I know Fargo already figured it out, but I thought I'd add my two cents on the prologue issue
A prologue should be used if:
1) The infromation offered is dire for the reader to comprehend the depth of the book AND it happens either to someone not a part of the main story, is a suppressed memory (and therefore couldn't be worked into the story) or is the key event that set the entire story in motion.
2) The scene sets up genre elements that will take time to develop. This is trickier, but it's a technique that when done correctly, can have awesome impact. A possible example for the horror genre, for instance: a character is killed by a serial killer on route 666, and then chapter one opens with a group of friends on a road trip turning down route 666.
3) The effect of the prologue is to showcase a character's pivotal personality change--a sort of reverse arc--like the child discovers Santa is really Dad--and then the book opens with him acting like Scrooge. This is different from #2 as it makes the unlikeable protagonist isntantly sympathetic. Should there be no prologue, then it might be difficult for the reader to become involved with the story and thus invested in the forward arc of the character.
When a prologue shouldn't be used:
1) When the purpose is solely to mask a floundering, or boring, first chapter. Rewrite the first chapter--don't play tricks with the reader.
2) When the author's lack of confidence in their abilities to portray three dimensional characters makes them believe a prologue describing the childhood of the character (especially if that childhood isn't necessary for the plot of the story) will make readers love that main character as much as the author does.
3) As was mentioned before, when the author thinks a prologue explaining the fictitcious world or the historical aspects of the story will enhance the readers experience. It is the job of the author to make this clear through the believable interactions between characters and showing that character within that environment. (Glossaries or forwards/afterwards are the more appropriate places for this sort of thing--if they're necessary at all.)
Okay, those are my thoughts--most likely I've missed some or there are arguments against these thougths. It is by no way all inclusive or written in stone. Like any so-called rules, there are exceptions
Just thought this might interest someone, is all.
Warmly,
Jenny
