How is Derleth? I've read all of Lovecraft's Cthulhu mythos works (naturally I've avoided the dream cycle like that plague because...well its just awful).
Last night I started re-reading Lovecraft's Dreams in the Witch House.
I know many people don't like Derleth's work, but I'm finding it more readable, on the whole, than most of Lovecraft and even Bloch's contributions. I've just started
Trail of Cthulhu and there's actually
some voice and
some character definition even though it is just another rehash of the same old storyline: somebody's dabbling in the musty old books, and it's going to end with death and/or madness. With the exceptions of the stories that people actually remember --
Innsmouth,
Color out of Space -- that's how Mythos stories go.
If I could theorize for a minute, I think people are drawn to the underlying concepts in the Mythos and they're willing to overlook the execution. All due respect to Lovecraft for layout out compelling ideas in his work, but... I mean, I like to think I have a pretty good vocabulary and grasp of grammar but I get really bogged down the narrative. Creeping horror? Doesn't have much choice, does it.
And, yeah, flat characters, flat dialogue (maybe it's just dated, though), rehashed plots.
It's all more scary when you sit and think about it at length
afterwards.
Which begs the question: could it be done another way?