- Joined
- Jul 28, 2005
- Messages
- 2,764
- Reaction score
- 120
Best Directorial Debuts
- Thread starter childeroland
- Start date
I had to go with American History X...the rest are excellent but that's my favorite movie. Edward Norton was brillant. Who cares about the directing? 
I had to go with American History X...the rest are excellent but that's my favorite movie. Edward Norton was brillant. Who cares about the directing?
I'd have to agree with this. Edward Norton is brilliant. I don't know how the directing would have been without him, but the movie sure ended up being good.
According to Tony Kaye, Edward Norton recut American History X without the director's permission, and Tony Kaye wanted his name removed from the film. If he removed his name, the Director's Guild would not allow him to talk about why he removed it. I've seen the director's cut, and I thought it made a lot more sense. The relationship between him and the guy he worked with in prison was developed more.
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2005
- Messages
- 46,262
- Reaction score
- 9,913
- Location
- on the Seven Bridges Road
- Website
- thepondsofhappenstance.com
You will scoff but Ben Afleck, Gone Baby Gone. Probably not the best first-time movie but one of the much better ones. He definitely should concentrate on directing. Although I like him as an actor, he picks not good movies to act in. Except for Hollywood Land.
American Beauty is right near the top. I detest Tarantino so don't even mention him. lol
American Beauty is right near the top. I detest Tarantino so don't even mention him. lol
Other:
Sidney Lumet - Twelve Angry Men
Fernando Meirelles - City Of God
Spike Jonze - Being John Malkovich
Kevin Smith - Clerks (perhaps less for direction and more about the mix of writing/directing)
Robert Rodriguez - El Mariachi
M. Night Shyamalan - The Sixth Sense
Mel Brooks - The Producers (again possibly the writing/directing combined)
And since I saw it yesterday and was quite impressed, honorable mention for Ben Affleck and Gone Baby Gone.
Sidney Lumet - Twelve Angry Men
Fernando Meirelles - City Of God
Spike Jonze - Being John Malkovich
Kevin Smith - Clerks (perhaps less for direction and more about the mix of writing/directing)
Robert Rodriguez - El Mariachi
M. Night Shyamalan - The Sixth Sense
Mel Brooks - The Producers (again possibly the writing/directing combined)
And since I saw it yesterday and was quite impressed, honorable mention for Ben Affleck and Gone Baby Gone.
Mike Nichols... debut was "Virginia Woolf," followed the next year by "The Graduate."
Apparently he got the hang of it right off.
Apparently he got the hang of it right off.
That was M. Night's third film. And I think the director of City Of God had done a few, too, but I don't know what they are.
- Joined
- Feb 21, 2006
- Messages
- 6,965
- Reaction score
- 3,051
From that list, I'd vote either Sam Raimi or Sam Mendes.
But Neil Marshall also deserves mention.
But Neil Marshall also deserves mention.
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2005
- Messages
- 23,708
- Reaction score
- 10,661
- Location
- In a world of my own making
- Website
- shadowferret.wordpress.com
I'd go with either John Huston or Orson Welles. Welles because Citizen Cain is simply considered a cinematic classic (even though it seems rather dated today). John Huston because I just love the Maltese Falcon. Everything else on that list I can live without.
I picked Welles' Citizen Kane, but Huston's Maltese Falcon was a close second. Both are brilliant films.
And I'm not really a Tarantino fan either.
And I'm not really a Tarantino fan either.
How could i forget? It's only my most favourite movie of all time. Stephen Frears for My Beautiful Laundrette.