Authors in Real Life

Status
Not open for further replies.

Auroch

Banned
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
23
Reaction score
1
Location
Ottawa, Canada
Do you like to know who writes the novels you read?

Does it matter to you who they are, and what they believe?

Does a disappointing encounter with an author turn you off their work?


Personally I prefer not to know.

Like a lot of people, I tend to put writers up on a pedestal and imagine them as alpha-humans, eloquent and wise, who use their superior intellects to produce high quality writing. I imagine female writers as beautiful women, and males as professorial types. Crazy, I know. Disappointment usually comes thanks to Google and Wikipedia.

Discovering that Orson Scott Card once wrote some really bigoted and homophobic essays for a Mormon news service tarnished my impression of him as an author. Ironically, discovering that Chuck Palahniuk is flamboyantly homosexual spoiled 'Fight Club' for me, because it changed the novel from a male friendship story to something homoerotic. Brandon Sanderson and Dan Wells; I enjoyed a few of their novels before coming across 'Writing Excuses', only to see that they are both kind of dorks. Shallow as it might sound, seeing a photo of a female author who is obese, or a male who looks like Pee-Wee Herman somehow makes me less interested in reading their work.

So how about you?
 

areteus

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
2,636
Reaction score
183
Location
Manchester UK
This is something referred to in art philosophy as 'the intentional fallacy'. It's where you read something into a work of art based on the biography of the creator and in general terms it is considered a bad thing to do with respect to appreciating the art.

Of course, we all do it...

My main tendency is to try to work out the inspiration behind a piece of writing based on what I know of the author. For example, a few years ago we were driving on the roads between Oxford and London and came across a village called 'Husbands Bosworth' which is a character name from Bridget Jone's Dairy. No idea if Helen Fielding got the name from there but I reckon it is feasible that she could have driven along that road and spotted that name...

Another example... we were driving in Norfolk and noted endless fields of nothing but cabbage. At that point our minds wandered to Terry Practchett and the Sto Plains in Discworld which are described as 'endless fields of cabbage'.
 

Sophia

Self-Ban
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 10, 2007
Messages
4,925
Reaction score
2,410
Location
U.K.
Auroch, I'm locking this thread.

Your questions are fine for AW, and there have already been discussions of these topics here that you might be interested in looking over: search in Roundtable and Novels, particularly, if you'd like to see some of the responses. You're also free to start a new thread - one of those rooms would be a better fit for these questions than Bookclub, which is focused on books rather than authors.

Your personal answer in your post is not at all appropriate for AW. Our one major rule is Respect Your Fellow Writer, and your response breaks that.

Please familiarise yourself with the Newbie Guide and with the standards of this community before posting again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.