Leading with a list

Status
Not open for further replies.

KansasWriter

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 27, 2007
Messages
316
Reaction score
9
Location
Bangkok, Thailand
Hi everyone,

When leading with a list of people, what punctuation, if any, is necessary after the list. For example:

[FONT=&quot]A South Korean belly-dancer, an assortment of South African politicians, and the inner circle of the White House. Hollywood’s newest political thriller? [/FONT]

As you can see, the first bit is not a complete sentence. But I'm fairly sure it is permissible when introducing an article. Yet, do I need something other than a period to finish it?

Thanks!
KW
 

job

In the end, it's just you and the manuscript
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
3,459
Reaction score
653
Website
www.joannabourne.com
OK. Not looking this up, and going with Chicago's rules here ...


1) It doesn't matter what you have a list of. The rules are the same for people, book titles, ideals, or ripe fruits.
Sentence fragments are fine in informal writing.
You can use them anywhere you want in an article, not just at the beginning.



2) Whether it's commas or semicolons separating elements of a list, no special punctuation is needed 'after a list'.


Jenny, Myrna, and Estelle shot the deputy.

Plaudits accrued, as Daniel, Gregory, and the other Postmodernists persevered.

Hand me the wrench, the tackle box, and the ham sandwich on the TV.




3) That said, an extra comma may be added to clarify meaning after a series.
( well ... this sort of clarifying comma can be added about anywhere.)

Hand me the wrench, the tackle box, and the ham sandwich that Susie made me, on the TV.



4) Looking at your particular example ...

A South Korean belly-dancer, an assortment of South African politicians, and the inner circle of the White House.


It doesn't matter that your sentence fragment is a list. The ending punctuation of the sentence fragment would be handled just like any other sentence fragment.

Sentence fragments can end with a period, exclamation point, question mark, ellipsis or em dash.

Sentence fragments cannot end with a comma, semicolon or colon. When these are used, the sentence continues.

When using an em dash or ellipsis at the end of a sentence fragment, it is necessaary to show that the next word begins a new sentence. If this cannot be done by capitalization - as in your case -- you'll need to recast the phrases for clarity.
 
Last edited:

FennelGiraffe

It's green they say
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
445
Location
San Antonio
When leading with a list of people, what punctuation, if any, is necessary after the list. For example:

[FONT=&quot]A South Korean belly-dancer, an assortment of South African politicians, and the inner circle of the White House. Hollywood’s newest political thriller? [/FONT]
A colon or maybe an em-dash would work for me. But like Shadow_Ferret, I'm not sure there's anything wrong with what you have.

I don't think the listiness of it matters. You can have the same structure with only one item. And the fact that it's people certainly doesn't.
Fried ice cream--dietary solecism?
Fried ice cream: Dietary solecism?
Fried ice cream. Dietary solecism?
There's no way to get a complete sentence out of it: not the first part, not the second part, not both parts together. So I'm not sure "correct" punctuation is a meaningful question here.
 

KansasWriter

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 27, 2007
Messages
316
Reaction score
9
Location
Bangkok, Thailand
I have to get me one of them Chicago manuals soon! :)

Ok folks thanks. And Job thank you for such a detailed explanation.

I also think it sounds OK as is but, it's one of my very first queries and I didn't want the very first sentence to be wrong!

The mag asked for a humorous slant and I think that's what I gave 'em.

KW
 
Status
Not open for further replies.