I'm going to read Jane Eyre again.

My personal preference is for...

  • Jane Eyre

    Votes: 17 54.8%
  • Wuthering Heights

    Votes: 14 45.2%

  • Total voters
    31
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
Yes I am. You heard me right.

I have the Vintage Classics edition, paperback, with the red spine, so it matches my copies of The Pickwick Papers, Pride & Prejudice and other classics.

And, of course, Wuthering Heights for dessert, as a literary palate-cleanser, if you will.

They say the world is full of cat people and dog people. I say AW is full of Jane Eyre people and Wuthering Heights people. No prizes for guessing which side I'm on.

So why am I reading this book again if I know I won't enjoy it? Well I've never read the two novels back to back and this time around, I want my second read-through of JE to be an examination of why I don't like it. A fairly easy question to answer on the surface -- a bigamist being portrayed as a romantic hero, whereas Heathcliff doesn't pretend to be anything other than a raging asshat in WH.

But there must be reasons why JE has endured, and I must be able to find something in it I like. Jane's character. Her humour, her loyalty, her strength?

Wish me luck. This will be my second read of JE and my third of WH. I'm reading them in this order so the thought of violence, hatred and passion will get me through a book about a nutty woman in the attic being usurped by a plain, self-righteous governess.

I could be persuaded to watch the film when it's out on DVD here, though. I mean, Michael Fassbender? Hell yeah!

I'm going in. *quakes*

PS: Poll's just for fun. No fighting! If only Fass had played Heathcliff; all would have been right with the world. *sigh*
 

Lyra Jean

Two years old now.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 10, 2005
Messages
5,329
Reaction score
794
Location
Boca Raton - Mouth of the Rat
Website
beyondtourism.wordpress.com
I have yet to read Wuthering Heights but I have read Jane Eyre.

It could be that Jane leaves Rochester and refuses to have anything to do with him since he is married and she only comes back after the crazy woman in the attic is dead.
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
It's the hearing voices thing too. The supernatural aspect of it came out of nowhere and didn't sit well in a novel that was supposedly about an ordinary woman. For those few pages, I was like, "Huh? What genre are we in?"
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
No, but seriously -- I hate the book, but it's a curiously enjoyable hatred. A guilty pleasure? Who knows?

And I just thought it would be fun to see which book is favoured by AWers. Not to debate the merits of which is best (clearly WH:D), just to tot up totals in a poll.
 

mirandashell

Banned
Joined
Feb 7, 2010
Messages
16,197
Reaction score
1,889
Location
England
I really enjoyed JE when I was 15. But it's not something I would read now. Far too melodramatic.

I've never read WH for the same reason. I'm not good with melodrama.
 

Soccer Mom

Crypto-fascist
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
Messages
18,604
Reaction score
8,039
Location
Under your couch
:wallows around in thread:

I hated both books. Jane Austen rules!

:spraypaints graffitti:
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
I do apologise. I can't believe I said it. I was way out of line, and would never deprive Moccer Som of M/M filth.

Carry on.
 

MaryMumsy

the original blond bombshell
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Messages
3,396
Reaction score
830
Location
Scottsdale, Arizona
If I ever read either, it was 45 or so years ago and I don't remember. I feel no need to read either now. I know we were required to read 'classic' novels. Silas Marner comes to mind, although I couldn't tell you a thing about it.

MM
 

gypsyscarlett

Ma fin est mon commencement
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 5, 2008
Messages
1,202
Reaction score
420
Location
mostly in my head
It's the hearing voices thing too. The supernatural aspect of it came out of nowhere and didn't sit well in a novel that was supposedly about an ordinary woman. For those few pages, I was like, "Huh? What genre are we in?"

Well, that's the thing. JE is really two genres. My fave book ever is Wuthering Heights, but I do also love JE.

The Brontes devoured older Gothic novels and those of the Romantic School while they were growing up. WH is pure Romanticism (not to be confused with romance).

With JE, Charlotte combined some of the elements of Romanticism and Gothicism (Byronic anti-hero, mad women, supernatural elements) with elements of Realism (how Jane copes with being an orphan and surviving as a woman in a time when it was hard as hell to be an independent woman)

What I admire about JE is not only how Charlotte combined Romanticism and Realism, but in her creation of Jane. Here was a heroine who was not beautiful. The first in literary history to be actively called, "plain". She had to survive by her inner strength and her wits.

Through Jane's plight, Charlotte did a damn good job depicting how harsh life was for females of that station.

So while WH is the book I want to be buried with, JE is an utterly amazing read in its own right.
 

gypsyscarlett

Ma fin est mon commencement
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 5, 2008
Messages
1,202
Reaction score
420
Location
mostly in my head
:snoopy:

Just a warning, don't get me started on the writing glory of
Emily. Because I will go on forever.

If you haven't yet, you should definitely read her poetry. Much of it highlights themes she would use in WH. Especially, "Light up thy halls".
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2005
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
13,247
WH isn't my favourite book ever, but it's definitely way up there in the top ten.

No.1 is either Wally Lamb's I Know This Much is True or Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind.
 

Calla Lily

On hiatus
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
39,309
Reaction score
17,513
Location
Non carborundum illegitimi
Website
www.aliceloweecey.net
I've read everything all 3 Bronte sisters wrote. When I was in college, the library had a shelf o' Bronte (including their brother's poetry, IIRC), and I plowed through all of it.

I never liked WH because Catherine is a selfish, whiny bitch, Edgar is a wuss, and Heathcliff is a thug. I liked JE because Jane had a spine. So many gothic heroines were doormats. I enjoyed Rochester's bitch-slapping from God--it's one of hte few conversion stories that came across as real and not heavy-handed. Of course, the entire St. John section took care of heavy-handed. :rolleyes:

Now, when I write a book and add a coincidence, I use the JE litmus test to see if it's too far-fetched. Yanno, when she runs away from Rochester, takes the first coach available, loses all her money, wanders across unknown country, and lands on the doorstep of her only living relatives on the planet. o_O
 

LJD

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 12, 2010
Messages
4,226
Reaction score
528
Don't hate me, but WH was a DNF for me :(
Maybe I shall try again some day.

I read JE when I was 11 or 12 and didn't mind it then. But I haven't felt the need to reread it.
 

Lady MacBeth

Out, damn'd spot! out, I say.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,476
Reaction score
289
Location
Canada
I love JE and WH. Tenant of Wildfell Hall is good too.
 

jennontheisland

the world is at my command
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 17, 2006
Messages
7,278
Reaction score
2,137
Location
in the rain
The only way I'll read either is for school credit.

And my one and only English class is next semester and we're reading "House of Mirth".

Bloody hell.
 

COchick

in a holding pattern
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 1, 2010
Messages
719
Reaction score
88
Location
Rocky Mountain High
Website
www.leighgrayson.blogspot.com
I've reread JE...but usually only the VERY end. I find myself skimming through everything else. But when Jane goes back to the blind Rochester and he's groping around desperately for her...ah, that's romance.
 

Dawnstorm

punny user title, here
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 18, 2007
Messages
2,752
Reaction score
449
Location
Austria
Hm, I liked Jane Eyere's childhood years, but the book went downhill after that part. It's been a while since I read it, but what I remember is thinking Jane ended up dull and self-righteous. She should have stuck with the missionary. I wanted to read more about Bertha - the woman Jane woulnd't dare to be.

Wuthering Heights contains lots of scary people. I wouldn't want to visit, but it makes for a great read.

Wuthering Heights person, here. (Also: cat person.)