Other warning signs to note from the Malice Press website:
We are open to novels, novellas, and volumes of short stories and poetry.
Whilst I love short stories and have a lot of admiration for poets, short story collections/anthologies and books of poetry don't tend to be money makers, which means that many publishers won't touch them.
We want writing that would be rated at least "R".
I've never heard of a publisher with a rating requirement before (oh okay, maybe some of the erotic literature publishers who want something steamy
).
Some of our publishing ideas may be unorthodox, but the goal is to exist and thrive in a very competitive environment.
Without distribution in place, you don't stand a chance in the publishing game. At the moment, its books are only listed as being available on Amazon and Barnes & Noble's website. That's not encouraging. They should have got the distribution sorted before opening to submissions.
Science Fiction, Horror, Mystery, thrilller, Western and any other genre, sub-genre, or cross-genre is appropriate for Malice Press.
Start-ups tend to specialise in one or two genres, where they can build up contacts and distribution. If they're accepting everything, then they're going to find themselves swamped with submissions (even allowing for the R rating requirement).
Then there's the fact that there's no previous publishing experience cited by the owner, other than a brush with PA. Whilst there's no shame with having been duped by PA it doesn't qualify someone to set up their own publishing house (although it seems that there are always some former authors who think it does).
I don't think the guy's a scammer or anything, he seems to be a well-intentioned but clueless amateur. I'd second the recommendations to avoid.
MM