Making an agent list to query

Keep in mind all sales are not listed on Publishers Marketplace. In many cases agents wish to widen the types of books they handle and also they may have had conversation with editors who say " I'm looking for X"

Yeah I would send to each one that want's fantasy- My agent has lunch with editors all the time and they tell her what they're looking for...If an agent falls in love with your story - that's HUGE...
When I have lunch with my editor she often chats informally about what she's looking for...

I think you query the agents you're interested in. If there's an agent you really like but they haven't sold fantasy (and they say they're interested in fantasy) I see no reason not to query them. If you get an offer of representation then you can ask them about their sales history in your genre.

Clearly we all want to query agents we think will want to represent us and our books, but I wouldn't narrow my choices unnecessarily.

For me, I sent out about 10 queries in my first round. I wouldn't have sent out any more queries until I'd gotten responses on those -- if you're not getting requests on the first batch then it's worth taking another look at your query. For that reason, I wouldn't set an arbitrary schedule of 5-10 queries every month -- I'd be more deliberate. Send the first batch, see if the response tells you something about your query and then send the second batch. At that point, once you start getting requests and know you have a solid and catching query letter, I'd open up the field and submit more.

I would not take a chance on an agent who expresses interest in fantasy but hasn't actually sold any. I would stick to agents who'd actually sold fantasy to the publishers you'd like to be published by.

SF/fantasy is a pretty small subsection of publishing, and also rather cliquish. An agent who hasn't sold into that market--even if they express an interest in fantasy--may not know his or her way around the little niche well enough to be most effective in targeting your book to the right editor--and with such a small market, every submission counts. This is especially true for selling foreign rights once your domestic rights have been sold--agents who aren't experts in the domestic fantasy market may be even less expert in overseas markets, or work with co-agents who don't normally deal with fantasy at all. (I speak from experience here.)

I wouldn't worry too much about the fine distinctions between subgenres. Obviously you don't want to send an agent a heroic fantasy if s/he specifically says s/he doesn't want these--but most editors buy in multiple subgenres, and an agent with a fantasy track record doesn't need to have sold a heroic fantasy to know who would be likely to buy one.

Locus magazine is a good resource for news on who's selling what in SF/fantasy. Writer Melinda Goodin has compiled Locus sales reports for the past few years into a spreadsheet--this is a fab resource for finding out about agents.

- Victoria

Dragon-lady said:

Wow, thanks, Victoria! The link didn't work but maybe I need to be a member.

Click to expand...

You don't need to be a member. Try this one. (It's 2007 data, but if you google, you can find her spreadsheets for a few previous years.)

Speaking as a novice who doesn't read or write fantasy (just so you know how much value to put into what I say), if an agent states that they are interested in fantasy, it could be that they are still waiting to receive some well written "heroic fantasy" so that they can make their first sale. And maybe lots of the heroic fantasy writers are being picky about agents and they are unwittlingly passing up these agents who could sell their books.

Any agent who has sold heroic fantasy had to have a "first sale." If an agent is interested in fantasy, or you think that he/she may be worth asking, go ahead and query them. They could very well be seeking heroic fantasy and you could be their first sale. If it's an email query, that makes it all the more easier.

I'd start with the people who have sold books for your favorite authors in your genre. If none of them turn out to be a match, then it might be time to consider broadening your net.

You could always go to a bookstore (or use Amazon, I suppose) and find books that are similar to yours. See if they acknowledge their agents in the front. If not, just write down the author's name and google it or use querytracker.com to find out who the agent is. That should give you a good list of agents who are selling books like yours.

I think querytracker has a section where you can search authors and find their agents.
Go find authors that write what you write, search them on querytracker and you can see who represents them. See if they are accepting queries by going to agentquery.com and searching for the agent (you can also find their submission guidelines there).

Hold on...there's an AW link to it, I'll go find it.


eta: here it is.

http://www.absolutewrite.com/forums/showthread.php?t=79090

Sorry about the non-working link, Dragon-lady. Here's the main page, with sales reports from 2004 through 2008.

ExposingCorruption said:

Any agent who has sold heroic fantasy had to have a "first sale." If an agent is interested in fantasy, or you think that he/she may be worth asking, go ahead and query them. They could very well be seeking heroic fantasy and you could be their first sale.

Click to expand...

I'm sorry, but this is poor advice, especially given your own admission that you are "a novice who doesn't read or write fantasy."

(This, by the way, is a textbook example of why it can be dangerous to try and learn the ropes by using the Internet.)

- Victoria

victoriastrauss said:

I'm sorry, but this is poor advice, especially given your own admission that you are "a novice who doesn't read or write fantasy." - Victoria

Click to expand...

I don't want to argue, but the fact is that any legit agent who has sold heroic fantasy had to have a "first sale." That's simple logic. And if she believes that an agent may be worth asking based on what she could determine about the agent, the worst the agent could do is either a) not respond, or b) turn her down.

ExposingCorruption said:

I don't want to argue, but ....

Click to expand...

My experience tells me that the word "but" neutralizes all the preceding words.

Anyway...

You are only minimally correct. People make first sales, achievements, and marks under supervision. No one develops bona fides out of the blue. Think about your argument and you will see that it is watered down irrelevance.

The only bad advice is that advice not taken and you are trying your best to hoard your unfair share.

I think "Thank you" would have been more appropriate.

JMHO though.

Seeing as Victoria is a very successful author of fantasy novels, I think her advice on the topic of how to get a fantasy novel published should carry tremendous credibility.

ExposingCorruption said:

I don't want to argue, but the fact is that any legit agent who has sold heroic fantasy had to have a "first sale." That's simple logic. And if she believes that an agent may be worth asking based on what she could determine about the agent, the worst the agent could do is either a) not respond, or b) turn her down.

Click to expand...

Actually, the worst the agent could do is say yes, then waste a year (or more) of the author's time and mess up future chances for the author by submitting the manuscript inappropriately.

What Victoria is saying (how presumptuous of me to speak for her... sorry, Victoria. ) is that it's actually unlikely for those new agents to make a "first sale" at all. There are lots and lots and lots of people who think it would be fun to be an agent. "How hard can it be?" they figure. "Just get some clients and send their manuscripts to publishers. Presto!" But as Victoria said, it's a pretty tight-knit circle-- a brand new agent had better have the right connections, know who's buying what at that time, understand tastes and trends and timing...

The only way you can be reasonably assured that the new agent has this potential is if he or she has been working as a "junior" agent or agent's assistant at a reputable agency, or has held prestigious positions in publishing houses (for example, if a senior editor at a major publisher decided to switch to agenting, that person would probably be worth a chance). But if you're just talking about some random new agent who claims to have connections (but with no concrete proof of having worked in an agency or publisher whose name you recognize), chances are that your work is just going to be tied up for no good reason.

I know that if I were a new author seeking an agent, I'd absolutely rather "waste" my time querying lots of top agents and getting rejections along the way, rather than taking the route easier to garner an acceptance (agents with no track record are more likely to take me on)-- because in the long run, I know that the former group is much, much, much more likely to make a sale for me.

I hope the above made sense... I am on Benadryl and am getting slightly foggy-brained.

I absolutely agree.
Query all the top agents, but keep a particular watch out for newly-appointed junior agents at these top agencies. They will have the mentoring and they will be looking to pick up more clients than the well-established folks.

I agree -- I should have clarified what I said. I would focus my first efforts on agents who have a clear track record in your genre. However, I would also research agents at agencies that have a track record in your genre. While I do think that every agent has to have their first sale, I think it's "safer" to go with an agent who has the back-up and knowledge of an agency behind them. When I was searching for agents I had a few that wanted my book to be their first YA sale or to build their small YA list -- in such a case I looked to their agency to see whether I would be taking too much of a risk with this -- were there other agents with lots of YA sales, did the agency have a strong track record, etc. I would not advocate taking a chance on an agent with no track record and no other form of support. But sometimes you have to get to the point of being able to talk to them to figure this out.

As for figuring out which agents you like, I'd look at things like their blogs, websites, sometimes you can find interviews if you google, and their client list. That way you can tell if you think you and your work would be a good fit for them.

Jenna, I guess that I didn't word my post correctly when I said, "If an agent states that they are interested in fantasy, it could be that they are still waiting to receive some well written 'heroic fantasy' so that they can make their first sale."

What I was trying to say is that an agent who has a track record for selling fantasy may still be waiting for their first "heroic fantasy" sale simply because they haven't received any decent stories that would fall under that sub-genre. I was trying to say that the agents who have sold heroic fantasy could have had a substantial number of fantasy sales before they sold their first heroic fantasy.

I was definitely NOT trying to say that she should query NEW agents, although looking back on my post, I can see that it comes across that way. My apologies to all those who interpreted it that way.