Survival of the fittest?

Oberon

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 16, 2007
Messages
453
Reaction score
87
Location
Palm Springs, CA
I bring you one of my pet peeves: Survival of the fittest. Every time I hear it or read it I cringe. It is a misleading idea. Fittest compared to what? Everybody can't be the fittest. It should be survival of the fit. Period. A living thing does not have to be the fittest to survive. Not supreme, just good enough. Is a grizzly more fit to survive than a panda? Probably, knowing the panda's limited diet. Is the fittest grizzly the only one to survive? No, there are lot's of grizzlies less fit surviving just fine.

An interesting observation: When the big guys are out there banging heads and antlers to win the females, a younger or less fit male sometimes sneaks in and gets it on with the harem while the fight is distracting the "fittest." So who gets to survive?

Superlatives are human inventions. We love them. The best, the fastest, the strongest, even sometimes the smartest. Reality shows, winners and losers. If you're not a winner you're a loser. Not so in the broader world of real reality. So I plead for a change. Survival of the fit. If you're fit you have a chance out in the wilderness.

I grew up knowing this. My father was a world-renowned biologist, pioneering ecologist, wilderness advocate. Peterson Field guide to Animal Tracks. A lot about animal behavior as well as how to discover who has been doing what where. Buy it. I get royalties.
 

wombat

wombats galore
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 16, 2007
Messages
345
Reaction score
33
Website
animalsbehavingbadly.blogspot.com
I have that book!

But isn't the point of that phrase, fittest for a specific niche? The fittest panda is the one that's best at being a panda, and it wins the competition with the less fit panda (the one who'd rather eat ma po tofu when all that's available is bamboo, say). Pandas compete with other pandas, not grizzlies or komodo dragons or amoebas or whatever.
 

Fenika

Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 3, 2007
Messages
24,311
Reaction score
5,110
Location
-
But the fittest still succumb to freak accidents....
Fit works
 

jessicaorr

Book fanatic
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 12, 2006
Messages
286
Reaction score
39
Location
Midwest
I have that book too! And yeah, -survival of the fittest- has always bothered me. It was popularized by Herbert Spencer as an expoundation/alternative to the phrase "Natural Selection" and adopted by Darwin in his later editions of The Origin of Species. The phrase itself is somewhat tautological but it's still used by laymen because the accepted definition of Natural Selection doesn't sound as catchy.

My evolution proff used to smack anyone he heard utter the phrase with his lecture notes LOL
 

Horseshoes

lisapreston.com
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 29, 2007
Messages
827
Reaction score
104
Location
Pacific Northwet
Website
www.lisapreston.com
I too make sure Oberon's getting them royalty checks.

Yeah, Jessica, Darwin said the most adaptable survived. A panda is adapted to its enviro, a grizz to his. Adaptation is where it's at, not necessarily iron-event level fitness.