Which genre to write in?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Beach Bunny

The Provocative One
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
3,146
Reaction score
2,971
Location
Where angels fear to tread
With the help of some very nice folks in the Children's section of the board, I have figured out that what I like to do is poke fun of adults with childish humor. For example, I get a character drunk and obnoxious and then he has to do something silly to make up for it. My tone is childlike or would appeal to children. While my characters are fantasy characters (dragons, faeries, elves, etc,) the subject matter is not appropriate for children. So, what are my options? What are the different directions that I can go with this style of writing?

A few that I can come up are:
Take out the inappropriate parts: the drinking, the mild swearing, the flirting, etc. And rewrite my short stories for the picture book market. ( approx. 1,000 words/pb)

Leave them as is with some minor changes and put the short stories together as a Chapter book for an older audience.

Poking fun of adults would probably appeal to Middle grade readers so maybe consider a series for the middle grades. (approx. 25,000 word/novel ???)

Teenagers around the age of 13 to 14 would probably find the sexual innuendo and playfulness hilarious, so maybe a young adult series (approx. 80,000 word/novel)

All of the above is also an option.

I don't think I can market my style of humor to an adult market. But, maybe it could.

Any and all thoughts, suggestions, or input would be greatly appreciated. :)

Before anyone hits post: Yes. I know "write the stories that you want to tell and don't worry about where it will fit." There is a big difference between writing a 1,000 word short story and an 80,000 word novel. So, if I get an idea for a humorous story and who I want to write it for, then I know how much work I need to do on the front end. Does that make sense?
 

kct webber

Squirrel, Sekrit type, 1 ea.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Dec 16, 2006
Messages
5,323
Reaction score
1,164
Location
In the booshes.
There's nothing wrong with writing for a market. There is something to be said for "write the stories that you want to tell" and all that, but at some point this is a business, after all.

I would ask you how much YA you've read though. You may be surprised at what is considered appropriate for younguns. I can't offer much more than that in the way of advice, since I don't write for kids. What I have heard from other writers and readers, though, is that a lot of people underestimate what's appropriate when it comes to kid's stuff.

If that's not the case with you, you have to ask yourself how much the inappropriate parts add to the story. Are they critical? If so, I would probably market it to a slightly older crowd--middle graders or teens.

Like I said, I don't write for the younger crowd, so take it with a grain of salt. :)
 

MumblingSage

Inarticulate Herb
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 15, 2008
Messages
2,308
Reaction score
349
Location
in a certain state of mind
Speaking as someone who still remembers her YA days, I wouldn't want to give them more sexual innuendo than they already have...and I don't know if they'd appriciate it.

I'd try experimenting with the children's stories first, since they're shortest and won't take a great deal of time as a trial run. And maybe post a sample of your writing in SYW (under 'sci fi/fantasy', I guess, rather than Middle Grade, Children's, or YA) and ask for thoughts after people have seen the product?
 

jannawrites

no, really
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
893
Reaction score
3,207
Location
shh... I'm thinking...
... I get a character drunk and obnoxious and then he has to do something silly to make up for it. My tone is childlike or would appeal to children.... <snipped>

Poking fun of adults would probably appeal to Middle grade readers so maybe consider a series for the middle grades. (approx. 25,000 word/novel ???)

Teenagers around the age of 13 to 14 would probably find the sexual innuendo and playfulness hilarious, so maybe a young adult series (approx. 80,000 word/novel)

All of the above is also an option.

I don't think I can market my style of humor to an adult market. But, maybe it could.

Seriously? I mean, you'd really want to write this for children? As a mom of two daughters, I don't think any of this is a good idea, even for older youth. I'm sorry if that comes across as unsupportive or mean, but I wouldn't let my girls read anything with content like what you've mentioned.

As for what I've bolded above... It sounds like your style of humor is appropriate for only the adult market.

Best of luck in working it all out. :)

ETA: Just wanted to point out I did see your comment about omitting certain content if you were to create a PB, but that my concern is still over what you'd include for teenagers.
 
Last edited:

Beach Bunny

The Provocative One
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
3,146
Reaction score
2,971
Location
Where angels fear to tread
Maybe it would help if I clarified this a bit better. Taking one of my stories, the fantasy writer's group that I belonged to gave me the following feedback:
"Wow! This is really funny! This would make a great children's picture book!"

I personally didn't think so.

So, I shared it in the SYW Children's area (It's called Stealing Cookies, if you want to take a look.) and got the following feedback:
"It's cute, but it isn't appropriate for a children's picture book."

Okay, I didn't think it was.

So, what I've got is a style of humor that adults consider "childish" and a children's picture book publisher wouldn't touch with a ten foot pole. :( What can I do with that? :flag::e2cry:
 

MumblingSage

Inarticulate Herb
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 15, 2008
Messages
2,308
Reaction score
349
Location
in a certain state of mind
I don't know anything about tastes in fantasy humor--I thought Xanth had hints of childishness to it, but of course also some adult themes :p. Yet I don't think people reading those books would care to much if they were slightly less mature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.