One Body Too Many
Directed by Frank McDonald and starring Jack Haley, Jean Harper, Bernard Nedell, Blanche Yurka, Lyle Talbot and Bela Lugosi as Merkil, the butler.
Horror comedy / Murder mystery
USA 1944
- "An insurance salesman arrives at a creepy mansion to discover his potential eccentric millionaire client already dead. Instead he gets embroiled in a house full of greedy, murderous relatives competing for the inheritance..."
This type of plot was far from new, even in 1944, so the screenwriters and the director had to boost other elements to keep it fresh and interesting. They did so by adding plenty of black (even morbid at times) humor and a dark, foreboding, gothic atmosphere to the proceedings. There's plenty of sneaking around in dark corridors and hidden passages, flashes of lightning creating spooky shadows, dead bodies disappearing / re-appearing in the oddest of places, paintings featuring moving eyes, creepy hands reaching out toward the hero... in short, all the classic gothic horror elements
The acting highlights come in the shape of Jack Haley who's a treat as the cowardly insurance salesman, and - of course - the horror legend Bela Lugosi who plays against type as a benign butler. It's quite a large cast, actually, which means there isn't time to flesh everyone out in the 75-minute running time. IM-H-O, they could easily have dropped two or three of the supporting characters without hurting the overall product.
The film was produced by the low-budget company
Pine-Thomas Productions. Although the men behind it were apparently known as the 'Two Dollar Bills,' they almost always delivered the goods by creating solid B-pictures that pleased the audience, and
One Body Too Many does exactly that even to this day, IM-H-O.
The only fly in the ointment is that the version found on Youtube comes from a poor print. It's not out of focus as such, but the edges are slightly blurry throughout, the frames show occasional artifacts, and the brightness-balance is offset too much toward the dark end of the spectrum which makes it a little difficult to see what's going on during some of the scenes. I guess those issues are inevitable given that the movie's in the public domain, but at least they don't detract too much from the viewing experience.
Definitely a fun way to spend an hour and fifteen minutes for the genre enthusiasts.
Norsebard