I've finally gotten to Best American Short Stories 2006 on my to-read bookcase. Out of curiosity, I started looking at how many stories One Story had managed to get in the book. They had two in the collection, plus another 5 in the honorable mention listing. So over a third of what they published in 2005 got into BASS. Suddenly I feel better about the story I sent them getting rejected, although I still think that they made a mistake (The Paris Review, however, not only concurred with One Story, but did so in half the time it took them to reject the last story I sent them).