Forums are dying.
Not really. Forums are dying. It's probably a better use of your time to be active on Twitter and Goodreads.That said I have bought books from two writers on AW so it may not be a total waste of your time.
Says Cereus.
On a forum.
FWIW, I've purchased and read some books by AW members I've "met" here in the forums. Some of these books I've loved, and some I've been more lukewarm about (for reasons relating to my tastes, not the quality of the work). But in each case, the person was someone I got to "know" through their participation in the same subforums I do. I liked them and the things they had to say about writing, world building, characterization, politics, the process of querying, or about other books they've read etc., and the books linked in their signatures looked like the sort of thing I might want to read.
I've never visited the Announcements, Events or Book Promotion subforum here on AW in order to find reading material, and I've never decided to read a book because it's author spammed my twitter feed or asked people to read it in a discussion forum.
No idea how typical I am, but I would guess you might gain some readers, or at least a few who might give your book a chance, if they get to know you in the forums as a person. I don't know how huge that impact would be on your overall sales. I personally do tell other friends who like the same sort of fiction I do about new (or new to me) authors I've discovered and liked (face to face, in forums, in my blog, and on social media), but I don't know how many go on to read the books I recommend.
Disagree strongly.
People have been predicting the death of the forum platform for years. I think certain forums will die, but that's the nature of any community. I don't think the platform will ever die though. There's discussion available here that just can't be done on Facebook or Twitter. It's also worth noting that Goodreads runs threaded discussions just like forums. They just call them Groups or Discussions. But I think those are closer to forums than they are something like Twitter.
ETA: this is not a new discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/socialmedia/comments/2ar5xi/are_internet_forums_dying/
I think forums fill a purpose, as they generally allow people who share a specific interest to have conversations that are more detailed, focused and complex than the ones on twitter or FB (and without forcing all your friends with different interests to see your long posts about writing, or dogs, or politics on their feeds). I feel like I "know" people I've met here on AW better than I "know" people I've met on twitter.
It's possibly true that there is such a vast number of forums out there that it's hard to get traction if you're starting one from scratch. But AW (and other writing forums I've encountered that have been around for a while) seem to be going strong. Some people drift away, but new people join every day. And it seems like a much better platform for sharing fiction critiques in a password-protected area than social media like Twitter.
But if you feel that forums like this one aren't worth your time, and you'd rather connect with people about writing on twitter or a similar platform, that's certainly your right. It's nice to have a variety of platforms and choices about which ones to use.
But I am of the opinion that hanging out on any social media platform just to promote your book is a waste of time, because if you're not having fun and connecting with people, then you're at risk of becoming one of those authors who scream "buy my book" all day long and alienate everyone.
Exactly! Put much more clearly than my usual meander.I've never read a book because someone appeared on a forum or social media saying, "Hey! I'm a person you've never heard of! Buy my book!" I just feel mildly irritated, and ignore it.
I have sometimes read a book because someone I've already encountered on social media, and thought well of, someone who I feel a sort of internet-friendly connection with, has written it. It's like reading a book by a friend or acquaintance.
Its useful to promote your books anywhere you can. Forums may not get you a lot of immediate sales, but if your book is good people will mention it to their friends and will talk about it. And that's exactly what forums are - places to talk with one's friends and mention things of common interest to them. Of course, in order for that to happen, your book needs to be worth talking about (and sometimes forums like this one could even help learn how to achieve that ).
Honestly, I don't know if anything I've done has resulted in book sales. Pretty discouraged at this time.
However, lately I've been using retweet teams and spending a few hours a day five days a week in front of this screen doing a number of things, connecting with other authors, and retweeting madly. I am always now looking for new opportunities to find retweet teams.