Need critique of intro.

janetbellinger

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
427
Location
Orangeville, Ontario
I'd really appreciate it if some of you would be so kind as to crititque the intro paragraphs of my new Children's novel, "The Spirit of Beautiful Joe."
It is a supernatural/fantasy/adventure. Thanks. I really want to make this one work for me.


Annabelle looked at the Pets For Sale section of the classified ads.
“Look mom, here’s some Basenji puppies for sale. They’re barkless.”
“Those puppies might not bark, but they would whine or howl or make some other noise to disturb the neighbors,” her mother replied.
“They wouldn’t make a loud noise.”
“.We’ve already been through all that. The neighbors would complain,” Mrs. Gray said.
“No, they wouldn’t. Everybody on the street has a dog.”
“That’s right, and they constantly complain about each other’s dog. You can’t have a dog and that’s final.”
Annabelle closed the newspaper and tried not to cry.
 
Last edited:

Sempine

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 9, 2007
Messages
409
Reaction score
34
Location
Bridgeport Al
I really like the first sentence.

The rest is fine--doesn't raise any negative flags. It doesn't do that much to draw someone in--

Perhaps something humorous about one of the dogs in the neighborhood?

Mac
 

JAlpha

Smilie Fanatic
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 16, 2005
Messages
1,998
Reaction score
809
Location
Usually at my computer
Website
diaryofaliteraryfictioneditor.blogspot.com
Quick thought . . . if you make the puppies free, it ups the conflict a bit, raises the reader's empathy for the child's perspective. An adult understands that the cost involved with owning pets only begins with the purchase price, but to a child a free puppy seems like a way to close the deal of whether or not they can have a dog, in addition to the plus of choosing a non barking breed.
 

LBW66

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 26, 2007
Messages
74
Reaction score
8
Location
Massachusetts
I have a basenji! If you're looking for words to describe them negatively they yodel and chortle. Also, need lots of exercise and room to run.

Overall sounds good, like typical dialogue between a kid wanting a dog and her mom!
 

janetbellinger

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
427
Location
Orangeville, Ontario
Thanks everybody. Actually this is the beginning of an adventure story. The family goes to Meaford, Ontario for a family vacation. While there, Annabelle visits Beautiful Joe Park. As she gazes at the statue of Beautiful Joe, his spirit comes to her and tells her he is sad because there is a puppy mill in the area, operating in the day as an apple orchard. Pups are being secretly kept in appalling conditions. Annabelle tries to involve the police but they can't find any evidence of a puppy mill operation. Beautiful Joe doesn't give up though and visits Annabelle again and again giving her more details. Annabelle learns that during the day, to avoid detection, the puppies are being kept in an old underground apple storage cellar. Annabelle sees the puppies during the night when she sneaks out to visit the apple orchard. She sees the puppies are suffering from being kept underground with inadequate ventilation. One night, she sneaks out of the house again to meet Beautiful Joe, who arrives in a milk wagon. (His cruel owner was a milk man.) Annabelle and Beautiful Joe succeed in freeing the captive puppies and dogs and carry them away, with the owners of the mill in hot pursuit. Beautiful Joe bares his teeth to scare the owners away and the horse rears up his legs at them and Beautiful Joe and Annabelle arrive safely at Annabelle's house with the dogs and pups. When her parents hear of the puppies plight and Annabelle's bravery they agree to let the dogs and pups stay overnight, untilt he SPCA opens in the morning. In the morning, after a night filled with howls and whines, Annabelles' parents agree to let her keep one pup. They say the noise of one pup will be nothing compared to the racket of the night before. Annabelle visits Beautiful Joe Park again, to thank Beautiful Joe, but only finds the statue. She strokes it as she says, "Thank you, Beautiful Joe." The she pats the pup she is carrying in her pocket, who she has named "The Spirit of Beautiful Joe."

In this story, I have attempted to drop my urge to make everything realistic. I know in real life the girl's parents would have a fit if she snuck away in the night and wouldn't let her go alone to the park etc etc but I am choosing to let this story be fiction. I can put a statement at the front of the book if I need to saying "Don't go sneaking off in the night."
 

Toothpaste

THE RECKLESS RESCUE is out now!
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 18, 2006
Messages
8,745
Reaction score
3,097
Location
Toronto, Canada
Website
www.adriennekress.com
MEAFORD!!! BEAUTIFUL JOE!!! Forgive the girly scream but I know them both sooooo well! I have a cottage up there and worked for the summer theatre festival for like 7 years! It is totally my second home and I know so many of the locals. Did you know that they published a little book on Beautiful Joe? And that Beautfiul Joe Park rocks for playing capture the flag!! That is just so cool!!!

Calm down, Toothpaste, calm down . . .
 

janetbellinger

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
427
Location
Orangeville, Ontario
My husband and I have a summer place there too. Maybe we'll run into each other in Beautiful Joe Park. I visited the park for the first time on the weekend. Of course I was very moved by all the memorial to working dogs. I must have read Beautiful Joe a hundred times when I was a child, so I remember it well.
 

moondance

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2006
Messages
348
Reaction score
37
Location
Oxford, England
Sounds fine to me - the only suggestion I would make is to call her 'Annabelle Gray' in the first line so that when you say 'her mother' and 'Mrs Gray' it's obvious they're the same person.