PDA

View Full Version : Good news


William Blake Bradbury
11-21-2004, 02:02 PM
I should have my I-was-raped-and-turned-into-an-asexual-whose-sociopathic
-girlfriend-blackmailed-him-into-dating-him-with-threats-of-
suicide-then-attempted-suicide-with-a-butter-knife-after-
she-tried-to-rape-me-twice memoir essay finished in a couple of days. Hoorah!

One question: dialogue.

I can't remember exactly what was said, but I can remember snippets and the general gist of exchanges. I want to re-create dialogue, because three scenes in particular would be well-served with conversation. Unfortunately, I'm not sure of the rules for dialogue in memoir. I've written out 300 pages of exchanges, but I don't want to insert any of them (streamlined to the extreme, of course) and then have a publisher say, oh, that's all made up, poo to you, and send my precious ms. to the fire can.

So how does one handle a situation like this? Is there any way to write a conversation between two people, with a modicum of give and take, without quotation marks [shaking reader lightly by the shoulder with mock violence]? Is it? Is it? [as John Lithgow in histrionic mode] Why won't you answer me? Just kidding ;) Anyhoo, sorry I haven't been around for a while (as you guys quickly tuck the champagne bottles behind your bottles and nod in mock sympathy), but, with any luck, I got quite a ball of literary fire speeding your way.

Thank you, thank you, thank you all. You're stardust, glittering, shiny, shiny stardust!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:rollin (Lord, what've I been smoking?)

aka eraser
11-23-2004, 12:41 AM
William, your long hyphenated section requires side-to-side scrolling which many readers are loathe to do.

I'm going to edit it to break it into more digestible chunks. If it works it may lose it's impact slightly but could encourage more replies.

aka eraser
11-23-2004, 01:19 AM
I'll take a crack at what I *think* you're asking.

I think dialogue is near-essential in any kind of story, memoir or not. The fact that you need to re-create it as best you can, including "making up" bits of it, shouldn't be a deterrent to publication. Few writers are blessed with total recall and none I've ever heard of had a full-time, life-long secretary to record every conversation. :)

As to formatting it without the use of quotation marks; sure, if it works. It would be darned tricky I think but might be doable. If the reader gets confused as to who is who though, you're doomed.

Why not post a snippet in Share Your Work? Test-drive it there to see if folks can follow it.

Congrats on having it near-done. :)

William Blake Bradbury
11-24-2004, 08:31 AM
Dear Mr. Eraser:
Thank you very, very much for your gracious and informative reply.

Have a frank and productive day.

I'd say something clever, but I'm feeling a little wonky, right now.

Thanks again.