• Basic Writing questions is not a crit forum. All crits belong in Share Your Work

Help with character goal, please?

NINA28

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 29, 2019
Messages
109
Reaction score
5
Location
UK
Been doing some writing tonight and realized my main character may have two goals.
My main character, EMMA, is a teenage girl and the last human on a planet dominated by magical beings.

Personal goal: Although she has never gone without material things Emma does not feel part of her community and as she and her friends grew older and they took on careers and husbands, her uniqueness has made her a loner. She now spends every free moment secretly searching for the answer to why humans mysteriously vanished and why she was the only one left. Why her mother abandoned her. (most jobs/careers on this planet require a magical user so she gets stuck with mundane jobs. There is also an aging difference between her and the other two species that could offer her a partner.) Her life is becoming lonely.

This goal is achieved by the end of the First Act. She finds her own kind in a dystopian world where they are slaves. So now she has what she wanted but has lost all her material wealth, her safety and her freedom. She sees the best in mankind and the worst that makes her wonder if she's left everything behind for nothing. Without magic working she can't return to her old planet but would she want to if she could? Maybe not a goal throughout but certainly some conflict.

Goal: Restore magic
Problem: the beings in this world rely heavily on magic for survival. It has never failed them before so they have never devised any other method for healing, travel etc besides magic. So when magic begins to suddenly fade away for seemingly no reason, daily life becomes difficult for them. Some are having to face losing their powers all together and the future returning to being primitive. Magic purifies water to drink, they have no other way. Emma's own community are the oldest race on the planet, created by a God and they need it to live. They are beginning to grow weak and die. This problem continues throughout the novel as Emma realizes that not only does her old planet need magic, but saving magic could also save mankind from enslavement. So her goal becomes discovering what's happening to magic.

Should I try and connect the two goals or keep them separate? Is finding humans her internal goal and saving magic her external goal? I'd like to try and conflict her goals just not sure how yet. I really need some advice. Which goal should be the main focus?
Thank you
 

MaeZe

Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 6, 2016
Messages
12,832
Reaction score
6,592
Location
Ralph's side of the island.
You have the right idea.

She finds her own kind in a dystopian world where they are slaves.
This goal is achieved by the end of the First Act. She finds her own kind

magic begins to suddenly fade away for seemingly no reason
So her goal becomes discovering what's happening to magic.
Trying to boil this down but I see no connection between finding the dystopia with other humans [at this point her goal is resolve the loneliness] and magic disappearing where she tries to save that world.

There has to be a consequence in leaving the magical world, [she leaves to find humans and needed companionship and or love]

But did her leaving cause the death of magic? The magical creatures rejected her, did she care about them anyway? Does she go back because it was her home?

I'm not seeing how to tie these goals at this point. Does she rescue human slaves and from whom?

Then keep in mind there are inner goals and outer goals. For example, outer goals would be all this saving. The inner goal would be being accepted? or finding her own self-worth despite being inferior to the magic? Or whatever inner goal you determine.

Hope that rambling is useful. :)
 
Last edited:

JEChillemi

Registered
Joined
May 28, 2019
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
I definitely think characters can have multiple goals, both internal and external. Maybe Emma's goal has shifted on how to achieve the balance of both goals? What she solved in ACT 1 and what she needs to solve by the end of the book?
 

jwhite1979

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 5, 2019
Messages
73
Reaction score
5
Location
Maine
I think you're omitting a lot of the connective tissue in your explanation of the plot. Without knowing exactly what's happening in the story, I can see there's a class struggle between magical and non-magical societies. Your protagonist, who is non-magical, finds herself among her people, who are enslaved. Meanwhile, the magical class is slowly losing their magic. Am I right so far? You have the makings of a decent Marxist narrative, in which class distinctions are subverted for better or worse. The disappearance of magic has a leveling effect, and I think an interesting angle would be for the protagonist to question whether to support this leveling effect. Her ultimate goal may be a sense of belonging, and the dramatic tension would come from straddling two worlds in trouble.