Quote Originally Posted by cgswe View Post
I do wonder if enthusiasm trumps experience in these cases. I love the idea of having a passionate advocate, but I don’t know if effusiveness is the strongest measure of advocacy. B is older than A and might just express interest differently.
Only you can really say in this case, because we haven't spoken to them.

But as a quieter person myself, I view effusiveness as a personality trait, and not any real indicator of genuine enthusiasm.