- Joined
- Jul 23, 2006
- Messages
- 8,142
- Reaction score
- 2,669
- Location
- In cahoots with the other boo-birds
- Website
- www.staciakane.com
Finally, I had a look at Wandering Sage's web site. After reading Stacia Kane's blog posts "Find the Right Publisher, Parts 1-3," except for the fact that WS has other things besides books, they seem to do everything right according to this article. They do at least look good on the surface. Do they really have all these "red flags" that everyone seems to be pointing out here, or should we give them a little more time to build a track record?
Hi Michael!
First, thanks for mentioning the blog and for apparently enjoying the articles and finding them useful. I appreciate it.
I do want to point out something, though. With the exception of the first part and some of the information in the last few posts (there were, um, six in all I think, six or seven) which is applicable to both, the Publisher series focused largely on epublishers, not print publishers. Things like distribution don't matter with an epublisher, because most ebooks are bought either directly from the publisher's site or from an online outlet like Fictionwise (and I do touch on that in one of the last segments).
However. Aside from the fact that, print or ebook, one of the major criteria I try to stress in the series is sales--which for a print book would mean, "Have you seen this publisher's books in stores?", which does largely answer the distribution question--I am in fact seeing a few red flags on the Wandering Sage site, some of which are things I did discuss in the Publishing series and some I didn't. Or at the very least, "pink flags"; things which give me pause.
Like:
*First, and most important, this is the website of what purports to be a publisher, yet there is really no focus at all on books. Yes, I understand that they sell other items as well, expanding into other sales areas or whatever it's called. And you know, I actually think that's kind of cool, or rather, it can be. And I see they have a few titles listed in a sidebar on the far right.
But a publisher should be a publisher first and foremost. Publishing is a complicated business and requires an enormous amount of time, work, and dedication; the amount of hours and skill editing alone can take is mind-boggling if you think about it.
You are looking for a publisher who wants to publish books, who will devote their time and care and attention to those books. Not who likes to sell the same pewter jewelry every other website sells, and decided to throw a couple of books together too. My books are important to me; I want them to be important to my publisher as well, and not just another product to toss up on the home page and see if it sticks.
Which is another important point, in fact:
*They do not show or list their books on their homepage, aside from a little sidebar on the far right for sale items, which does not appear to focus excusively on *their* books. Again, publishing appears to be a sideline for this company, not the reason it exists. I don't want to be a secondary income stream to my publisher.
*No submission guidelines
*NO previous publishing experience for any of the company's management; at least none I can see. Of course there are no bios listed. Which is another red flag I mentioned in Pt 1 of the Publishing Series; beware of companies that won't tell you who they are. (Now, in this case, the owners have made their names clear here, and I guess some pages are incomplete [see below] but still, it's something that makes me wary.
*Several blank pages which should be filled; there is no About Us. There are no FAQs. Their Store Policies are woefully inadequate, IMO, with no information about shipping and no real info about returns or credits or anything.
*Another one from the Publishing series: There are no excerpts on the website, only short blurbs (I haven't looked at many of the blurbs, but the ones I have looked at are not impressive). Excerpts are HUGELY important in selling books; why would you go with a publisher who isn't cognizant of this one extremely basic fact?
I wouldn't call this publisher a scam, at all. I don't get any sense at all that's the case. I'm pretty sure they're honest and well-intentioned, and given those other selling areas it wouldn't surprise me to see them remain in business for some time.
That doesn't mean I think they're a good publisher for your work, though. Not at all. I don't.
Does that help? Please don't hesitate to email me if you ever have any questions about the Publishing series or anything else on my blog. Really. I'm happy to hear from you.
Last edited: