Should I Make it More Commercial?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lisamer

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 13, 2005
Messages
306
Reaction score
20
Location
Summit County, CO.
My full MS is being looked at by a few publishers, but in the event of rejection, I was wondering if I should revise the plot.

The current premise:

On September 11, physical therapist Mariel Savan Leeds loses her father, former 10th Mountain Division member Aaron Savan. In the years that follow, she suffers from depression and survivor's guilt, only to come out of it when she visits Colorado, where her father trained as a member of the 10th Mountain Division.

When her husband, Jonathan Leeds sees a physical therapy clinic for sale in Breckenridge, he buys it for his wife. Caveat: he will stay in NYC until they know that the clinic will be profitable. Once in CO., Mariel's loneliness and insecurity makes her vulnerable to the attentions of ski in structor David La Vecchia. You can read more plot details here:

http://www.freewebs.com/skinovelist/

In the original manuscript, Mariel is in her 40s. I'm thinking of making her in her 30s. Jonathan would not be her husband. Instead, he'd be a Wall Street banker who decides to bankroll her PT clinic, in hopes that she'd agree to marry him.

David La Vecchia would be a Desert Storm veteran who is involved with the Wounded Warrior's program. (see website link for details) He is also invlolved in making a film about the 10th Mountain Division. He asks Mariel for help in this project.

The Kate character (see website link) stays the same.

In the original, the conflict arises from Mariel's doubts about the strength of her marriage. Jonathan has been known for his infidelity, and now that they are living in different palces, she does not know if she can trust him. Her own attraction to someone else confirms her doubts about the marriage.

In the proposed re-write, Mariel does not want to marry Jonathan because she thinks he will be unfaithful. David is attracted to Mariel, but does not want to mess up her relationship with Jonathan. He is also dealing with his own post traumatic stress disorder from his time spent in Iraq.

I though about making him a disabled vet, but that semed to take things too far.

So, whadda ya' think?

Should I sell out?

Of course, if the original sells, the question is academic.

Thanks!
 

jhtatroe

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 15, 2007
Messages
395
Reaction score
104
Location
Colorado
Website
www.jennifertatroe.com
I would think this kind of decision would be dependent ont he feedback you get from the publishers. If they're rejecting you because they don't feel the plot is commercial enough, sure, I guess you could consider it. If not, why go to all that work, especially if you consider it selling out?

I do have a question about the 10th Mountain Division connection, though. I'm in my 30s and my grandfather was in the 10th Mountain Division. It was deactivated in the late 40s and not reactivated until the mid-80s. For my father to have been in the 10th Mountain, he would have had to have been in his 40s or 50s by the time he had me and his 80s by 9/11. Is that going to work for your story?
 

NeuroFizz

The grad students did it
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 18, 2005
Messages
9,493
Reaction score
4,283
Location
Coastal North Carolina
It matters less what your characters do (or did)--it matters more how you build them and make them interesting through what they do for the reader. Concentrate on that and you have good characterization. In other words, don't try to pull too much of your characterization from the "what they've done, and what they do for a living" categories. Pull it from what they are doing in your story. If their actions in the story are better suited by a specific occupation, then go with that, but sometimes uniqueness comes from the unexpected, the unfamiliar, and certainly from somewhere other than cliches and backgrounds of convenience.
 

Scrawler

Bored fanatic
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
662
Reaction score
62
Location
Los Angeles
I like your new ideas.
My opinion: As it is, it's ok, but it wouldn't really grab my attention. If I understand the idea correctly, Mariel's basic conflicts are that she feels bad that her dad was killed, and then lonely because her husband is away.

The new ideas give it more substance, more areas for twists and turns, suspense, tension. I wouldn't call this selling out. I'd call it further developing the characters and plot.
 

EriRae

:P
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
1,481
Reaction score
1,358
Location
The State of Marriage Equality.
People do get married in their 30's (and before). You could still have the marriage with the question of infidelity. Some men cheat before the honeymoon is over. I agree that the new ideas give the story more areas for twists and turns.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.