. So being able to pay for that, and to have the financial cushion to take time off of work if shit gets too stressful. Which it's absolutely going to be, as you can imagine.

{I know I'm being non-specific about what this is, but that's because this forum is visible to everyone, and I don't want random people [such as coworkers] learning about this. I do have the first scene in SYW, which you might have already read, so you should understand why I feel that way.}

My plan WAS to work on this memoir, but not as my primary thing, as I slowly deal with the medical gatekeeping/insurance process, and trying to even find the right professional. And if that's not possible or is out of my means (which is very likely), I'd just DIY it. Which you CAN do, but...well, it's not really recommended. Shit can go bad, which is why you want someone helping you with it. Ending up hospitalized and finding out how to hide that from work sure would make an interesting story! But I would rather not have to live that, if possible.

So my question is ??? fold:
  • Is doing a book proposal for memoirs really a thing?
  • Is it worth doing in my situation? Is my "concept"/"hook" compelling enough (and then my voice/style is also good enough) to make this worthwhile? I do have SOME industry contacts but...this would be published with a pen name. I can't leverage any of my networks/socials for the book, and I know that is part of the package for nonfic proposals.
    • But also I have all of those diversity/under-represented voices things, but idk if that'll make up for the no following thing
  • If an agent says no to a proposal, does that mean I blew my chance with them and can't submit a query/finished MS later?
  • Is there anything else I'm not thinking about
I'm not expecting a huge amount of money for this. Even $3,000 would be an amazing help. I do have SOME money but it's more of an "in case of emergency, break glass" thing. Like if I accidentally put myself into the hospital lol. But I'd rather not you know
 

Elenitsa

writing as Marina Costa
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 20, 2011
Messages
989
Reaction score
791
Location
Bucharest, Romania
Website
caribbeandawn1720.jcink.net
I am always of the opinion to write the story you want to write (fiction or non-fiction) and find a publisher afterwards (or self-publish it, if you cannot find a publisher).
 

Unimportant

No COVID yet. Still masking.
Staff member
Moderator
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 8, 2005
Messages
20,010
Reaction score
23,557
Location
Aotearoa
This is outside my area of knowledge, Chase, so I'm just making guesses.

If you are, or are a close relative of, a super famous person -- say, the child of Cher or Michael Jackson or Elvis or Kim Kardashian or Donald Trump or somebody -- then, yes, your memoir would probably sell on proposal and be commissioned by a publisher. (And obvs I have no idea if you are or not. If you are, go for it!)

If you're a nameless rando plebe like me who hasn't done anything hugely novel or memorable or unique, then without name recognition (e.g. Fauci) or a previous track record of publishing I think it's quite unlikely you could sell on proposal.

IMO if an agent says no to a proposal now, you could query them with a completed work several years from now with no problem.

One possibility to up your recognition level might be to publish pieces of your memoir as short stories/articles. For example, the Huffington Post publishes a lot of "personal" stories, and they seem quite popular (and they're paid work, which would help with the $$). You could try pitching a piece after reading a few to get a feel for what they look for. If you can get a few pieces published, that'll make an agent take a second look, since it's proof that your work is publishable/sellable.