I shopped my first book to a few university presses and received rejections.
Then later I found the perfect publisher for the book and it's done well ever since.
I've spoken to an author who has written for university presses, and his experience has not been that great. His criticisms included poor communication between author and publisher, poor promotion, and poor distribution. Now, I don't know if these are universal among all university presses, but that was what he told me. He told me I was way better off for going with the publisher who published my book.
Many university press books are too scholarly for my tastes. I've picked up a few and I see looooong sentences and big words. IOW, by the time I got to the end of the sentence, I had forgotten what happened at the beginning of the sentence.
On the other hand, I own a university press book that I was quite satisfied with, and that was
this one about WKRP.
It's a good, well-written and well-researched book about the show. Now if you look at
amazon's listing, you can see a few negative customer comments, but those are beside my point. My complaints about it are awful cover and bad title, and that's what you might get with a university press.
And the reason Bowling Green University Press published it is because I believe the author was a professor there. It is my humble opinion that the book could have found a larger publisher.
allen