- Joined
- Nov 5, 2006
- Messages
- 17,875
- Reaction score
- 4,668
- Location
- dunking doughnuts at Dunkin' Donuts
I attended RWA's national convention for the first time this year, and it was a spectacular learning experience for me. During the annual general meeting (first thing I attended. Hey, I'm a member, I was there, I want to know what the organization's doing for me and my fellow writers), the subject came up of RWA's looooooooooooooong history of dragging their feet on issues. Recently, they're addressing issues on diversity in the romance publishing industry and better representation of underrepresented groups. The primary discussion is on race but they've long also looked at QUILTBAG as part of the "diversity" umbrella.
During the RITA awards, author Suzanne Brockmann received the Lifetime Achievement Award and in her speech, she excoriated RWA for long looking down on QUILTBAG authors and novels, starting primarily with her own experiences in trying to get a novel published with a gay man as a minor background character (SPOILER ALERT: in 1992, you couldn't even do that in a novel and expect the organization to stand behind you). As recently as 2008, she was asked to MC the RITA awards and after rehearsals, was asked to not mention the wedding of two gay characters in a novel she'd published then. She didn't fight back then, either. She finally fought back long, hard, and loud during her LTA speech, especially since her own son has recently gotten married to his boyfriend, speaking out in a "now or never" tone that became more strident, more impassioned, and more brilliant as it went on.
Many people who'd never heard of her before that night fell deeply, completely, and totally in love with her. (I had to tell her that I need to track down her books and how much I hate it when an author forces me to buy more books.) Full text of her speech here; make wid der klikkety.
But, obviously, not everybody shares in the enthusiasm. The owner of Clean Reads is shocked, horrified, and aghast that such a deeply profound honor has been sullied and turned into a political event, claiming she'd insulted most of the people in the audience* (which was hard to tell if she'd insulted anybody at all, considering she'd gotten THREE standing ovations during the course of her speech). Brockmann had the platform and I'd say she reminded RWA of the contract they have with their members, to represent them and promote the romance genre, and how much work still needs to be done. She kept it on track within the confines of the group and their mission, unlike various performers over the years who'd used their Oscar win to promote their stances on the Israel-Palestine conflict; that is politicizing the moment and taking away from it.
My other takeaway from this? Jesus H., those RITA awards are fucking HYOOGE. If you've seen All About Eve and the Sarah Siddon Society award Eve receives during the run of the film? You think THAT thing was gigantic? Holy crapsticks, you could probably stun an ox with a RITA.
*The original Facebook post has since been deleted but a screencap is included with the Twitter feed.
During the RITA awards, author Suzanne Brockmann received the Lifetime Achievement Award and in her speech, she excoriated RWA for long looking down on QUILTBAG authors and novels, starting primarily with her own experiences in trying to get a novel published with a gay man as a minor background character (SPOILER ALERT: in 1992, you couldn't even do that in a novel and expect the organization to stand behind you). As recently as 2008, she was asked to MC the RITA awards and after rehearsals, was asked to not mention the wedding of two gay characters in a novel she'd published then. She didn't fight back then, either. She finally fought back long, hard, and loud during her LTA speech, especially since her own son has recently gotten married to his boyfriend, speaking out in a "now or never" tone that became more strident, more impassioned, and more brilliant as it went on.
Many people who'd never heard of her before that night fell deeply, completely, and totally in love with her. (I had to tell her that I need to track down her books and how much I hate it when an author forces me to buy more books.) Full text of her speech here; make wid der klikkety.
But, obviously, not everybody shares in the enthusiasm. The owner of Clean Reads is shocked, horrified, and aghast that such a deeply profound honor has been sullied and turned into a political event, claiming she'd insulted most of the people in the audience* (which was hard to tell if she'd insulted anybody at all, considering she'd gotten THREE standing ovations during the course of her speech). Brockmann had the platform and I'd say she reminded RWA of the contract they have with their members, to represent them and promote the romance genre, and how much work still needs to be done. She kept it on track within the confines of the group and their mission, unlike various performers over the years who'd used their Oscar win to promote their stances on the Israel-Palestine conflict; that is politicizing the moment and taking away from it.
My other takeaway from this? Jesus H., those RITA awards are fucking HYOOGE. If you've seen All About Eve and the Sarah Siddon Society award Eve receives during the run of the film? You think THAT thing was gigantic? Holy crapsticks, you could probably stun an ox with a RITA.
*The original Facebook post has since been deleted but a screencap is included with the Twitter feed.