I've entered pitchwars numerous times, including with a manuscript that was not only polished but had been through paid developmental editing and several paid copy editors and 16 beta readers.
I've never gotten a single request. So no, polishing is not the key, although a first draft will not survive slush. One pitchwars mentor a few years back flat out said, on twitter, they would never pick a book that highlights climate change... because it doesn't sell.
It's true, we like to see the end of the world in our fiction but not if it actually aims to help save the real world. Because that's depressing and doesn't sell. <eyeroll> <insert rant about capitalism and climate here>
Tamlyn, I'd recommend that you look through the past showcases--which are kept online. I've done all sorts of analyses, three or four years running, on what sorts of manuscripts get picked, and which get the most requests from agents in the showcase. You can get a feel for this stuff by browsing the showcase. And some of the entries are so good you wonder how the hell these authors aren't agented yet. Others feel like pet projects. It's all interesting to browse.
A few AWers have been in pitchwars. I can think of two off the top of my head.
I've never gotten a single request. So no, polishing is not the key, although a first draft will not survive slush. One pitchwars mentor a few years back flat out said, on twitter, they would never pick a book that highlights climate change... because it doesn't sell.
It's true, we like to see the end of the world in our fiction but not if it actually aims to help save the real world. Because that's depressing and doesn't sell. <eyeroll> <insert rant about capitalism and climate here>
Tamlyn, I'd recommend that you look through the past showcases--which are kept online. I've done all sorts of analyses, three or four years running, on what sorts of manuscripts get picked, and which get the most requests from agents in the showcase. You can get a feel for this stuff by browsing the showcase. And some of the entries are so good you wonder how the hell these authors aren't agented yet. Others feel like pet projects. It's all interesting to browse.
A few AWers have been in pitchwars. I can think of two off the top of my head.