Rewrites

Status
Not open for further replies.

Southern Girl

Prayer in a tango
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 3, 2009
Messages
316
Reaction score
40
Location
North.
I wrote a book (that I love - of course), and am having the worst time writing a query for it. I wrote an awful, wordy, descriptive query initially, and from that query, two agents picked up my ms for review. One, a full, the other, a partial. Two out of nearly 60. That's how bad the query was.

I made some revisions to my query in Query Hell, but it's still substandard. I edited my ms down from the massive 123,000 word count to a trimmer 100,000 word count. Both agents were happy to accept the revisions, and did so graciously, without giving me impression that it was a big deal.

But back to this query. After writing and rewriting and rewriting...I wonder now if it's a flaw with the book, rather than me just not being able to write a decent query. I just cannot seem to make this query interesting, and I honestly believe it is because my best character (according to my test readers) is not my MC. To make a long story short - I wrote in the POV of the ghost, or dead guy, when I should have written in the POV of the girl who can see him, the clairvoyant. It's always been my plan to spin off into another book starring the clairvoyant, which is what I'm working on now.

I do believe the story will be much stronger if it's rewritten, but honestly - at the time, it never occurred to me. And if I rewrite, it will be major work - practically a whole new book. I don't know what to do. If I should wait and see what the agents have to say, and if they don't like it, offer to rewrite in this new POV....or if I should rewrite now and hope that I can resubmit to them in an immediate turn-around, which is what I've heard can happen if they like the writing but aren't crazy about the story.

Anyway, I don't want to get in touch with these agents and ask them to accept another revision right now. They are both dream agents and I am stressing over not having heard anything from them yet. It's 3 months this week for the partial, 6 weeks for the full. I feel confident that my work shows promise, at the very least...but I would like to somehow fix this situation so that I can wait for their decision without feeling like a total spaz 23 hours out of the day.

Any advice?
 

Phaeal

Whatever I did, I didn't do it.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
9,232
Reaction score
1,898
Location
Providence, RI
If you don't have a burning desire to write something new, rewrite the novel in the new POV and see what happens. If you do have a burning desire to write something new, go at that and wait for agent feedback before you do more editing on the first novel.

Two requests, one for a full, isn't that bad a result in this market.
 

Danthia

Rewriting is part of writing, even after you get published. If you think the book you have out there is a strong book, just keep querying and trying to find a way to make that query sing. If you feel the book isn't as strong as it could be, and want to rewrite it in a new POV (essentially redoing the book) then dive in and do it. You're in control of your work so do what you think will have the best chance at selling and will make you happy. It will be more work, but if the goal is to be a published author, this is what you'll deal with on a regular basis anyway. Might as well get used to it now :)

I'd suggest leaving the book with agents for now and either start the rewrite or start something new. If they reject it, you can always submit the rewrite to them when you're done. It'll be a new book so there's nothing wrong with doing that. Depending on their response, you could even mention it's a revision in a new direction that they asked for previously. Withdrawing it or sending another rewrite will just look unprofessional and might put you on the "watch out" radar.
 

AlterEgox5

Expert Procrastinator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
608
Reaction score
47
Location
That other half of Missouri
Website
abooksellerblog.blogspot.com
The fact that you got to a full ms request is pretty awesome. I'm currently up to 26 queries, have had only 3 partial requests, and everything ultimately rejected.

First, try sending your current query to Query Shark. While it may not get picked, it can't hurt to try. If chosen, Janet will pick it apart and help you make a better one.

I think for now, if you're just too exhausted to rewrite, then just wait to see what the agents have to say. At the same time, you never know what an agent might request anyway if they do pick your ms. They might ask you to rewrite it exactly the way you think may make it more interesting. I had a friend who had to change his entire ms from 1st to 3rd person to satisfy the agent. In which case, there you go.

If every time you look at the ms and think, "Geez...this would be so much better if it were written from the other character's POV..." then maybe it really is in your best interests to tighten your boot straps and start to tackle the thing. Then if the agents say, "No thanks," you can always ask them for their personal input on whether they think it would be better to have it written from the other character's POV. If one agent was willing to look at the full ms, then there's a good chance they'll be willing to give you some feedback.
 
Last edited:

Southern Girl

Prayer in a tango
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 3, 2009
Messages
316
Reaction score
40
Location
North.
Thanks for the link, Alter - I submitted my query to the Shark and hope to hear that I've been picked to be picked apart. :)

And thanks for all the good advice, everyone. Still mulling over my "options".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.