Currently I have two YA fantasy ideas I'd like to develop into novels. A YA epic fantasy happening in a secondary world (let's call it Book #1). The other a modern YA fairytale retelling (the story happens in the US with a Chinese American protagonist as it's based on Chinese mythology); let's call it Book #2. Apparently, a lot of agents are seeking fairytale retellings, especially non-western based. I've also looked at recent YA fantasy sales posted on PM; all the debut YA fantasy sales are for modern fantasy. So it may be smart to write Book #2. The problem is, I don't feel enthusiastic about Book #2. I really want to write Book #1, but I'm tired of writing another book that's not sellable/marketable, since a lot of YA agents say they don't want second-world or high fantasy. I'm querying an #OwnVoice YA fantasy book right now; if I can get an agent or even a publisher for this book, what subcategory I write in may not matter as much. But if I can't, then I need to write something I can sell.
I know people say, "Write what you want to write." But writers need to be realistic and be aware of the market, too, don't they?
I know people say, "Write what you want to write." But writers need to be realistic and be aware of the market, too, don't they?