(Also posted in Ask the Agent)
Hi there,
I sent out my first 15 queries at the beginning of March. Since then I have had 3 form rejections, a personal rejection, an offer of representation which I ended up declining for various reasons, and a full MS request. The most recent agent who requested the full emailed me today. She said some lovely things about my book, complementing the confidence of my writing, my sense of place and the premise of the book.
However, (you knew that was coming, right?), she then went on to say that it needs a lot more work, including addressing the POV (too many), and the characterisation. She has invited me to phone her tomorrow to discuss these points, and concludes the email by saying she would be pleased to take another look if I "decide to rework the story".
Now, is this a rewrite/resubmission scenario? The overall tone of the email suggested that she didn't mind either way if I wanted to take her advice (which I most certainly do - she is one of my top agents), but then again wouldn't she have just rejected the whole thing if she didn't see any promise? I'm really looking forward to talking to her tomorrow and am planning on spending the evening making some notes on possible areas of improvement.
Would she be offering me this help if she didn't think it would be possible to get the manuscript up to publishing quality? I really want this agent...
Hi there,
I sent out my first 15 queries at the beginning of March. Since then I have had 3 form rejections, a personal rejection, an offer of representation which I ended up declining for various reasons, and a full MS request. The most recent agent who requested the full emailed me today. She said some lovely things about my book, complementing the confidence of my writing, my sense of place and the premise of the book.
However, (you knew that was coming, right?), she then went on to say that it needs a lot more work, including addressing the POV (too many), and the characterisation. She has invited me to phone her tomorrow to discuss these points, and concludes the email by saying she would be pleased to take another look if I "decide to rework the story".
Now, is this a rewrite/resubmission scenario? The overall tone of the email suggested that she didn't mind either way if I wanted to take her advice (which I most certainly do - she is one of my top agents), but then again wouldn't she have just rejected the whole thing if she didn't see any promise? I'm really looking forward to talking to her tomorrow and am planning on spending the evening making some notes on possible areas of improvement.
Would she be offering me this help if she didn't think it would be possible to get the manuscript up to publishing quality? I really want this agent...