Very interested to see people's takes on this one.
It's not a bad musical, but it would have been better without the attempt to make it a "based on the life of..." kind of thing.
It's a total failure as an attempt to tell the story of P.T. Barum and how he interacted with his family, his circus, etc. It doesn't just gloss over the dark chapters, it repaints them as something bright and hopeful. It mangles Jenny Lynd (Sp?), who deserves better than the "spurned woman" sidebar she's made into.
If they'd just made a musical about a guy who started a circus, rather than trying to couple it to the history of a man whose story they decided to not actually tell, I don't think the reviews would be so mixed. The musical numbers are well choreographed and the cinematography is very well executed. I especially like the acrobatic / aerial love song and the "anthem" sung by the circus performers.
It's not a bad musical, but it would have been better without the attempt to make it a "based on the life of..." kind of thing.
It's a total failure as an attempt to tell the story of P.T. Barum and how he interacted with his family, his circus, etc. It doesn't just gloss over the dark chapters, it repaints them as something bright and hopeful. It mangles Jenny Lynd (Sp?), who deserves better than the "spurned woman" sidebar she's made into.
If they'd just made a musical about a guy who started a circus, rather than trying to couple it to the history of a man whose story they decided to not actually tell, I don't think the reviews would be so mixed. The musical numbers are well choreographed and the cinematography is very well executed. I especially like the acrobatic / aerial love song and the "anthem" sung by the circus performers.