A few questions for MG project ( partial repost from YA forum)...

zeppelin123

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
182
Reaction score
45
Location
Canada
I am reposting part of my questions here as the people on the YA form said this piece was more MG than YA.


I am working on story about a 12-year-old surviving twin who lost her parents and twin brother at birth in a car accident. Malika Evelyn (Evy) feels out of place so she creates this idealistic world in her mind with her birth parents and brother, calls her cousins who have been her "parents" since birth by their first names, and insists on being called by her middle name because it belonged to her birth mother. Evy learns to become a leader by organizing other students in an effort to raise money to save a sick kitten. Through the mentoring of her grandfather, Evy overcomes motor difficulties to perform in a traditional Native dance as part of the fundraising effort.

Partway through the story she gets lectured for calling her adoptive parents/cousins Dan and Rena and begins calling them Mom and Dad like she once did.

Her decision to be called Evy was a recent decision rather than something she was called all her life. At the conclusion of the novel should she decide to go by her origional first name? Her first name was given to her by her adoptive mother and is a deriviation of Rena's middle name Mikayla.

I think this change may symbolize the transition out of her fantasy world but I'm afraid it will also create confusion. If I did this, it would be in my final chapter of the book.

This is my planned last paragraph if I do decide to go this route

"You will always be a part of who I am but so are my family and friends here. I will end my story with the last paragraph of anassignment I did in class today because I think it says what I want to say best.

Not long ago, I thought I didn’t belong anywhere. I wanted to be anybody other than who I was. I tried calling myself by my middle name, trying to start my own country, and even wanting to run away from this world to a place where everything was perfect. None of these things worked. Making a difference in this world did. I found out I did not need to be Prime Minister to make a difference. I just have to be Malika Evelyn Deaki member of Earth club, citizen of the world."
 
Last edited:

MsJudy

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 12, 2007
Messages
5,669
Reaction score
1,440
Location
california
The paragraph works nicely. Because you haven't had her DROP Evelyn, it shows how she has accepted all the parts of herself. Malika, Evy, they are both who she is.

I work with kids from Mexico, and it's interesting to watch how the names change as they grow. Maria Guadalupe is Lupita as a little girl, and at some point decides to be either Lupe or Maria. The boys are often named after their fathers, with a different middle name. So the son of Victor Manuel is Victor Ivan. His family calls him Ivan to tell him apart from his dad. But at school, the bureaucracy doesn't really have a space for that, so he ends up being Victor. To the kid, it feels like the minute he starts kindergarten, he's a grown-up. He now uses his father's name.

So to me, it makes a lot of sense that what she chooses to be called is a significant rite of passage.