- Joined
- Aug 18, 2011
- Messages
- 330
- Reaction score
- 24
- Location
- Lincoln, CA
- Website
- www.ethereality.info
My book's two MC's are precocious 12~13 yr-olds. As I'm writing their dialogues and inner thoughts, I got concerned about how the average reader who's not familiar with precocious children might feel.
I was one of those precocious children myself, and I knew I was very different from other children. While I was still a child in many ways and liked many things that children my age liked, I also read literary fiction, listened to classical and jazz and avant-garde, and thought about things like duty and honor, existence, human nature, and my place in the world.
Because I was a precocious child, I can believe the extent to which a child can be precocious, but I've noticed a lot of people who aren't familiar with precocious children can't. For example, I've seen people commenting on things written by twelve/thirteen yr-olds online and refusing to believe someone so young could be so articulate and intelligent--to the point of calling bullshit and claiming that they were written by older teens or adults masquerading as children. And if it's videos of precocious children, some will make snarky remarks about how these children were brain-washed by their parents and forced to memorize speeches. I've seen comments like that made about Severn Suzuki's speech to the United Nations at age twelve (you can find it on youtube), or Jonathan Krohn's videos (also can be found on youtube) talking about his book. But why is it so hard to believe, when we have young authors like Nancy Yi Fan and Jamila Pegues and Sara Samarasinghe who are legitimate young authors?
My MC's are a lot like I was as a kid. They read literary fiction. They listen to sophisticated music. They think and talk about things that other children don't care about and probably can't really understand. (They are also both abused and bullied, so they find sanctuary in each other, feeling that they are soulmates.)
So my concern is whether I should just write my MC's as I see them, or should I make them more like normal children so they seem less exotic/unrealistic, or make them a bit older--around fifteen or so? Do you feel precocious children who are intelligent, articulate, soulful, and have high emotional intelligence are hard to believe in?
I was one of those precocious children myself, and I knew I was very different from other children. While I was still a child in many ways and liked many things that children my age liked, I also read literary fiction, listened to classical and jazz and avant-garde, and thought about things like duty and honor, existence, human nature, and my place in the world.
Because I was a precocious child, I can believe the extent to which a child can be precocious, but I've noticed a lot of people who aren't familiar with precocious children can't. For example, I've seen people commenting on things written by twelve/thirteen yr-olds online and refusing to believe someone so young could be so articulate and intelligent--to the point of calling bullshit and claiming that they were written by older teens or adults masquerading as children. And if it's videos of precocious children, some will make snarky remarks about how these children were brain-washed by their parents and forced to memorize speeches. I've seen comments like that made about Severn Suzuki's speech to the United Nations at age twelve (you can find it on youtube), or Jonathan Krohn's videos (also can be found on youtube) talking about his book. But why is it so hard to believe, when we have young authors like Nancy Yi Fan and Jamila Pegues and Sara Samarasinghe who are legitimate young authors?
My MC's are a lot like I was as a kid. They read literary fiction. They listen to sophisticated music. They think and talk about things that other children don't care about and probably can't really understand. (They are also both abused and bullied, so they find sanctuary in each other, feeling that they are soulmates.)
So my concern is whether I should just write my MC's as I see them, or should I make them more like normal children so they seem less exotic/unrealistic, or make them a bit older--around fifteen or so? Do you feel precocious children who are intelligent, articulate, soulful, and have high emotional intelligence are hard to believe in?
Last edited: