I need to improve prologue..someone help?

Status
Not open for further replies.

SiverMask

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 26, 2005
Messages
77
Reaction score
3
Hi, can someone help me out here? I need to improve this. Sentence structure and wording. Is it boring? By the way I cant seem to post under Share Your Work. If anyone knows how, please let me know.

The Meet was a yearly meeting the King Tyzlan Lyzar Rubithos sar Denath of Venth of the Ezzek Empire has with his high lords, the wealthy merchants and overlords, who arrive in Athel to seek hearing and address with their king. It was held in the part of the year just when the cool, relaxing spring was replaced by the blistering scorch of summer. Thus it was so that on this day, only a few days into summer, the local market thronged with a large crowd of said people, gathered to attend said meeting. Dressed in their rich and superfluous robes, with a large purse hung ostentatiously by their waist, they were easy to spot, and ripe for the picking.

Tarya moved amongst the bustling crowd. She walked at a leisurely pace, a finger playing the seams of her dress, her eyes seeming to wander mindlessly on the goods the vendors peddled. But her mind was alert, calculative and on other things aside from the pleasant stocks the vendors had specially hoarded for this time of the year. The target: A young lord dressed in expensive, pale cream robes, his thin, slender fingers bedecked with humongous-jeweled rings. However, it was the heavy pouch that hung from his waist that Tarya eyed. From the smooth bend of the lord’s cheek, it was unlikely that he had seen a day’s growth of beard. Still, he managed to walk with the imperious swagger of a man who knew he had it all. A duke’s son, Tarya figured.

Her eyes skipped to the guards mounted on their horses, some distance away by the fruit stall. The guards were heavily armored, a hand on the scabbard of their swords. They sat with their backs straight, their eyes moving vigilantly around the market. They, like her, were on the prowl. It was well known that the king disliked thieves, especially those who stole from his rich servants and lords. The law had been passed that anyone caught stealing in the capital city of Athel would be whipped and then hung in the city’s quadrangle, without water or food until the life left their bodies and they were naught but bones. But that was nothing compared to the king’s latest sadistic punishment. Caught offenders were amputated at the arms and then hung up at the city gates until they bled to their deaths. The horrific way of death was enough of a deterrent for many.
However, for some others impoverished their entire lives, living in the filthy, decrepit sections of the city, with elderly mothers and children dying from lack of food, they were left with little choice but to continue the risky business of pinching food or money, even with the knowledge of the ghastly consequences.

It was mostly such who were caught.

But Tarya was not such. Dressed in a modest dress, she could almost have been a daughter of a blacksmith or even of a well-to-do merchant. Her target was within reach by now. Making sure the guards’ gazes were not on her, she reached out with one hand and expertly unhooked the pouch from the lord’s waist without his notice. She began to ease away gently when a running boy crashed into her. Flailing to regain her balance, the pouch fell loose from her hand, hurtled towards the ground and hit the floor with a loud chink.

Silver pensas and gold innaks spilled out and began its ominous dance on the paved ground.

Tarya looked up, wide-eyed. The young lord’s face had turned into a red tomato hue and then an inevitable bellow of, “Thief!” exploded from his lungs.

Tarya ran for her life.
 

JoNightshade

has finally arrived
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
7,153
Reaction score
4,140
Website
www.ramseyhootman.com
Posting in SYW is the same as posting here. If you're unable to get into Share Your Work, the password is Vista.
 

herdon

What's up?
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
78
Website
ipad.about.com
I only gave it a skim, but the first thing I'd say is lose the first paragraph completely. It's the first thing your reader is going to read so it should be something that pulls them into the story.
 

Gillhoughly

Grumpy writer and editor
Absolute Sage
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
5,363
Reaction score
1,763
Location
Getting blitzed at Gillhoughly's Reef, Haleakaloha
I find most prologues, unless they're written by Professor Tolkein, are 100% improved by deleting them entirely.


icon10.gif
 

Bufty

Where have the last ten years gone?
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 9, 2005
Messages
16,767
Reaction score
4,662
Location
Scotland
Hi Ho Siver,

Prologue and Chapter issue apart, if you know the sentence structure and wording need to be improved then you are more than half-way there. Can't see that these are really your main problem, though.


Is it boring? W-ell, I'm not sure I would wish to read a whole 300 pages of this style. It is a tad wordy to my eye and it does go on and on before anything happens.

And starting with a King's name that uses almost every letter of the alphabet twice isn't exactly going to encourage either me or the populace to cheer and shout his name, or come up with snappy T-shirt slogans, is it?

KTLRsDoVotEE - We love thee.

:welcome: Your profile is empty but you must have a sense of humour. :Hug2:
 
Last edited:

FennelGiraffe

It's green they say
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
445
Location
San Antonio
Yes, you have some sentence structure problems (that first sentence is atrocious). But you also have a serious infodump problem. That's what makes it boring.

I usually try to resist the temptation to rewrite someone else's work, because it should be your words, not mine. But in this case I can't really see any other way to explain. If I may offer this alternative:

Tarya moved amongst the bustling crowd of Athel market. She walked at a leisurely pace, a finger playing the seams of her dress, her eyes seeming to wander mindlessly on the goods the vendors peddled. But her mind was alert, calculative and on other things aside from the pleasant stocks the vendors had specially hoarded for this time of the year King Tyzlan's yearly Meet. But her mind was alert, searching for a likely target. There: A young lord, with the smooth cheeks of a youth, dressed in expensive, pale cream robes, his thin, slender fingers bedecked with humongous-jeweled rings.

Tarya eyed the heavy pouch that hung from at his waist. Making sure the guards’ gazes were not on her, she reached out with one hand and expertly unhooked the pouch from the lord’s waist without his notice. She began to eased away gently when only to stumble as a running boy crashed into her. Flailing to regain her balance, the pouch fell loose from her hand, hurtled towards the ground and hit the floor with a loud chink.

Silver pensas and gold innaks spilled out and began its an ominous dance on the paved ground.

Tarya looked up, wide-eyed. The young lord’s face had turned into a red tomato hue and then an inevitable bellow of, “Thief!” exploded from his lungs.

Tarya ran for her life.
There is still ample room for improvement; I mostly just cut out the infodump and bridged over the gaps. Some of it was information we don't need at all; some of it should wait until we want to know it.
 

SiverMask

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 26, 2005
Messages
77
Reaction score
3
Okay. I loved your constructive criticism. I'll try to mix and match what I have so far...Mind seeing the next chapter? I don't know much about the info dump thing, but everytime I read through fantasy novels in the bookstore, they seem to have more info dumps than I do. So I tried to do it their style. But I'll definitely take your advices. I like FennelGirraffe's one. I would probably adopt that style...

Chapter 1

Grim darkness cloaked the decrepit houses. What little illumination in the area came only from randomly situated large cans, in which small fires had been started with whatever bits and pieces that could be found. Disheveled, thinly clothed men and women huddled together around these cans to keep warm. Too weak with cold and hunger, they paid no heed as a figure scurried past them, rounded a corner and disappeared into the darker alleyway.

The figure flattened herself to the grimy, algid walls after another few turns and dared a peek around the next corner. Rats scampered across the lane, littered with broken bottles and waste. An acrid stench of urine, dung and rotten food wafted to greet her nostrils but the street was otherwise empty. Relieved, she darted further down until finally, upon reaching an aged, blackened wooden door, she stopped and fumbled clumsily for the key.

The door swung open suddenly. Surprised, she jumped.

Fenril, Tarya’s accomplice, stood at the doorway. “You scared me!”

He stepped back to allow her in, and she quickly shut the door. The room was dark, save for a dull orange glow given off by two stubs of wax by the grime-smeared windows. It was a place secured by Tarya for only the purpose of meeting up after each day’s work to split the earnings. With the increased surveillance in the markets, she was afraid that a guard could follow and capture them.

Fenril was the first to speak. “You were caught.”

“I was almost caught,” she immediately corrected.

“Almost?” Fenril grinned.

Oh, what she would give to box that mocking set of teeth out. She had a million other comebacks to articulate, but stopped short when she suddenly realized she had been whispering. Her nerves were still jumping from her close brush with the guards.

Fenril didn’t notice. He pulled out a wooden chair, one of the few furniture in the dingy room, and settled himself quite comfortably onto it. The other sparse furniture available in the room was just a rocky table and a rotting wooden cupboard. “You were caught,” he began to explain, “just fortunate to escape.” His grin widened, if that were possible. “But you should have seen the look on your face then.” He laughed aloud.

Tarya felt the heat in her cheeks rise. Not from embarrassment, but anger. She could never get embarrassed in front of Fenril, because the man had to be the biggest walking embarrassment in the entire history of the Ezzek Empire. But for Vaile, the teacher who had adopted her and taught her all the tricks of the trade, she certainly wouldn’t have given one whit about him.

“Stop laughing,” she snapped at his grating laughter. “Don’t you know the danger I face? That man was probably some high lord’s son.” She had to get out of Athel fast.

She didn’t realize that she had spoken the last thought aloud until Fenril exclaimed, “You can’t just leave!”

“Of course I can,” she retorted irritably.

“What about me?” Reality had finally sunk into the man’s dense head.

“Humph, that’s nothing to do with me.”

Fenril jumped out of his chair. “Of course I have everything to do with you! Don’t forget what my father said to you.”

“Fenril,” she replied, disgusted, “You’re twenty and five, five years older and supposedly wiser than me. Surely you can take care of yourself.”

“But my father told you to take care of me before he passed on!” he insisted. See why she thought he was the biggest walking embarrassment in the whole of Ezzek history? His own father didn’t believe he could take care of himself. And he had the gall to admit to it.

“And Big Sister Tarya has taken care of you for five years. Now that she is in trouble, you can take care of yourself,” she told him with sarcastic, saccharine sweetness.

He pointed at her with an accusing finger. “You ungrateful wench! I just knew Father should have never bothered with you. I told him so! If it weren’t for you, Father might have put more effort in teaching me and—”

Tarya interrupted, her temper ablaze, she spoke icily. “Don’t put the blame on me for your own laziness. You never bothered to learn. It was Vaile who took me in. I owe your father, but I certainly owe you nothing.”

With that said, she made for the door to leave.

He quickly stopped her with a hand on a shoulder. “Oh, come on,” he said apologetically, quickly changing tact as he realized that his only source of income was going to walk out on him. “I’m sorry. I’m sorry. Please stay, all right? Just do the last one, and I promise I won’t ask anymore from you.”

That did nothing to alleviate Tarya’s anger. She brushed his arm from her shoulder and asked acerbically, “The last time?”

He nodded, looking at her pleadingly.

“Wasn’t that what you said the last time? In fact,” she poked at his chest, “You just said that this time. Which was why I went out and tried to steal from that man.”

“Aw, come on, Tarya. My father treated you like his own daughter.”

“No,” she told him resolutely. “It’s too dangerous. I told you a long time ago that this is getting too dangerous. And it’s my head on the line, not yours.”

“Come on, you say it as though I don’t help out.”

“You just but have to distract the guards’ attention. I’m the one who does the dirty work. The one who shall hang from the city gates if caught.”

“Tarya,” he said, almost whining now.

“Couldn’t you go out and earn your own living?” she said stubbornly.

“You know I’m no good at stealing.”

“Then find other types of work. Go and learn a trade. Be a baker or a blacksmith.”

“Aw, come on. Those will take years to learn. Besides, I’m no good at these types of work either.”

Tarya snorted. “Yes, I can believe that you’re a good-for-nothing.”

He didn’t even try to deny it. “Say you’ll stay.”

It was always at such times that Tarya wondered how a sturdy man like Vaile could have fathered a son like Fenril. He was lazy, stupid and grossly embarrassing, nothing like the teacher whom she loved and respected. “Fenril, my life is in danger. The guards would be on the lookout for me and I could be hanging in the quadrangle with my limbs missing tomorrow if I don’t get out of this city.”

He shook his head. “You can hide a while. In a few weeks, it would be safe once more.”

“For the life of Earth, Fenril!” Tarya exclaimed, frustrated. “Would you use your addled brain for once and think? The King’s favorite sport is killing thieves like us. The guards would be on the hunt. Do you truly believe that they will leave me alone if I remain in this city? The very city where the mad King lives? If you think that, you’re madder than he is!”

He still looked confused so Tarya decided to spell it out clearly for him. “By tomorrow, my face could be on posters all over the city with a prize on my head.”

Understanding finally dawned in his eyes. “Oh.”

“I’m leaving.” And she turned and left.

---------------

In the darkness, Tarya gathered her belongings into a cloth sack. She had been planning to leave Athel for some time. The city was too dangerous to remain. Except for her sense of obligation towards Vaile to upkeep the promise she’d made, she wouldn’t have stayed as long as she had.

But times had changed since she’d made her promise to Vaile. A year after Vaile’s burial, King Denaris died and the Crown Prince took over the throne. The story went that an unwitting pickpocket had stolen from a delegate of the Reekans that attended the prince’s coronation. Naturally, the newly crowned king offered them justice. Justice was served in an arena with thousands of spectators. There, the poor, unwitting fellow was flogged cruelly, split at the stomach so that his internal organs spilled out and finally hanged at the city gates until the body became but a carcass of bones. Apparently, the King enjoyed the spectacle so much, he made it a monthly affair. Thieves and pickpockets like herself had been hard-hit with the new king’s implemented laws and punishments. The general public was of course elated with the king’s stand on thievery. As for the Reekan delegate, he was killed in battle barely a year later by one of Ezzek’s own soldiers, after the king decided he wanted the northern lands to add to his already vast empire.

As to all stories, there was another side to it. The other story went that the King was a bloodthirsty sadist who had murdered his own father with sorcery to attain the throne. The demons that had assisted in his father’s murder naturally wanted payment for the help, which was why the King had to resort to such drastic punishments to satisfy the demons. The numerous wars that were fought since the king’s ascension to the throne was also yet another bid to spill more blood for the demons’ appetites. Of course, the latter story was only talked about amongst the people secretively and privately. No one wanted to go against the demon-possessed king and his demons.

Demon-possessed or not, as far as Tarya was concerned, the new king had been nothing good. But before his reign, life had been good. So good. Vaile had taught her, “Never take more than necessary. And only steal from the rich. Even thieves have a set of code of honor.” Tarya followed that code for all but a few months after Vaile’s death, before she tired of Fenril’s constant harassing that she went out and stole more often. In those days, money flowed freely. Twenty pouches taken in a day were common. Tarya had to admit that greed had touched her. No longer did she have to live thriftily as Vaile had taught her, but she would spend on luxurious meals and ………clothes. The first dress that Tarya put on came only when she reached sixteen. The dress fitted her curves, showing off a figure she never even knew she had. Looking at herself in a mirror she’d purchased, vanity waved and introduced itself to her. No longer did she wear passed-me-down clothes from Fenril whenever she marketed. Instead, dresses and ribbons replaced the baggy and manly clothes. She was thrilled and in love with her newfound self. On occasions, she even wore the feminine clothes when she went out to steal. Who would expect a well-dressed woman a thief?

Today had been such an occasion and this newfound self would apparently be the death of her. The feminine clothes did nothing to hide her face. The cap that she wore atop her head when she went out and stole were replaced with elaborate hairclips that certainly did nothing for disguise. Stupid, stupid, she scolded herself as she packed. How could she have so quickly thrown aside the lessons taught by Vaile?

Suddenly, a scene came back vividly to her. She was just seven. Her forehead was furrowed, as she concentrated on taking an orange from the center of a pile of fruits. She had to ensure that the pile didn’t topple over in the process.

“You have to be nimble and swift,” Vaile told her. “And patient. Fingers swift, but nimble.” Then he snatched the orange so quickly with one hand, she didn’t catch the motion. But the pile of fruits didn’t topple. He passed her the orange, and she took it with her small fingers. “It’d be the same when you steal. Remember the four most important lessons, Tarya. Swift but nimble, vigilant and astute.”

Now, the lesson echoed in her mind. But it was too late.

After the new king took over, the excessive lifestyles Tarya and Fenril were used to soon declined. The guards were too vigilant. Moves were difficult to make and it was overall too taxing and nerve wrecking. How many times had she made a move when the word, “Thief!” was shouted? Each time, she was certain she was caught before the real offender was lassoed in and whipped by the guards .The next day, the market would be abuzz with news of the newly hung culprit.

Tying a tight knot to form a bag around her possessions, she was ready to go. She had changed into her disguise of the old—a man’s clothing of shirt and breeches so that she looked nothing like a woman, but more of a boy. A worn out cap two shades paler than her own brown hair sat atop her head, her long hair tucked underneath it. This time, lesson learnt, she packed only men’s clothing. She was going to have to pretend to be a man if she hoped to be able to survive this ordeal. Only one last thing remained. Over the years, especially the year of the plenty between Vaile’s death and the new king’s reign, she had managed to accumulate some money and precious jewels. The funds would enable her to set up a shop and acquire a decent place to live in, in whatever town or city she did finally decide to settle down.

The money was kept inside a wall behind a small side table by her bed. She always termed the hiding place ‘her getaway funds’ . Now, she crept to it for the last time, not to add but to remove its contents. She squatted, her hand dislodging a brick of the wall behind which all her savings lay, when the door of her room crashed open suddenly.

She whipped her head around. The silhouettes of two city guards were framed in the doorway. Before she could even comprehend her situation, spears were thrust in her direction and more guards had poured into the room.

Then Fenril was suddenly there, amidst the heavily armored guards.

One of them, a stout man with thin lips, spoke, “Is that she?”

Fenril replied, “Yes.”
 

Gillhoughly

Grumpy writer and editor
Absolute Sage
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
5,363
Reaction score
1,763
Location
Getting blitzed at Gillhoughly's Reef, Haleakaloha
You need to put all this in the "Share Your Work" thread.

Read the Welcome Newbie and FAQ threads for the rules on this, or look up how to do it.

Or contact a Moderator and ask if they will shift it for you.

Read the rules for "Share Your Work."

The Novels thread is not for critiques.
 

FennelGiraffe

It's green they say
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
445
Location
San Antonio
You need to put all this in the "Share Your Work" thread.

Yes, you should probably ask a moderator to move this whole thread.

I don't know much about the info dump thing, but everytime I read through fantasy novels in the bookstore, they seem to have more info dumps than I do. So I tried to do it their style. But I'll definitely take your advices. I like FennelGirraffe's one. I would probably adopt that style...

Thank you :) Glad you liked it.

Fantasy, science fiction, and historical novels usually require a much greater amount of background information than other genres. And you're right, some do get published with huge lumps of indigestible exposition in the first few pages. But that falls into the same category as, "Would you jump off a cliff just because everyone else was doing it?" Even though some authors get away with it, it's not the best choice.

I don't hang around historical writers much, but every SF/F writers' group, board, forum, blog, etc., I've ever seen has addressed infodumps. That's because handling that much background information is difficult. So look around; I know there are numerous discussions here at AW (check the Uncle Jim thread), as well as elsewhere. I can give an overview, though.
  • Large lumps of exposition ("infodumps") tend to make the reader's eyes glaze over. If you're lucky, he'll merely do a fast skim until the next line of dialog. If not, he'll decide it's a good time to see what's on TV. Either way, he'll have no idea what it said.
  • I hope I don't even need to mention the dreaded "As you know, Bob" (AYKB). Never, ever, have characters stand around telling each other things they already know. This is one reason so many SF/F stories make their protag a stranger or outsider. A stranger has to ask for explanations of things that are familiar, every day occurances to the locals.
  • There's a type of POV violation that is related to AYKB. It occurs when you are in a 1st or limited 3rd POV and the narrative goes into great detail about the surroundings, yet the location is one that is very familiar to the viewpoint character. That which is familiar is invisible. Do you notice the color of your drapes every time you walk through your living room? OK, OK, sometimes there's a reason to notice a particular detail. And of course, in a familiar setting, we notice changes.
  • Resist the temptation to describe everything you know about your world. Only 1/10 of the details should actually be mentioned. Does that mean you can skip 9/10 of the worldbuilding? No, not at all. The hidden 9/10 supports and informs the visible 1/10. It makes your world richer, gives it depth. You need to know it; the reader doesn't.
  • Sprinkle background information lightly through the text, a little at a time. Don't tell the reader anything she doesn't already want to know. How do you recognize when the reader is going to want to know something? Good question. If you figure it out, will you explain it to me?
  • SF/F readers have a high tolerance for unresolved questions. Most enjoy the frisson of curiousity upon encountering an unfamiliar name. It's a promise of wonders yet to unfold. Can it be overdone? Is it possible to explain too little? Sure. The reader needs some idea of what's going on. How many questions can you leave unresolved before the reader gets confused? How long can you leave one unresolved before the reader forgets what the question was? That's one of the things you want your beta readers to tell you.
I'm going to repost my version from earlier, but this time explain the choices I made with your background information. I didn't think all this through at the time. It was just what felt right; now I'm trying to figure out why it felt right.

Tarya (There are other good ways to begin, but identifying the protag is a reliable way.) moved amongst the bustling crowd of Athel market (I'm mentioning Athel, without identifying it as the name of the city. Still, using the name to modify market hints at that possiblity, while leaving other interpretations open as well. In a little while, it should be mentioned again, confirming that it is the name of the city. It's not entirely clear in your opening sentence, but I'm guessing that Venth is the name of the kingdom, and the kingdom is part of the Ezzek Empire. If so, we don't need to know that now. It can be mentioned whenever we do.). She walked at a leisurely pace, a finger playing the seams of her dress, her eyes seeming to wander mindlessly on the goods the vendors had hoarded for King Tyzlan's yearly Meet (This culture has a king, and his name is Tyzlan. I very much doubt people go around calling him King Tyzlan Lyzar Rubithos sar Denath in everyday conversation. If we ever need to know his full name, we can learn it later. We don't know exactly what a Meet is yet, but we do know it happens annually. Fairly predictably as well, since the vendors are able to plan ahead for it. We know the Meet is associated with the king in some way. And we know the vendors find it worthwhile to offer all their best merchandise during the Meet, which implies either many customers or wealthy customers. Lots of juicy tidbits there, most of them begging for further elaboration.) But her mind was alert, searching for a likely target. There: A young lord, with the smooth cheeks of a youth, dressed in pale cream robes, his slender fingers bedecked with jeweled rings (Pale cream robes don't explicity describe wealth, but they imply it in a subtle way, which is reinforced by the rest of the description. I cut all of your other information about the wealthy visitors come to town for the Meet. Some of it may have been worth keeping for atmosphere if this scene occured later in the book. But I felt it bogged things down too much in an opening scene. That's just me, though. Others may disagree.).

Tarya eyed the heavy pouch at
his waist. Making sure the guards’ gazes (I may have lost a little here by not identifying these as city or royal guards, rather than the young lord's personal guards. But I couldn't find a graceful way to say so. Her desire to avoid capture doesn't need any explanation, so I cut the gruesome description of how thieves were punished. That the penalty is execution raises the stakes, though, so that much does need to be told, although it could wait until she is on the run.) were not on her, she reached out with one hand and expertly unhooked the pouch without his notice. She eased away gently only to stumble as a running boy crashed into her. Flailing to regain her balance, the pouch fell loose from her hand, hurtled towards the ground and hit the floor with a loud chink.
 

Red Robin

Veni Vidi Scripsi
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 10, 2007
Messages
120
Reaction score
18
Location
Toronto, Canada
There is lots of good advice in this thread, so I'll just skip to the thorn in my thumb-

King Tyzlan Lyzar Rubithos sar Denath of Venth of the Ezzek Empire

Ouch.

I'd put the novel back on the shelf if I saw this, but I'm a little crazy with names.

Tyzlan Lyzar? Using a Y and Z just sounds like novelty but twice?

Sar sounds like it is a preposition. Is it? Why the 'of' then. Is he from two places? Why isn't 'of' in a made up language (or 'sar' in English)

Denath of Venath thoundth like you're lithping Denith the Menath.

Ezzek - You've use up your 'Z' quota for the whole book.

Some other problems-

The Meet was a yearly meeting

Dressed in a modest dress

You see the problems here.

It was well known that the king disliked thieves
Few do, so why mention it.

You've already changed much of this, but I think these are the problems.

-Exotic sounding names aren't interesting
-Try not to repeat words in a redundant fashion
-Try to show not tell

As if I'm a pro :) But that is what caught my eye.

Also, the name Athel is used by Games Workshop in their Warhammer Game. It doesn't seem to be copyrighted by them, which makes me worry because they try to copyright everything. Makes me believe the word has been used elsewhere. That might not matter.... these people aren't wood elfy are they?

Hope some of this helped
 

FennelGiraffe

It's green they say
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
445
Location
San Antonio
There is lots of good advice in this thread, so I'll just skip to the thorn in my thumb-

King Tyzlan Lyzar Rubithos sar Denath of Venth of the Ezzek Empire

Ouch.

I'd put the novel back on the shelf if I saw this, but I'm a little crazy with names.

Tyzlan Lyzar? Using a Y and Z just sounds like novelty but twice?

Sar sounds like it is a preposition. Is it? Why the 'of' then. Is he from two places? Why isn't 'of' in a made up language (or 'sar' in English)

Denath of Venath thoundth like you're lithping Denith the Menath.

I'm not at all sure whether this is what SiverMask intended, but I parsed it as
  • The king's name is Tyzlan Lyzar Rubithos sar Denath
  • sar is "son of" or "of the clan of" or something like that
  • He is king of Venth
  • Venth is a kingdom in the Ezzek Empire
Whether my interpretation is right or wrong, though, I agree that is an atrocious string of names. It would be awkward even if the parts were familiar, say Angus Ewen Connall mac Donald of Scotland of the British Empire. In the first line of a fantasy, though, where we have no idea what any of the parts refer to, it's just a confusing mess.

I also keep wanting to turn Venth into Venath when I see it next to Denath.

I'm not so much bothered by the Ys and Zs, though. At least the names are nicely pronounceable, and there aren't any gratuitous apostrophes. I'm willing to accept that a fantasy language might make more extensive use of those letters than English does. And it does make Tyzlan and Lyzar look like they belong to the same language.
 

herdon

What's up?
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
78
Website
ipad.about.com
I agree, this should go in share your work. I glanced through the chapter, though, and what stood out to me is that there wasn't any major passage of time between your prologue and chapter one. There should be a reason something is a prologue -- either a major passage of time, a PoV different than the rest of the novel, etc.

Personally, I don't usually write prologues. There are times when they can be handy to set up events in a certain way, though, so I wouldn't say never use them but there *should* be a reason for it. I don't see that here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.