iPhoto name tags - 2 questions

juniper

Always curious.
Requiescat In Pace
Registered
Joined
Mar 1, 2010
Messages
4,129
Reaction score
678
Location
Forever on the island
Question 1:
Recently got back from visiting my daughter (got her MFA in visual arts - yay!) and am looking through the photos I downloaded from camera to iPhoto.

I'm going through them, tagging them with names, and then about to email them off to her when I have a thought: is there a way to send them to her so that the name tags will be stuck on them? She's on Mac also and uses iPhoto.

It would just save her the trouble of going through and name-tagging them all.

///

Question 2:
Under iPhoto library, on the corkboard where all the "faces" folders show up - is it possible to delete some of them from the corkboard, but keep the folders? I'd like to keep just the most commonly used ones on there, not every person I ever tagged. Some of the folders are for just one photo but clutter up space on the corkboard.


BTW - I'm using iPhoto '09 - is the upgrade to 2011 much better overall? (I guess that's Question 3.)
 
Last edited:

kuwisdelu

Revolutionize the World
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
Messages
38,197
Reaction score
4,544
Location
The End of the World
Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure the answer to both your questions are "No." I'm assuming by "tagging them with names" you mean identifying the people using iPhoto's Faces feature.

There's no standardized metadata for facial recognition, and I'm sure Faces is implemented using a machine learning algorithm that learns faces specifically to each iPhoto install — it's meant to learn over time, but unless there's standardized metadata for facial recognition tagging, there would be no way to transport this without Apple using some proprietary format for the photos. The idea is, ideally, after doing it enough times, iPhoto will be able to tag everyone automatically. It takes a lot of photos before this is very accurate, though.

For question #2, I guess the answer is more like "no, but there's a workaround if you want." You can't delete individual people from the official Faces corkboard view without deleting the Faces data. Again, due to the fact that this is implemented by an iPhoto-specific algorithm and database metadata, rather than any kind of standard, means you have to rely on iPhoto's implementation, and that particular view is tied to the whole Faces algorithm and all data that iPhoto has so far.

However, one thing you could do is make a Smart Album that contains only the Faces that you want. Just create a new Smart Album where it says "Match the following conditions" add a new condition for every person you want as "<Face> <is> <______>" and add his or her face.

To be honest, iLife '11 wasn't too much of an upgrade. There were a few new features added to iMovie and GarageBand, but I can't remember anything added to iPhoto other than an improved UI. I do like the UI in iPhoto '11 a little better, but it's probably not worth upgrading unless you use it very extensively and have the disposable income lying around to do it.
 
Last edited: