- Joined
- Jul 16, 2006
- Messages
- 14,627
- Reaction score
- 2,057
I'm sort of glad about this.
I STILL haven't read it, and I really wanted to watch the movie, but I prefer to compare them.
I'm one of those types in the theater that get's popcorn thrown at them for picking apart the movie and complaining about the differences. At least this way I can just enjoy it as a zombie movie.
It's odd; Brad Pitt had to push for years to get this movie made. So why not make it closer to the book? The obvious way to adapt it would be in the form of a documentary, with a combination of interviews and a variety of footage: cellphones, news-channel footage, battlefield filming, government agency documentation, etc. At least, fans of the book would like it.
I guess it's another case of choosing between pleasing the existing fanbase, or making it more accessible to a larger potential fanbase .
When I read Steven Gould's excellent novel Jumper, I thought, "You could very easily adapt this to a movie; hardly have to change anything." Then somebody made a movie, and apparently they changed nearly everything, for no apparent reason, and not to its betterment.
I asked Gould how he felt about it, and he said something like, "It doesn't change the book I wrote; that's still available in the form I intended. The movie is a separate property, and doesn't belong to me."
So I'll probably go see the movie, keeping it mentally separate from the book I like. (And I still wish Brooks would write a sequel focusing on NYC. "World War Z: The Hero City".)
The original I am Legend Movie (LINK) Actually did a good adaptation. Good luck finding a copy, I had to search for a LONG time to find one.I just wish they had called it something different. In fact, why did they even buy the rights to this book if they weren't going to use any parts from it. Granted I am assuming this without having seen it. and might be wrong but the very nature of the book makes it likely.) Now no one can make a proper movie version of the book because of this film and the talk that this will be a trilogy if successful.
They've basically pulled an "I Am Legend." which was an okay movie but should have been called something else so that some one could make an actual "I Am Legend" properly.
I think I got my copy for $5 at a Big Lots.The original I am Legend Movie (LINK) Actually did a good adaptation. Good luck finding a copy, I had to search for a LONG time to find one.