"Piracy" is such an outdated term anyway. I don't think it applies anymore. It's more like free marketing, but I guess an author with imaginary numbers of losses in his head isn't going to be able to see it that way. Not yet, anyway. Which is fine--I'm sure complaining to NGOs with zero real authority does make a person feel better inside. But maybe soon more artists will realize that working with this gets you much farther than fighting it.
Yes, expect wrath. I'm a working writer and need every penny I earn.
Every time some thief posts my books without my permission, that's money coming out of my pocket, never mind the copyright infringement.
Those were
not imaginary numbers my friend quoted.
She is one scary smart individual and does those kinds of projections in her day job. She was also being conservative.
I do not complain to the hosts of such sites. Being rude gets you nowhere. I am polite, and they return in kind by removing the material. When they do, I thank them.
I maintain that they are in the wrong for turning a blind eye to the thousands who post copyrighted material and, while giving lip service to copyright and the DMCA, continue to allow it, and allow offenders to repost. They make no effort to police their content, and claiming they just don't have time to check everything. They sure do have time to check their bank accounts as the ad money rolls in.
It IS piracy. Free marketing is exactly the kind of term a thief will use to defend his or her actions. It cuts no ice with me or other professionals.
Cory Doctrow may be right, but the younglings coming up now need to be educated. Time and again I see them assuming that if it's on the Net, then it's free. They have never heard of copyright, no one has taken the time to tell them just how it hurts the writers they love.
Again, those downloads are
invisible to the beancounters.
No arguing that libraries loans are invisible. Librarians keep track of the times a title is checked out and order more books from that writer. The publishers keep track of library sales, same as they do for bookstore sales.
No arguing that used bookstores may also hurt the writers. At some point those books were counted as a legit sale.
And used bookstores do not sell or give away an endless supply of Xerox copies.
No one try telling me that the thieves aren't getting something out of it. They put stuff up on sites so they can download other things they want more. They post on sites where they earn a few pennies off each download. (Usually it's a porn site.)
I've tracked one dufus across the main download sites. He signs his pseudonym and tells people to "enjoy" at my expense. He's not posted other books, just mine, so I can safely conclude he's a fan who thinks he's doing me a favor. I'd like to wring his lazy neck. Most of the sites tend toward getting the money for him when people click on his links, the lazy bast%%d. If he's got time to steal from me and earn a few pennies on a porn site, he's got time to get a job; I've got no sympathy for any of them.
Last fall some moron posted his whole e-library on the Net, inviting everyone to download and read all the books. He'd gotten himself a website and it was free.
He was being altruistic out of bald-faced ignorance. He honestly did not know how illegal that was.
Of course the hundreds of writers, including myself, and their publishers saw things differently. They went after his host server, and he was closed down within a day.
To his credit, he did apologize. He never had copyright ownership explained to him.