Thanks, as always, Nikee.
I posted my first draft of the query, if anyone is interested in critting it. I'll have to keep in mind what you said and add to it, Nikee.
http://www.absolutewrite.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75805
Okay, I took a look at it and I hope you'll forgive me if I'm very tough on it.
As you've written it, it sounds extremely generic and very expensive. Part of my fear, in reading it, is that much of what sounds generic in its description may be equally generic in its execution.
When one talks about an "idyllic planet" -- I'm reminded of a classic put down of bad science fiction. Someone, I forget who, once started a story with, "It was raining on Earth that day."
Well, of course, it doesn't "rain" on the entire planet of Earth -- but somehow or other, when people write SF, the tendency is to make other whole planets into all one thing.
A rain planet. A desert planet. A jungle planet. An Ice Planet (remember Hoth -- that was an "Ice" planet). Or do you remember Alderan from Star Wars. It was a "peaceful" planet. Yup. The whole freaking world of Alderan. It was all peaceful. The whole place -- until they blasted it.
And would I be right to presume that this is another one of those alien planets occupied by beings who are, in all respects, identical to human beings? Well, if this is a human colony, or was one, maybe that's not a problem.
No -- I'll tell what the real problem is. You've buried your unique selling point. In fact, it doesn't appear in your log line at all, which you've managed to make completely generic.
Here's the deal -- Star Wars has been made, and it has recently been remade -- three times -- and it has totally filled the niche for all "movies like Star Wars." Anything that you start out selling as "star wars lite" -- and that's how the log line sounds, you're dead.
But hiding in your sort of convoluted description of the action, there is actually something interesting.
Aliens from another world go back into Earth's past -- to the Middle Ages -- to alter history so that they will win a future war. But they're actually the good guys.
That's the log line. That's the pitch. Because that's intriguing.
And please, before you send anything out -- get rid of those pseudo-Lord of the Rings fantasy-ish names. Change them in your script and change them in the pitch paragraph, if you decide to still keep it.
Truly, nobody wants to read about the beautiful planet Melliflua being attacked by the evil general Snidely Backstabber -- or any version thereof. You have got to take a big giant step beyond that kind of stuff in terms of your naming of names.
Hope you take this in the spirit it's given. I really want you to have the best shot that you can.
NMS