Screw Dan Simmons episodic crap

Go watch Total Recall. You'll feel better

Why not read the last page before shelling out the bucks?

Or just do a second or two of research before deciding to read the book.

I agree--an author has a certain responsibility to deliver a promised story, and not just use a book as a money-making scam. Otherwise we’re just politicians!

The problem is that some stories are too big for one book. If I remember correctly, Hyperion was supposed to be one story, but it was so long that they had to break it into two books. (I no longer have my Locus magazines from that time, however.)

There are also some cases where a book was published in one volume in hardback, but when it became a paperback, they had to break it into two parts because of length. For example, this happened with one of Tad Williams' novels, and with the Legends anthology and with another recent fantasy anthology.

Besides, it's rarely up to the authors whether or not the publisher lets you know that something is the first book in a series. There are cases where the publisher refuses to label books as parts of a trilogy, probably because they know some readers don't want to buy books in a series or at least don't want to buy the series until all the books have been published. So readers might get the first book and get upset that they have to get another book to find out what happens. Worse, readers sometimes pick up Book Two by accident and then find themselves lost and confused. (This happened with Lynn Flewelling's latest fantasy trilogy IIRC.)

Also, I've known of publishers who made an author write something with a cliffhanger ending, no matter what the author thought, because the publisher figured readers would be more likely to pick up the next book if the first one ended with a cliffhanger.

What about those wonderful, publicly funded through your tax dollars, institutions called libraries? They have these things called books. And they let you borrow them!

Seems silly to me to complain that *you* spent *your* money on a book that you didn't like. If it's such a problem, check the book out of the library next time.

That's a shame, I mean Simmons has written some sterling stand alones. Including the most horifying novel I ever read--so much so I have never had the guts to re-read it. It just tripped all my triggers.

But one poster is absolutely right, the author has little control over whether or not a long book comes out as a single volume or two.

Regards,
Scott

Yeah, but you don't end a novel in the middle of a sentence or say "find out in my next novel." That's horse pucky, no matter who's idea it is.

I don't have to worry about that. I've never ever, since Crime and Punishment read a book of so many pages.

I know what you mean--Vanity Fair made me wary of any especially long books.

DeniseK said:

Yeah, but you don't end a novel in the middle of a sentence or say "find out in my next novel." That's horse pucky, no matter who's idea it is.

Click to expand...

I completely agree. At the very least, it should be made clear on the cover. Cliffhangers are one thing, but stopping mid-sentence?! That's just BS.

kuatolives said:

I dont mind a book that's part of a triology, but to so shamelessly leave off any semeblence of a climax is unforgiveable.

Click to expand...

If it makes you feel any better, Olympos doesn't have much of a climax either IMO.

Movies...

kuatolives said:

That is the LAST time I buy one of his novels. There is nothing more
dishonest to make a reader trudge through 750 pages only to find out the book is episodic in nature. Specifically, in Illium he spends those 750 pages
building up a big battle that he just says....oh continued with my next novel. Not with my 10 bucks it aint.

Screw you Simmons.

Click to expand...

Did you see Back to the Future II? Did you see Back to the Future III?

I know what you're saying. NEVER should it be done. Let the story be told.

JPS

Popeyesays said:

That's a shame, I mean Simmons has written some sterling stand alones. Including the most horifying novel I ever read--so much so I have never had the guts to re-read it. It just tripped all my triggers.

Click to expand...

Song of Kali?

That book was incredible.

To the people who have opened the threads on writing trilogies: pay particular attention to the responses in this thread.