Prologue or no prologue?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fargo

The book I have written seems to fall in the YA genre. The book has a prologue that could be moved to another part of the story as a flashback. I don't know if I should because it could give away the ending...maybe.

What do you think about prologues or epilogues? My book has both.
 

maestrowork

Fear the Death Ray
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
43,746
Reaction score
8,654
Location
Los Angeles
Website
www.amazon.com
The book I have written seems to fall in the YA genre. The book has a prologue that could be moved to another part of the story as a flashback. I don't know if I should because it could give away the ending...maybe.

And putting it in prologue won't give away the ending because....?
 

Fargo

As a prologue I have cleverly disguised it as the background of the societal ill that plagues the country. As a flashback it gives away the end too soon or makes some of the foreshadowing and possible plot twists moot points.

I've read some of the books that my YA daughters read and I don't recall any of them ever having a prologue.
 

Hapax Legomenon

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
22,289
Reaction score
1,491
I've always thought that if you can get rid of the prologue, do it.

How essential is it? Can you get rid of it completely? Think about it.
 

Fargo

To be honest, sometimes when I'm reading, I'll skip the author's prologue altogether. I know --bad me.

This particular part of the story is an integral piece to the mindset of one of the characters.

I don't really know how the SYW section of this board works yet, but, if it will help I could probably post it there. What do you think? Would it be easier to help if you could actually see what I was talking about?

I just ask that you be a bit merciful as this is the first story that I have ever finished.
 

Nymtoc

Benefactor Member
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
43,833
Reaction score
3,367
Location
Between the lines
At a writers conference I once heard a literary agent say that he refused to read novel manuscripts with prologues.

Take it for what it's worth.

:hat:
 
Last edited:

JJ Cooper

.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 28, 2007
Messages
2,511
Reaction score
1,248
Location
On a big Island
Never been a fan of the prologue - then my editors suggested my novel could use one. They made strong, and valid, points that tied a piece of the puzzle together nicely. It's short and concise and I think adds value. So, although I'm still not a big fan - they have a purpose if required. Same with the epilogue.

JJ
 

maestrowork

Fear the Death Ray
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
43,746
Reaction score
8,654
Location
Los Angeles
Website
www.amazon.com
As a prologue I have cleverly disguised it as the background of the societal ill that plagues the country. As a flashback it gives away the end too soon or makes some of the foreshadowing and possible plot twists moot points.

Why can't you do the same as a flashback? I still don't understand. You're the writer. You can do it any way you want.
 

tehuti88

Mackinac Island Fanatic
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 12, 2008
Messages
1,487
Reaction score
149
Location
Not here anymore
Website
www.inkspot.com
If you feel the story needs the prologue and epilogue, then use them. Though your explanation of why you're using the prologue is kind of hard for me to understand, so you might want to examine your reason for using it.

And you've already read here that some people skip reading them entirely. I find this practice utterly baffling--akin to just randomly skipping the first chapters of a story--but that's just me. I find it weird that even though a lot of writers misuse the prologue as an infodump (shame), some people will judge EVERY single prologue as if it must be the same, before even reading a word. But I'm kind of forgiving that way...and I tend to use prologues in my novels. (Though I have to append a note to the first chapter to let readers know that if they skipped the prologue, they've in effect skipped the beginning of the story!)

I'm not writing with publication in mind, be aware. If agents don't bother reading manuscripts with prologues, I find that terribly sad and disappointing, but I'm not the one getting people published. I guess you'll just have to go with your gut and take your chances.

Also please note these are just my personal opinions so I shan't feel a need to defend them further. :)
 

Danthia

As a prologue I have cleverly disguised it as the background of the societal ill that plagues the country.

This suggests to me that the prologue can go. It's not starting the book in media res, it's setting up backstory and world building, both of which can come later when needed.

You'd likely be better off putting your protag in a situation that starts the story off with a bang and also shows the societal ills of the country and how that affects your protag. Let the reader figure out what's plaguing the land by what they see, not by being told about it before they meet the protag. Until readers have a character they care about, they usually don't care about the world or what's wrong with it.
 

Fargo

Couple of things:

1.) I'm a girl. LOL!

2.) I took all of the advice and removed the prologue and embedded it into a more appropriate place in the story and I feel better about it.

Thanks everyone.
 
Last edited:

Feidb

Been Here A While
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
606
Reaction score
51
Location
Las Vegas
Website
www.fredrayworth.com
I like stories with prologues, as long as (as a few of you have said) it isn't an info dump or a history lesson.

There have been a lot of disturbing rumblings from the agent communities that they are dead set against prologues. To me, it's just the "in" thing at the moment, to hate prologues. It may get you rejected and it may not. Also, not every agent is against them.

We are having a writer's conference coming up in the spring and several of the agents coming hate prologues. Guess I can just forget about pitching to them, huh?

I just don't buy the logic that it can be integrated into the story or just eliminated. If the prologue is an action scene that sets up the premise for the rest of the novel, it should be used.

One more thing, it should be short and sweet. Not a 30 page mini-novel (to start the regular novel).

Also, Fargo, in your case, you didn't seem to be happy with it to begin with so integrating it into the body of the novel was the right thing to do.
 

JRTurner

Banned
Joined
Oct 28, 2008
Messages
255
Reaction score
35
I know Fargo already figured it out, but I thought I'd add my two cents on the prologue issue :)

A prologue should be used if:

1) The infromation offered is dire for the reader to comprehend the depth of the book AND it happens either to someone not a part of the main story, is a suppressed memory (and therefore couldn't be worked into the story) or is the key event that set the entire story in motion.

2) The scene sets up genre elements that will take time to develop. This is trickier, but it's a technique that when done correctly, can have awesome impact. A possible example for the horror genre, for instance: a character is killed by a serial killer on route 666, and then chapter one opens with a group of friends on a road trip turning down route 666.

3) The effect of the prologue is to showcase a character's pivotal personality change--a sort of reverse arc--like the child discovers Santa is really Dad--and then the book opens with him acting like Scrooge. This is different from #2 as it makes the unlikeable protagonist isntantly sympathetic. Should there be no prologue, then it might be difficult for the reader to become involved with the story and thus invested in the forward arc of the character.

When a prologue shouldn't be used:

1) When the purpose is solely to mask a floundering, or boring, first chapter. Rewrite the first chapter--don't play tricks with the reader.

2) When the author's lack of confidence in their abilities to portray three dimensional characters makes them believe a prologue describing the childhood of the character (especially if that childhood isn't necessary for the plot of the story) will make readers love that main character as much as the author does.

3) As was mentioned before, when the author thinks a prologue explaining the fictitcious world or the historical aspects of the story will enhance the readers experience. It is the job of the author to make this clear through the believable interactions between characters and showing that character within that environment. (Glossaries or forwards/afterwards are the more appropriate places for this sort of thing--if they're necessary at all.)

Okay, those are my thoughts--most likely I've missed some or there are arguments against these thougths. It is by no way all inclusive or written in stone. Like any so-called rules, there are exceptions :)

Just thought this might interest someone, is all.

Warmly,
Jenny:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.