Very curious to see what the reactions to last night's episode are like on the American side of the pond. I enjoyed it -- it felt a little bit too on-the-nose, but then again I sometimes need to remind myself to step back and remember I'm not the target audience for the show anymore and it needs to be accessible to younger audiences. A few of the points it raised really stuck with me, particularly that you can't walk away from the awful parts of history. You ARE a part of it, even if you as a person wouldn't condone it now you know better. It's just such a chewy theme, the idea that sometimes you have to watch, because you DID just sit and watch at the time, because if you were of that time you would have sat and watched. Modern Doctor Who often leans more towards 'we should do good and help the world' over 'we should preserve history', and it feels like a long time since we've had an episode that pushed hard in the preserving history direction.
It was so good. It was powerful. It's still on my mind days later.
I do wonder if there were elements that could have been handled better... it felt *so* weird, somehow, having a bunch of Brits shoving themselves into a charged American environment and getting to hold the upper hand of 'we're much more enlightened'. But given the limitations of the format [that is to say: must contain the companions and the doctor] I think Malorie Blackman did a fantastic job turning in a powerful piece of storytelling.
The time vortex manipulators did give me a powerful sense of missing Jack Harkness, though. I would've liked to see him here using Barrowman's American acting to its fullest and adding a bit of American perspective to things.
It was so good. It was powerful. It's still on my mind days later.
I do wonder if there were elements that could have been handled better... it felt *so* weird, somehow, having a bunch of Brits shoving themselves into a charged American environment and getting to hold the upper hand of 'we're much more enlightened'. But given the limitations of the format [that is to say: must contain the companions and the doctor] I think Malorie Blackman did a fantastic job turning in a powerful piece of storytelling.
The time vortex manipulators did give me a powerful sense of missing Jack Harkness, though. I would've liked to see him here using Barrowman's American acting to its fullest and adding a bit of American perspective to things.