Credentials To Give It A Go?

Status
Not open for further replies.

MelancholyMan

Wear Thick Armor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 23, 2008
Messages
525
Reaction score
89
Location
There's a rumor we're getting close...
I've been :Headbang: for a long time now in the fiction world. Honestly, it's just starting to get a little old. My stuff is good. I know I'm a capable writer. But getting a foot in the door seems to be based about 95% on luck. And that is after you've written a good manuscript. Did the agent you happened to query eat a bad apple just as they were opening your email and run off to the bathroom to puke? And ever after that last idea they read was anathema? Did they just go on vacation and your email query will be one of three thousand they return to? That kind of crap.

It has been said that getting published in the non-fiction world is more... I'll say, reliable. Not necessarily easier, but perhaps more repeatable. Now this isn't necessarily a bad thing. I like to both read and to write non-fiction. But I don't know if I have the credentials to get a proposal pushed through. I don't do self-help, or Chicken Soup for Dummy's, or anything like that. I don't write cookbooks. What I am is an aerospace engineer with a Masters degree and 17 years in industry as a rocket scientist. I love education and teaching. And I have a prodigious knowledge of history - particularly 20th century military history. Build furniture - when I have time. Play soccer. In addition, I'm an armchair philosopher, constantly wrestling with the seeming inconsistencies of religion and the absolute inconsistencies of reality.

But am I really qualified to write about any of this stuff? I have ideas, but can I reasonably expect an agent or editor to look at my proposal seriously if I don't have a Ph.D. next to my name? Here are a few of the ideas I've been batting around for a couple of years while I've been writing fiction and apparently wasting my time.

  • A YA book using rocket science and video games to teach/discuss science and math.
  • A historical treatise focusing on why we love World War II so much.
  • A philosophical work on the 20th Century murder of God by Christians, from a Christian perspective.
What do ya'll think? Stupid idea??? Seems like I'd just be querying the same unprofessional, no-reply agents I'm wasting my stamps on now.

-MM
 
Last edited:

escritora

.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Dec 21, 2007
Messages
2,995
Reaction score
616
Because it doesn't seem that you have the platform or credentials for options two and three. Look into the following idea:

A YA book using rocket science and video games to teach/discuss science and math.

Specifically, research similar published titles and learn what you can about the publisher and the author. You'll want to know if the author has a platform, what are her credentials, and so on. From there you can determine if you are the right person to write that type of book.

I'm not sure what you know or don't know about nonfiction, but it's unlike fiction where a debut author's name doesn't matter. With the nonfiction writing you are interested in, name recognition is important.

For that reason, some argue that a nonfiction writer has more hurdles to climb (is that the right phrase?) than a fiction writer. In a way, I can see that side of the argument.

The bad news is that it can take years to develop a platform. Even then, you may never find a publisher that is interested. The good news, however, is that it doesn't seem your heart is in nonfiction. Sounds more as though you are down on the publishing industry (perhaps you received a rejection in the last week or so).

Maybe narrative nonfiction will suit you best.

I can't remember the name of the book, but the premise was this: a man wrote about the year he learned to ride a bike. He took the reader on the journey of his sixth year alive.

Maybe you can develop creative nonfiction ideas, similiar to the one I mentioned above, that will get you excited.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.