Perspective Advice

Status
Not open for further replies.

Revelationz

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 17, 2008
Messages
83
Reaction score
8
Location
Waycross, GA
Website
www.myspace.com
After some helpful advice, I decided to rewrite my story. But, I'm just not sure whether first person perspective would be best, or third person limited. It's a Sci-Fi story that takes place around a few decades from now on a spaceship. My MC becomes captain of the spaceship and encounters a lot of struggle with his friends, commanders, the government, and eventually an alien encounter. I plan on covering the story completely from his POV.

While it is a story very driven by my main character and his perspectives on what's happening, at the same time the story is also driven by the plot. From what I understand, plot-driven stories are best told through third person, but character-driven stories are best told in first person.

So, for my first question: Which perspective do you believe would best suit such a story?

And, in that case, if I'm telling the story through only one character's POV, would there even be a point to me telling the story in third person? Wouldn't it just be better to go ahead and put the reader into the MC's head?

But this leads me to another conflict. I've read first person stories that were well done (Odd Thomas being a top notch example) but whenever I write in first person it just irks me that my character is recalling everthing with near crystal clarity. It just seems unrealistic for someone retelling a story to remember every instance of dialogue. It's wierd because it doesn't bother me when I'm reading FP, but when I write it I just feel uncomfortable with the accuracy of the MC's memory.

Anyways, I know I'm laying a lot on you guys. I don't expect a definite answer to solve all my concerns. Just be honest with your opinions and experiences, and I greatly appreciate your time. Thanks :)
 

katiemac

Five by Five
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
11,521
Reaction score
1,667
Location
Yesterday
Which one feels more natural to your story?

Try out both. Rewrite your first chapter twice, once in first person and once in third. See which one you like better and which one you can sustain for the rest of the novel.
 

JoniBGoode

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
Messages
362
Reaction score
59
Location
Chicagoland
If it seems awkward to write in 1st person for you, then don't do it. It is quite possible to write in 3rd person and still show the characters thoughts, either directly or through action.

The way a writing professor explained it to me: think of POV as a camera. The camera can be very, very close to a character (sitting on his shoulder or even inside his head) or it can be a little further away, or it can be very remote, up in the sky somewhere. I think what you want is 3rd person POV with the camera in close-up on this one character.

There are many different opinions on this topic, but I find 1st person a little gimmicky unless it is done very, very well. So I would tend to use 3rd person unless you can come up with a good reason not to.

Cheers,

Joni

PS. I LOVE your quote about mastering the English language. Do you mind if I share it with my writing group? They will think it's hilarious -- and so true! If you would like me to credit you by name, rather than absolutewrite i.d., please PM me.
 

Danthia

There is no "best way" for anything in writing. There are traditional and typical ways, but they aren't set in stone. I write in first person, and my stories tend to be very character-driven stories wrapped around a plot-driven event.

You have to ask yourself which feels right to you, and which you're more comfortable with. The most important thing is how good the story is in the end, and the only way you'll accomplished that is to write to your strengths, both as a writer amd a storyteller.

If you're unsure, try a scene in both styles and see which one sings to you. I was a third limted gal through and through until my last book, where the protag just screamed at me to try first person. I grudgingly did, and discovered I loved it. My voice works better in first than it did in third. You'll likely find you're drawn to one or the other as well, or you might discover you uwork equally well in both.

Trust your insticts. Go with what feels right to you and what you think is best for the story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.