- Joined
- Oct 24, 2011
- Messages
- 23,122
- Reaction score
- 10,882
- Location
- Where faults collide
- Website
- doggedlywriting.blogspot.com
I think another reason that Democrats tend to do a lot of navel gazing and blaming of their own party is because it gives one a sense of control to do so. We can (possibly) change the things our own party does, but we are pretty helpless to do anything to change the behavior and attitudes of the Right, at least in the short term. I think many of us have experienced the frustration of attempting to discuss these issues with a friend or family member who has been sucked into the reactionary right, and it feels pretty hopeless.
And to be fair to the navel gazers, the post Bill Clinton Democrats have become friendlier to big business, corporations etc. The party mainstream has bought into the idea that less regulated "free" markets are the best thing for the country. This is not only not working for those who have always been marginalized, it's not working for working class and (increasingly) for middle class Americans either, but no one inside Washington really seems to care. People who have been able to enjoy a middle class lifestyle (home ownership, benefits, and relative economic security and a chance at college for their kids), even if they have joyless, grueling jobs, are falling into economic insecurity and poverty.
The Democratic party has moved to the left on some social issues, which is reflective of a shift in the population as a whole (most Americans don't want Roe overturned and think same sex couples should be allowed to marry, for instance). But they haven't addressed the problems faced by more and more people, rural and urban, White and people of Color etc. in a world where globalization and technology are turning workers without very specific skills that are currently in demand (and even those skilled folks must be constantly updating their skills to remain competitive and often lose out as they get older) into a disposable commodity. A small number of people are doing better, much better, than ever before, but everyone else is working harder to stay in the same place, if they are lucky, or actively losing ground if they are not.
People are losing their place in the world, and they don't see a ready way to make a new place for themselves from within the system. This is really scary. Scared people get angry. This leads them to embrace weird, out-there outsiders whose whole personas ooze anger and are increasingly frank about their desire to burn everything down.
Why small-town, White working class people are particularly inclined to embrace candidates that essentially hate everything and want to burn our democratic institutions down is an interesting question too. I am guessing it probably relates to the reaction by folks who are losing what they had vs that of people who are being stymied in their attempt to get something they hoped for? There is also a tendency to dismiss beneficial things like science, higher education, modern health care, public health agencies etc. if one hasn't got access to them anyway, but the results are horrific in a world where science, higher education, modern health care, and public health agencies are more important than they have ever been.
I am definitely not excusing the racism, homophobia, and misogyny, which are disgusting and scary, but they seem to keep cropping up in this country, like mold in a water-damaged house. We can't seem to escape from our racist history, nor from the weird idea that the strong should rule the weak that is so at odds with our pride in being the first modern democracy and with conservative claims that we are a Christian nation
And to be fair to the navel gazers, the post Bill Clinton Democrats have become friendlier to big business, corporations etc. The party mainstream has bought into the idea that less regulated "free" markets are the best thing for the country. This is not only not working for those who have always been marginalized, it's not working for working class and (increasingly) for middle class Americans either, but no one inside Washington really seems to care. People who have been able to enjoy a middle class lifestyle (home ownership, benefits, and relative economic security and a chance at college for their kids), even if they have joyless, grueling jobs, are falling into economic insecurity and poverty.
The Democratic party has moved to the left on some social issues, which is reflective of a shift in the population as a whole (most Americans don't want Roe overturned and think same sex couples should be allowed to marry, for instance). But they haven't addressed the problems faced by more and more people, rural and urban, White and people of Color etc. in a world where globalization and technology are turning workers without very specific skills that are currently in demand (and even those skilled folks must be constantly updating their skills to remain competitive and often lose out as they get older) into a disposable commodity. A small number of people are doing better, much better, than ever before, but everyone else is working harder to stay in the same place, if they are lucky, or actively losing ground if they are not.
People are losing their place in the world, and they don't see a ready way to make a new place for themselves from within the system. This is really scary. Scared people get angry. This leads them to embrace weird, out-there outsiders whose whole personas ooze anger and are increasingly frank about their desire to burn everything down.
Why small-town, White working class people are particularly inclined to embrace candidates that essentially hate everything and want to burn our democratic institutions down is an interesting question too. I am guessing it probably relates to the reaction by folks who are losing what they had vs that of people who are being stymied in their attempt to get something they hoped for? There is also a tendency to dismiss beneficial things like science, higher education, modern health care, public health agencies etc. if one hasn't got access to them anyway, but the results are horrific in a world where science, higher education, modern health care, and public health agencies are more important than they have ever been.
I am definitely not excusing the racism, homophobia, and misogyny, which are disgusting and scary, but they seem to keep cropping up in this country, like mold in a water-damaged house. We can't seem to escape from our racist history, nor from the weird idea that the strong should rule the weak that is so at odds with our pride in being the first modern democracy and with conservative claims that we are a Christian nation