Some days I zig, some days I zag, some days I hit a snag. I'd kinda planned on dropping the other stuff temporarily to focus on getting LoLa out the door, but the comp-hunting is proving a lot harder than expected. That and I'm kinda not making enough headway on the synopsis and haven't really gotten a query underway.
However, I realized that besides kinda having a possible query for GB, it looks like the synopsis might also be passable, so I may return to editing that after all. And I'm also half-leaning toward not describing the four friends. As I've probably mentioned, I'm pretty sure Lindsay Currie didn't describe the three friends at the start of The Mystery of Locked Rooms * and iirc Katherine Arden didn't describe Brian until chapter 3 or 4 in Small Spaces** (probably because she spent 3 or 4 paragraphs describing CoCo; Ollie, the MC, isn't described at all), so it might not be a big deal.
[*Although she was already a NYT bestselling author by then. Also, apparently she had another horror novel come out this year where, despite being disappointed by her a few of her other books and not wanting to go all-in on any one author, I'll probably find up reading; if nothing else, the woman consistently knows how to title horror (X Marks the Haunt))
**Katherine Arden was also already a bestselling author, albeit for either YA or adult. iirc, the Small Spaces quartet is her only MG.]
In other news, I started reading GSI after accidentally opening the manuscript instead of GB. Read through the first few chapters, really got a kick out of the humor. Of course, I have no idea how I'm going to comp that. I might have to rely on that suggestion of going for tone with a story that bears no resemblance (and, actually, I might have to do that with LoLa, too, despite the fact there MUST be something within that same general sphere. Kids accidentally raising pet monsters in a contemporary setting can't be that rare)
And I'm kinda debating ditching the MG mall idea for not being commercial enough. Lot of creepy things I could do with it, but there's nothing scarier than having a manuscript that won't get interest. (Which might wind up being the issue with LoLa, considering Pointy Hat did so badly.)
YMMV with all that. Personally, I've always thought the descriptions of MG bullying were tame. But I also went to a middle school where a classmate was expelled for sticking a pistol in another kid's face. (Unloaded, mind you. Also, this was obviously pre-Columbine where guns in schools didn't get quite the same reaction they do today.) There were students who were bullied so badly they had to transfer out.
I'm obviously happy to hear that you and your kids' experience hasn't been that, though.
I kept it, and I think you might've seen close to the version that went out. iirc, I got feedback on the 10 pages and changed a few things before you beta'd it.
While I can't always be sure where I lost people or why, the agent who mentioned being open to a R&R didn't like the lunch table scene a bit further on. The agent who requested the first 50 or 75 pages stopped on the part where the MC and the twin were talking on the stairs, which, you know, you'd suggested I do something with and I don't think I finally did. (Although she made it past the rooftop escape, which I trimmed and adjusted, per your suggestions.)
tbh, despite swearing I'd never fall into that boat again, I probably have a few dozen planning docs now with barely anything in them. So the idea is kinda saved, but it's really not going anywhere.
I'd been pretty good about approaching planning then drafting methodically up until I had an idea for a comedic mystery-horror that parodied the idea that these small towns in amateur detective shows would have tons and tons of murders.
However, I realized that besides kinda having a possible query for GB, it looks like the synopsis might also be passable, so I may return to editing that after all. And I'm also half-leaning toward not describing the four friends. As I've probably mentioned, I'm pretty sure Lindsay Currie didn't describe the three friends at the start of The Mystery of Locked Rooms * and iirc Katherine Arden didn't describe Brian until chapter 3 or 4 in Small Spaces** (probably because she spent 3 or 4 paragraphs describing CoCo; Ollie, the MC, isn't described at all), so it might not be a big deal.
[*Although she was already a NYT bestselling author by then. Also, apparently she had another horror novel come out this year where, despite being disappointed by her a few of her other books and not wanting to go all-in on any one author, I'll probably find up reading; if nothing else, the woman consistently knows how to title horror (X Marks the Haunt))
**Katherine Arden was also already a bestselling author, albeit for either YA or adult. iirc, the Small Spaces quartet is her only MG.]
In other news, I started reading GSI after accidentally opening the manuscript instead of GB. Read through the first few chapters, really got a kick out of the humor. Of course, I have no idea how I'm going to comp that. I might have to rely on that suggestion of going for tone with a story that bears no resemblance (and, actually, I might have to do that with LoLa, too, despite the fact there MUST be something within that same general sphere. Kids accidentally raising pet monsters in a contemporary setting can't be that rare)
And I'm kinda debating ditching the MG mall idea for not being commercial enough. Lot of creepy things I could do with it, but there's nothing scarier than having a manuscript that won't get interest. (Which might wind up being the issue with LoLa, considering Pointy Hat did so badly.)
Not really commenting on the specific story in question or the larger conversation about an opening's viability . . . but I would say that, personally, both as a child and an adult, I never really found any of those things to be relatable.
Personally, I don't really think the way MG students get portrayed is "ordinary." Most kids aren't relentlessly bullied (which is how it is often portrayed with bullying) or have no friends, or are specifically targeted by teachers and/or are complete loners.
What makes it relatable, at least remembering being a kid myself, is that everyone has had a moment where it was true of them - where they didn't think they had friends, got bullied, etcetera, so they can put themselves in the space of that character when reading - i.e. those tropes engage their imagination.
YMMV with all that. Personally, I've always thought the descriptions of MG bullying were tame. But I also went to a middle school where a classmate was expelled for sticking a pistol in another kid's face. (Unloaded, mind you. Also, this was obviously pre-Columbine where guns in schools didn't get quite the same reaction they do today.) There were students who were bullied so badly they had to transfer out.
I'm obviously happy to hear that you and your kids' experience hasn't been that, though.
yes it was a waking up opening (not sure if you changed that specific part prior to querying or not)
I kept it, and I think you might've seen close to the version that went out. iirc, I got feedback on the 10 pages and changed a few things before you beta'd it.
While I can't always be sure where I lost people or why, the agent who mentioned being open to a R&R didn't like the lunch table scene a bit further on. The agent who requested the first 50 or 75 pages stopped on the part where the MC and the twin were talking on the stairs, which, you know, you'd suggested I do something with and I don't think I finally did. (Although she made it past the rooftop escape, which I trimmed and adjusted, per your suggestions.)
I had a super lovely dream that is making me contemplate a new story idea... which I should leave on the backburner bc I have too many half baked ideas brewing and a lot of revisions to finish up before I should even think about another WIP. So, we'll see how long this idea sits. Might forget about it in a few days, anyway
tbh, despite swearing I'd never fall into that boat again, I probably have a few dozen planning docs now with barely anything in them. So the idea is kinda saved, but it's really not going anywhere.
I'd been pretty good about approaching planning then drafting methodically up until I had an idea for a comedic mystery-horror that parodied the idea that these small towns in amateur detective shows would have tons and tons of murders.
