- Joined
- Nov 24, 2006
- Messages
- 213
- Reaction score
- 17
I keep thinking I won't be further surprised by what somebody decides just CAN'T be used in a script. But I've recently run into another of those shibboleths that people seem to get from film school or something: NO LYRICS. Does that seem weird to anybody else, or has anyone heard the rationale behind that one? I ran into two last month.
One was a script on the Zoetrope site, which features a background song over a montage--kind of "Miami Vice", then later a major set piece the leads listen to in a nightclub act. Original lyrics.
The review said: "Lyrics are getting in the way…nice and creative to have ideas in mind for that..but they just took up great portions of three pages" (Actually less than two pages--we've all seen how long a song is, right?)
Then I got back another script from Accolades (the screenplay contest, not the lying, swindling TV one that didn't award or announce prizes last time). The short notes from the typical loser contest reader focused on having "too many song lyrics" This one was a MUSICAL...contained several songs that advanced the plot. Actually, I was rather proud of the way the songs moved the action and characterization forward and considered it innovative. But all this guy saw was lyrics...so shocking in a musical.
Now what's the deal here? We're not supposed to write musicals, just non-musical scripts. That seems harsh when some of the top films of all time have been musicals. Did "Sound of Music" or "Rocky Horror" or "Little Shop of Horrors" have too many lyrics? Was sticking a song in the middle of "Butch Cassidy" or "Midnight Cowboy" or "Adventures in Babysitting" or "Ferris Beuler" a horrible idea? How many is too many? Why would lyrics waste space, when dialog doesn't?
In short, I don't get it. And since I like writing movies with songs in them, I'd LOVE to get some glimmer of what the hell the problem is?
One was a script on the Zoetrope site, which features a background song over a montage--kind of "Miami Vice", then later a major set piece the leads listen to in a nightclub act. Original lyrics.
The review said: "Lyrics are getting in the way…nice and creative to have ideas in mind for that..but they just took up great portions of three pages" (Actually less than two pages--we've all seen how long a song is, right?)
Then I got back another script from Accolades (the screenplay contest, not the lying, swindling TV one that didn't award or announce prizes last time). The short notes from the typical loser contest reader focused on having "too many song lyrics" This one was a MUSICAL...contained several songs that advanced the plot. Actually, I was rather proud of the way the songs moved the action and characterization forward and considered it innovative. But all this guy saw was lyrics...so shocking in a musical.
Now what's the deal here? We're not supposed to write musicals, just non-musical scripts. That seems harsh when some of the top films of all time have been musicals. Did "Sound of Music" or "Rocky Horror" or "Little Shop of Horrors" have too many lyrics? Was sticking a song in the middle of "Butch Cassidy" or "Midnight Cowboy" or "Adventures in Babysitting" or "Ferris Beuler" a horrible idea? How many is too many? Why would lyrics waste space, when dialog doesn't?
In short, I don't get it. And since I like writing movies with songs in them, I'd LOVE to get some glimmer of what the hell the problem is?