Sentence advice

Status
Not open for further replies.

ShadowChaser

Registered
Joined
Jul 27, 2008
Messages
37
Reaction score
2
Hi all,

Thanks for all you help in the past. I am currently editing my superhero novel, trying to remove "as" words in some of my narrative. I have seen different styles, and I wonder what would be the best.

Ex: "I will see you soon, my friend," Brown said as he left the room.
I changed it to:
"I will see you soon, my friend," Brown said, and he left the room.
But to me it looks awkward. So, I tried:
"I will see you soon, my friend." Brown left the room.
"I will see you soon, my friend," he said. Brown left the room.
"I will see you soon, my friend," he said, leaving the room.

For the record, French is my first language, but I always wanted to improve my English.

I would appreciate any help you can provide.

:)
 

Seaclusion2

Extraneous Comma Slayer
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 14, 2008
Messages
3,699
Reaction score
2,143
How about:

"I will see you soon, my friend," Brown said. Then he left the room.

Richard
 

Ziljon

Tortilla di Patate
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 19, 2007
Messages
1,316
Reaction score
417
Location
In the midst of 1000 Oaks
Website
www.daviddepalo.com
Here are my thoughts:

"I will see you soon, my friend," Brown said, and he left the room. This is fine.
"I will see you soon, my friend." Brown left the room. This is a bit abrupt but still grammatical.
"I will see you soon, my friend," he said. Brown left the room. Again works grammatically but is clunky.
"I will see you soon, my friend," he said, leaving the room. This one get's my vote. But he's walking out of the room as he says it. If that's okay, then this is okay.

Or if you want a bit of drama:

Brown said, "I will see you soon, my friend." And then he left the room.
 

FennelGiraffe

It's green they say
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
1,704
Reaction score
445
Location
San Antonio
Is this simultaneous action? Is Brown actually in the process of leaving at the same time he speaks those words? If so, your original version (Brown said as he left the room) is fine. The last of your choices (he said, leaving the room) is fine, too. Both of those, though, can only be used for true simultaneous action.

If it isn't simultaneous--if Brown speaks first, then leaves--you need one of the other forms. They all work, as do the suggestions from Seaclusion and Ziljon, although a couple of yours are a little abrupt.

I have a hunch this isn't one particular sentence you're having trouble with, but rather a sentence pattern you use repeatedly. If that's the case, the best choice is to mix it up, to use all of the variations. But be aware whether you're describing simultaneous actions or consecutive actions.
 

blacbird

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Messages
36,987
Reaction score
6,159
Location
The right earlobe of North America
For me, as reader, and as human being, I find it unlikely that Brown spoke simultaneously with leaving the room. It seems more probably as a sequential action, he speaks first, then leaves the room. Any construction that conveys that sequence clearly, without extraneous words, would work for me.

caw
 

Bartholomew

Comic guy
Kind Benefactor
Poetry Book Collaborator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 2, 2006
Messages
8,507
Reaction score
1,957
Location
Kansas! Again.
Uh... "as" actually works fine, there. I've said "goodbye" while I was walking away before. The word wouldn't stop me in that particular sentence at all.

It's when you have people speaking as they take drinks that you need to rethink sentences.
 

Bufty

Where have the last ten years gone?
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 9, 2005
Messages
16,767
Reaction score
4,662
Location
Scotland
Why did you decide to get rid of that 'as'?

Nothing wrong with it there.

The use of 'as' - and other things - should be checked, but not removed en masse without thought. Remove 'as' and 'was' or whatever, if they don't work or they cloud the meaning instead of aiding clarity.
 

ShadowChaser

Registered
Joined
Jul 27, 2008
Messages
37
Reaction score
2
Thanks again for all your help. I really appreciate all the advice. :)
 

riteideas

I think you want to get rid of as when it's physically impossible or unlikely to be able to do.

He said as he was drowning.

You might want to get rid of 'as' and 'was' in that example.

I think the removal of 'as' is covered in "Self-Editing for Fiction Writers".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.