I'm having a moral dilema

Status
Not open for further replies.

MonaLeigh

Wasting time
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 10, 2006
Messages
665
Reaction score
65
Location
NY
I am writing a novel about a married woman who falls in love with someone else. I'm having a hard time b/c I keep thinking people won't like my main character, even though I've made her funny and likable. Should I just shut that inner critic up and write what I want?
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
In short, yes.

I don't read books and think it's a reflection on the author, or that the character is black-and-white bad. Good people do bad things. I'd find it more believable if her marriage was obviously in trouble, though. To give her affair a reason.

But aside from that, write the book first, THEN worry about how people will receive it.
 

Azraelsbane

Agony is defeat
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
1,917
Location
In front of the Almighty, on the wrong side of the
Website
www.granitewindstarr.com
Yes, just write. If I worried that people wouldn't like my characters, I'd never get anything written. I actually count on people not liking some of my characters, or at least having some reservations about liking them. ;)

Who cares if she's married and falls in love with another person? Happens every day and those people still manage to have sympathizers.
 

MonaLeigh

Wasting time
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 10, 2006
Messages
665
Reaction score
65
Location
NY
Thanks. It happened to me. I was married for six years and fell in love with someone else. I didn't want to, but I did. Fast forward seven years, I'm happily remarried and so is my ex-husband. Ironically I am best friends with my ex-husbands wife, and the four of us get together a few times a month and we all hang out (our kids are friends too).

I went through hell when I left my ex-husband b/c he wasn't a 'bad' person. As my family pointed out over and over, he didn't hit me and wasn't abusive in any way. It's hard to explain that you're just married to your best friend, but you don't feel the husband/wife love.
 

maestrowork

Fear the Death Ray
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
43,746
Reaction score
8,654
Location
Los Angeles
Website
www.amazon.com
I am writing a novel about a married woman who falls in love with someone else. I'm having a hard time b/c I keep thinking people won't like my main character, even though I've made her funny and likable. Should I just shut that inner critic up and write what I want?

You're putting your own moral judgment on your character, and why? Just write and let your readers make their own conclusion. And besides, if you write it well, you can let your readers see her point of view. And love knows no boundary -- I really don't think people will automatically find someone who falls in love with another person "bad." Give her reasons, conflicts (she doesn't just does it for glee without regard to her husband's feelings, does she?), guilt, etc. -- make her flesh and blood real. Your readers will like her.
 

shakeysix

blue eyed floozy
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 1, 2007
Messages
10,839
Reaction score
2,428
Location
St. John, Kansas
Website
shakey6wordsmith.webs.com
qualms

just give her some qualms to make her human. you know like her conscience is telling her one thing and yet...there he is, under her skin. i am pretty sure you know what is going through her mind. don't see how you can not make a likable character when you have gone through the same thing--empathy rounds out characters. hey--did you ever see 'the butcher's wife"? that movie deals with a situation something like your novel.--s6 ps--and maybe you could have her super scrupulous in some other area. super honest--returns stolen items that she finds in a house she is cleaning. OR reports her neighbor for abusing his dog--like that. buen suerte.
 

necia phoenix

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 26, 2007
Messages
836
Reaction score
102
Location
Oklahoma
Website
necia-phoenix.livejournal.com
don't sweat it, I have a character who fell in love with his best friends lover. It becomes an interesting mess for my character to wade through. When I told my soundingboard (my best friend who doubles as my s-i-l), I feared she wouldn't like the idea but instead she said it makes the characters more complex and interesting. Which I agree.
 

wayndom

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
775
Reaction score
130
Location
San Francisco
A character's moral dilemma is your moral dilemma. Is it okay for this character to cheat on her husband? You know the circumstances under which it happens, so you're the only one who can answer the question.

And the question does have to be answered. If not, you'll end up writing a novel with your eyes closed, so to speak. That is, you'll write about events which you don't approve of, without disapproving of them. Isn't that dishonest in a fundamental way?

I've had to deal with this problem in thrillers, where I want a protagonist to kill a villain, but can't because the villain's true villainy hasn't been revealed yet, so the act would simply render my protagonist a murderer.

How many movies have you seen where the hero stops the villain's evil plot, then confronts him with his villainy, and while reading him the riot act, the villain falls backward off the balcony (some crappy TV movie of a V.C. Andrews thing)? Or the villain picks up a weapon to kill the hero, and touches a high-tension cable and is electrocuted?

These are the result of the story calling for the villain to be killed without making the hero a murderer.

Your situation is more subtle, but it's the same problem. It's hard to depict a character doing something morally repugnant, and expect readers to root for that character.

Possibilities: Have your character agonize over her attraction, and do her damnedest to make her marriage work, but her lump of a husband absolutely refuses to take part in her marriage-saving attempts, thus putting responsibility for the marriage's failure squarely in his lap.

For added measure, she could continue to agonize over the immorality of it all even after her husband demonstrates his lack of concern, maybe by confessing (if she's Catholic), or some such.

Everyone understands that there are sham marriages in which "fidelity" is just another motion to go through, and that people sometimes meet and fall in love through no fault or motivation of their own (if they work together, for example).

Work it out.
 

Kaytie

Registered
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
Messages
47
Reaction score
8
Location
in my head
Website
www.kaytie.net
Don't forget Madame Bovary. ;)

The outcome of your novel sounds as if it will be very different.

Forgive me saying this--I've been trying to find a way to put it politely, and I only mean it in the most helpful sense, but...perhaps you're having second thoughts writing this particular story, not because you're afraid the main character won't be sympathetic but because the novel so closely mirrors your own experience...that you're afraid any resistance to the main character will reflect on you and your past choices?

If you hadn't mentioned your own experience, I would say don't worry about what people might like or not like about your character because you can't control that.

And maybe you're not writing this story to validate your own choices but that's the question that comes to my mind after your second post.


And as someone with a similar experience in my past, I write this with no judgment. :)
 

IrishScribbler

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 19, 2006
Messages
610
Reaction score
41
Location
central Illinois
Website
coffee-stainedwriter.blogspot.com
Read Disobedience by Jane Hamilton. It's written from a teenage son's perspective; he finds out about his mother's affair and doesn't let anyone know he knows.

I think it does a good job of not only making the mother--who is having an affair--likable, but also the son--who reads her email often.
 

Chasing the Horizon

Blowing in the Wind
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
4,288
Reaction score
561
Location
Pennsylvania
I've been very surprised by some of my beta readers' reactions to my characters. I have one character who's an assassin, and my readers like her because 'she's just so cool and sarcastic and funny' (their words, not mine). Apparently being 'cool' enables one to be forgiven for cold-blooded murder, repeatedly. *shrug* I don't quite get it myself, LOL. I wrote the book focused on my hero because he's the only one of the whole group who's a halfway decent person, but my betas like most of the other characters just as much. If readers can forgive murder, I have a hard time believing they wouldn't forgive infidelity, assuming the character is otherwise very likable.
 

wayndom

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
775
Reaction score
130
Location
San Francisco
I've been very surprised by some of my beta readers' reactions to my characters. I have one character who's an assassin, and my readers like her because 'she's just so cool and sarcastic and funny' (their words, not mine). Apparently being 'cool' enables one to be forgiven for cold-blooded murder, repeatedly. *shrug* I don't quite get it myself, LOL. I wrote the book focused on my hero because he's the only one of the whole group who's a halfway decent person, but my betas like most of the other characters just as much. If readers can forgive murder, I have a hard time believing they wouldn't forgive infidelity, assuming the character is otherwise very likable.

Your readers like your villains as much as your heros? I hope you're not complaining...
 

Azraelsbane

Agony is defeat
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
1,917
Location
In front of the Almighty, on the wrong side of the
Website
www.granitewindstarr.com
I've been very surprised by some of my beta readers' reactions to my characters. I have one character who's an assassin, and my readers like her because 'she's just so cool and sarcastic and funny' (their words, not mine). Apparently being 'cool' enables one to be forgiven for cold-blooded murder, repeatedly. *shrug* I don't quite get it myself, LOL. I wrote the book focused on my hero because he's the only one of the whole group who's a halfway decent person, but my betas like most of the other characters just as much. If readers can forgive murder, I have a hard time believing they wouldn't forgive infidelity, assuming the character is otherwise very likable.

Hey, you are not allowed to have a sarcastic, funny assassin chick! That is mine! ::looks down at Granite Windstarr and pouts:: :tongue

Yeah, I agree with the reader forgiveness. My assassin uses infant killing as the final test for choosing her clan of shooters (no, it doesn't go into detail). I thought that pretty much would have killed any sympathy votes for her, but from all 4 female betas I got the same "I think she really tries to be a good person, but she just doesn't know how." :Shrug:

Now my char is sporting a morality complex... As if she wasn't giving me a hard enough time already!
 
Last edited:

Azraelsbane

Agony is defeat
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
1,917
Location
In front of the Almighty, on the wrong side of the
Website
www.granitewindstarr.com
Your readers like your villains as much as your heros? I hope you're not complaining...

I'll complain about this. ;)

My husband is one of my beta readers, and if I hear "I really liked this section, but it needs more Nikoli (my main antagonist)" or "Is Nikoli going to be in the next chapter?" one more time I swear I'm gonna brain him! LoL
 

Shadow_Ferret

Court Jester
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Messages
23,708
Reaction score
10,661
Location
In a world of my own making
Website
shadowferret.wordpress.com
I am writing a novel about a married woman who falls in love with someone else. I'm having a hard time b/c I keep thinking people won't like my main character, even though I've made her funny and likable. Should I just shut that inner critic up and write what I want?
Why wouldn't we like her simply because she's human and falls in love?
 

mastershake

Registered
Joined
Aug 15, 2006
Messages
11
Reaction score
2
A few books i have read, the writer puts his or her morols into the story. Its useually distracting for me when its out of the blue and has nothing to do with whats going on wit the rest of the plot.

Its not somethign to shy away from or over do. Smoking and gun control seem to be two of the bigger drops writers put into their work these days. It swings both ways, too pro or con of anything distracts me from the plot.

If the storyline is good your MC could toss wrenches out her car window at nightborhood cats, and id still read it.

MS
 

AndiB

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
325
Reaction score
48
Location
I'm a child of the corn
I can't help but think of Scarlett O'hara. She was in love with a man that wasn't her husband and yet most who read the book managed to root for her even though she was selfish, spiteful, and vain. In fact, readers liked her inspite of herself.

Humans are flawed. I for one, am tired of watching perfect people take center stage in books these days. I like to see the flaws of characters and love them for their strengths as well as their weaknesses.

Just my two cents.
 

Kudra

Back and on track
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
1,765
Reaction score
384
Location
London
Website
www.TheInternationalFreelancer.com
This reminds me of the book How to be Good, by Nick Hornby, where the protagonist has an affair. Throughout the book, she keeps saying, "I'm a doctor! I'm a good person!" obviously trying to convince herself just as much as anyone else. It's very effective. And very funny.
 

maestrowork

Fear the Death Ray
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
43,746
Reaction score
8,654
Location
Los Angeles
Website
www.amazon.com
This reminds me of the book How to be Good, by Nick Hornby, where the protagonist has an affair. Throughout the book, she keeps saying, "I'm a doctor! I'm a good person!" obviously trying to convince herself just as much as anyone else. It's very effective. And very funny.

Yup. But to be honest, I don't like the book that much -- I don't think Nick Horby did the voice justice. Maybe because I knew he wrote it... I just kept thinking the narrator didn't sound like the woman. I didn't dislike the character because of her affair, but because of her self-absorption.
 

EriRae

:P
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
1,481
Reaction score
1,358
Location
The State of Marriage Equality.
Thanks. It happened to me. I was married for six years and fell in love with someone else. I didn't want to, but I did. Fast forward seven years, I'm happily remarried and so is my ex-husband. Ironically I am best friends with my ex-husbands wife, and the four of us get together a few times a month and we all hang out (our kids are friends too).

I went through hell when I left my ex-husband b/c he wasn't a 'bad' person. As my family pointed out over and over, he didn't hit me and wasn't abusive in any way. It's hard to explain that you're just married to your best friend, but you don't feel the husband/wife love.

I think you've been hard on yourself about this, just as your family was hard on you, and now you're afraid that your readers will feel the same way. Most readers aren't as vested in characters as they are in family (until the fourth or fifth book in the series...lol). They're much more likely to forgive a character of murder than the daughter they raised to do the right thing. Don't be so hard on yourself. Everything worked out for you, and it will for your character, too. Don't worry about what anyone else thinks.
 

MonaLeigh

Wasting time
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 10, 2006
Messages
665
Reaction score
65
Location
NY
perhaps you're having second thoughts writing this particular story, not because you're afraid the main character won't be sympathetic but because the novel so closely mirrors your own experience...that you're afraid any resistance to the main character will reflect on you and your past choices?

You're right, b/c when I started this novel my idea was to prove that people do leave a marriage even there isn't a glaring problem that others see. My family was so against me, and I lost almost all of my/our friends when I left. I guess part of me wants to prove that this does happen. But I know it's silly to try to prove anything through fiction.
 

KTC

Stand in the Place Where You Live
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
29,138
Reaction score
8,564
Location
Toronto
Website
ktcraig.com
Kill the critic. There are plenty of characters that do that and still manage to be likable. We all have faults...as long as you show other attributes that are endearing.

I'm thinking right now of Robert Weirsema's BEFORE I WAKE. One of his main characters was this guy who left his wife for a woman at the office. You should not like this guy...especially since this is all going on in the middle of a disastrous situation with the man's little girl...but you like him. You can make characters likable even if they have these flaws that are unacceptable. Nobody's perfect. Sometimes characters are likeable because of their flaws. Go for it...

ETA: Besides...who says falling in love outside of marriage is bad? Your heart speaks...you should listen to it. One life to live.
 

Kaytie

Registered
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
Messages
47
Reaction score
8
Location
in my head
Website
www.kaytie.net
You're right, b/c when I started this novel my idea was to prove that people do leave a marriage even there isn't a glaring problem that others see. My family was so against me, and I lost almost all of my/our friends when I left. I guess part of me wants to prove that this does happen. But I know it's silly to try to prove anything through fiction.

From a story perspective, the situation is rife with conflict that could be interesting for a reader. I would believe that most married people could relate to the situation of being attracted to a person other than the spouse, whether they acted upon it or not, whether it was really love or not.

And everyone is giving you really good input about how they'd react to such a character.

Now you just have to decide whether this is the story you want to put out there. No matter how you write it, not everyone will be convinced because that's the nature of fiction--people disagree with stories all the time. If I were you, I'd ask myself this question:

"If I put this story out there, can I handle it if readers reject it?"

You have to be able to say "yes" to that question in order to write that story. Any story, really, but I'd say in this case, since you're so close to the main character, you'd need to be okay with it in a way other stories don't demand of writers.




Or, you could write the memoir instead. :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.