• Read this stickie before posting.

    • In order to reduce the number of new members requesting a Beta reader before they're really ready for one, we've instituted a 50 post requirement before you can start a thread seeking a Beta reader.
    • You can still volunteer to Beta for someone else; just please don't request someone to Beta for you until you're more familiar with the community and our members.

Entry #40 - Beta Project 2014

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
66,692
Reaction score
28,146
Age
44
Location
Cheering you all on!
Manuscript Title: 40 Days
Manuscript Genre: New Adult / Adult Fiction**
Manuscript Word Count: 85,000
Is your manuscript finished?: Y

Hook:

After moving to Los Angeles for her dream job, 23-year-old Bree Rodgers finds herself unexpectedly single. As a way of coping, Bree embarks upon a 40-Day Detox: No to talking to her ex, yes to exploring a new part of Los Angeles daily. When the job turns out to be a nightmare, Bree has two choices: stay in the city she’s growing to love and search for a better position or give up on a lifelong dream to move home and resume her relationship with the love of her life.

First 750 words:

New city. New job. New apartment.

This was supposed to be exciting. She was 23 and moving into her very own apartment in Los Angeles. Los Angeles. Sunshine for 300 days of the year. Her dream job.

Bree Rodgers had never been more miserable in her entire life.

“You’re breaking up with me?” Bree was sitting on one of the plastic bins she had brought from Indianapolis. She was not crying. She would not cry. Brandon was getting on a plane in two hours, and she would not let the last image he had of her be a tear-streaked, bright red face. “You just drove cross country with me and helped me move, and now you’re breaking up with me?”

Oh no. Her voice was doing that pre-crying quivery thing.

“Not breaking up with you. Just – ” Brandon paced. He never paced. He was the calm one in their relationship. “I think we should take a break, be willing to see other people.”

“That’s what people say when they don’t have the courage to break up with someone.” Bree pushed her fingernails into the palm of her hands to prevent tears. “Everyone knows that. It’s the new ‘it’s not me, it’s you.’”

“We’re going to be 2,200 miles apart.”

“It’s closer to two thousand.” Even as she said it, she wondered why. Like those two hundred miles would make him change his mind.

He laughed. How could he laugh? He was breaking up with her. Laughing was not allowed.

“You’re the only person in the world who could say something like that and not sound ridiculous.” Brandon knelt down in front of her, took her hands in his. She had always imagined he would do this someday, but it would be to propose. Not to break up.

Bree loved how their hands fit together. That’s how she had known, on their first date, that they were meant for each other. From the first time their hands connected, they had fit together like two interlocking puzzles.

She should pull her hands away, but she didn’t, because this was Brandon. Brandon, who had held her hands when she didn’t get that post-grad fellowship. When she found out her childhood dog had to be put down. For five years, his hands had been her steadying presence when her world upended. Now, even as his warm hands comforted her, he was the one upending of her world.

“I love you, but I can’t do long distance,” Brandon said.

Bree stared at him. “You’re telling me this now?”

“If I told you back in Indianapolis, you never would have left,” Brandon said.

“Of course not!”

Brandon stood up, his hands sliding away from hers. “That’s exactly why I couldn’t tell you! Because you wouldn’t have taken your dream job!”

“Exactly! It’s a job! That’s all! Our relationship, us, it’s much more important!” Bree stood too. She couldn’t believe him. Couldn’t believe this. “This is just an excuse, isn’t it? Your way of getting out of this relationship.”

“No! Bree, I love you. That’s why you have to take this job. I want you to be happy.” Brandon was making wild gestures with his hands. He only did that when he was upset.

Bree crossed her arms. Something she did when she was upset. “I’m happy WITH you!”

Brandon ran a hand through his hair. “Maybe now, but in five years? You were already bored with your job in Indy. You were never going to go anywhere with it.”

Bree stared at him. She had always found Brandon attractive, had teased him about being tall, dark, and handsome. Right now, he looked terribly ugly to her.

“I can’t believe you’re doing this.” She was not going to cry. “We’re a team. We’re Brandon and Bree. We’re that couple, the one who everyone wants to be.”

He looked like he was about to cry. Bree hated him for it, because he was the one causing all of this pain. He didn’t deserve to cry.

“Can you honestly say that we can make a long-distance relationship work?”

“We did before,” Bree said. “When I studied abroad!”

“That was for four months. It was temporary,” Brandon said. “You might never move back to Indiana.”

“You could move out here.” Even as she said it, Bree already knew the answer.

“I can’t leave. You know that. My family’s business, I love what I do. I don’t want to do anything else.”

What do you look for in a beta?:

**Regarding genre: I'm hoping potential beta readers will help me figure out the genre. The character’s age puts the book into New Adult, but, as written, the book more closely resembles adult fiction in the vein of women’s literature / chick lit.

At this point, what I most want is readers who can comment on the big picture: what works and what doesn’t about the characters (plus character motivation), pacing, and plot. My goal is to get feedback that would help determine the direction I take in the next round of revisions.
 

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
66,692
Reaction score
28,146
Age
44
Location
Cheering you all on!
This was really tightly written, with not many grammar or other errors. I'll cut out a lot in the crit because there are large passages that worked fine without any needed input from me. It's also my kind of story, and I wouldn't worry so much about it being NA or Adult; these characters are my step kids' ages and I'd still read it.

Manuscript Title: 40 Days
Manuscript Genre: New Adult / Adult Fiction**
Manuscript Word Count: 85,000
Is your manuscript finished?: Y

Hook:

After moving to Los Angeles for her dream job, 23-year-old Bree Rodgers finds herself unexpectedly single. As a way of coping, Bree embarks upon a 40-Day Detox: No to talking to her ex, yes to exploring a new part of Los Angeles daily. I love the "detox" idea! In fact, that's what got my interest up to keep reading. If you are going to go with this idea in the query then maybe do up the examples: "visit a new part of Los Angeles daily, [something else new and fun], and most of all no talking to the ex!" When the job turns out to be a nightmare, Bree has two choices: stay in the city she’s growing to love and search for a better position or give up on a lifelong dream to move home and resume her relationship with the love of her life. A tad confused by this last sentence. Staying somewhere she loves and getting a better job isn't a very bad alternative to going home. The stakes aren't very high. Has Brandon given an ultamatim: come home to Indiana or lose me? In a query, this will need to be more explicit. And if you go this route, she will need a special reason to want to stay with Brandon. "Sometimes love just ain't enough" as the song goes, and I've never been much convinced by love stories where we have to take it on faith that she/he just can't live without the guy/girl. LA is a huge place (stereotypically) filled with the best looking people in the world. You'll need to keep the reader from saying "dump the farm boy; go for the budding soap opera actor!"

First 750 words:

New city. New job. New apartment.

This was supposed to be exciting. She was 23 and moving into her very own apartment in Los Angeles. Los Angeles. Sunshine for 300 days of the year. Her dream job.

Start here. The 50 words or so before this read more like back cover copy. Although it's minimal as an infodump, it's still an infodump and isn't anything we won't pick up from the coming paragraphs. One time, I went to the book store and read the first page of about ten books on the "Hot Now!" table. Those that impressed me the most were those that weaved the infodump in snippets as the opening page progressed. Bree Rodgers had never been more miserable in her entire life.

“You’re breaking up with me?” Bree was sitting on one of the plastic bins she had brought from Indianapolis. On first read, I for some reason thought they were in an airport since the next sentence said he was getting on a plane. Here it seems they are in her apartment. Somewhere here might be a clever place to sneak some of the info dump in. But no more than five or so words! She was not crying. She would not cry. Brandon was getting on a plane in two hours, and she would not let the last image he had of her be a tear-streaked, bright red face. “You just drove cross country with me and helped me move, and now you’re breaking up with me?”

Oh no. Her voice was doing that pre-crying quivery thing. I'm liking the voice; almost first person.

“Not breaking up with you. Just – ” Brandon paced. He never paced. He was the calm one in their relationship. “I think we should take a break, be willing to see other people.”

“That’s what people say when they don’t have the courage to break up with someone.” Bree pushed her fingernails into the palm of her hands to prevent tears. “Everyone knows that. It’s the new ‘it’s not me, it’s you.’” As a lifetime recipient in the breakup game, there is nothing new about a "break to see other people." Perhaps not anything you need to change here, and is likely something your character would say, but it stuck out to me.

“We’re going to be 2,200 miles apart.”

“It’s closer to two thousand.” I like this attention to detail she has. Gives me a good insight into her how her mind works. Even as she said it, she wondered why. Perhaps make it more close in POV: "She wondered why she said that" or even "Why did she say that?" You've been close enough in POV to be almost first person, and how you worded the tag pulls away from her to me. Like those two hundred miles would make him change his mind.

He laughed. How could he laugh? Hmmm, maybe my first suggestion "She wondered why she said that" might be better. You don't want too many narrator questions. He was breaking up with her. Laughing was not allowed.

“You’re the only person in the world who could say something like that and not sound ridiculous.” Brandon knelt down in front of her, and took her hands in his. She had always imagined he would do this someday, but it would be to propose. Not to break up.

Bree loved how their hands fit together. That’s how she had known, on their first date, that they were meant for each other. From the first time their hands connected, they had fit together like two interlocking puzzles. Build in this, not here since you're moving along really well, but elsewhere to make that connection that it's more than love. What does she stand to lose by losing him that she can't find in someone else?

She should pull should have pulled her hands away, but she didn’t, because this was Brandon. Brandon, who had held her hands when she didn’t get that post-grad fellowship. When she found out her childhood dog had to be put down. For five years, his hands had been her steadying presence when her world upended. Now, even as his warm hands comforted her, he was the one upending of her world. Maybe put this and the previous paragraph slightly later in the story (like the scene right after this one) to do what I said earlier. You're starting to break up the pace. Maybe here just put in a line or two about those hands, those perfect hands, that had held her through so much and she hoped would wear her ring. Or something.

[snip]

Brandon stood up, his hands sliding away from hers. I do this a lot--combining two actions--and people have told me it's distracting. I like it, but many don't and it should be used sparingly. “That’s exactly why I couldn’t tell you! Because you wouldn’t have taken your dream job!”

[snip]

“No! Bree, I love you. That’s why you have to take this job. I want you to be happy.” Brandon was making wild gestures with his hands. Another thing I do that people tell me to cut down on: progressive tenses. "Brandon waved his hands wildly" or "made wild gestures" tends to go over better than "was making." Look for any "to be" conjugation with a gerund "--ing" and evaluate if there is a better way to do it. He only did that when he was upset.

[snip]

Bree stared at him. She had always found Brandon attractive, had teased him about being tall, dark, and handsome. Right now, he looked terribly ugly to her. Here's another pulling away from Bree's POV.

[snip]

I really enjoyed this excerpt. It's my kind of story, and I would definitely be up to give it a beta read. And although I have a couple of novels ready for betaing, I know that's a big commitment and would beta this one even if you don't want to swap.
 

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
66,692
Reaction score
28,146
Age
44
Location
Cheering you all on!
Entry # 40

Please note that I’m not a native speaker. English Grammar and Punctuation usage is not my strong suit.
Hook:

After moving to Los Angeles for her dream job, 23-year-old Bree Rodgers finds herself unexpectedly single. As a way of coping, Bree embarks upon a 40-Day Detox: No (I don’t know why you’re capitalizing here) to talking to her ex, yes to exploring a new part of Los Angeles daily. When the job turns out to be a nightmare, Bree has two choices: stay in the city she’s growing to love and search for a better position or give up on a lifelong dream to move home and resume her relationship with the love of her life. This makes no sense. Why would she give up her lifelong dream and her love for a shitty job in LA?

First 750 words:

New city. New job. New apartment.

This was supposed to be exciting. She was 23 and moving into her very own apartment in Los Angeles. Los Angeles. Sunshine for 300 days of the year. Her dream job. Good use of short sentences and fragments.

Bree Rodgers had never been more miserable in her entire life. Nice contrast

“You’re breaking up with me?” Bree was sitting on one of the plastic bins she had brought from Indianapolis. She was not crying. She would not cry. Brandon was getting on a plane in two hours, and she would not let the last image he had of her be a tear-streaked, bright red face. “You just drove cross country with me and helped me move, and now you’re breaking up with me?”
Great start, # 40.

Oh no. Her voice was doing that pre-crying quivery thing.

“Not breaking up with you. Just – ” Brandon paced. He never paced. He was the calm one in their relationship. “I think we should take a break, be willing to see other people.”

“That’s what people say when they don’t have the courage to break up with someone.” Bree pushed her fingernails into the palm of her hands to prevent tears. “Everyone knows that. It’s the new ‘it’s not me, it’s you.’”

“We’re going to be 2,200 miles apart.”

“It’s closer to two thousand.” Even as she said it, she wondered why. Like those two hundred miles would make him change his mind.

He laughed. How could he laugh? He was breaking up with her. Laughing was not allowed.

“You’re the only person in the world who could say something like that and not sound ridiculous.” Brandon knelt down in front of her, took her hands in his. She had always imagined he would do this someday, but it would be to propose. Not to break up.

Bree loved how their hands fit together. That’s how she had known, on their first date, that they were meant for each other. From the first time their hands connected, they had fit together like two interlocking puzzles. Nice paragraph

She should pull her hands away, but she didn’t, because this was Brandon. Brandon, who had held her hands when she didn’t get that post-grad fellowship. When she found out her childhood dog had to be put down. I would add another ‘when’ for the rhythm. It might be me though. I just love threesomes. For five years, his hands had been her steadying presence when her world upended. Now, even as his warm hands comforted her, he was the one upending of her world.

“I love you, but I can’t do long distance,” Brandon said.

Bree stared at him. “You’re telling me this now?”

“If I told you back in Indianapolis, you never would have left,” Brandon said.

“Of course not!”

Brandon stood up, his hands sliding away from hers. “That’s exactly why I couldn’t tell you! Because you wouldn’t have taken your dream job!”

“Exactly! It’s a job! That’s all! Our relationship, us, it’s much more important!” Bree stood too. She couldn’t believe him. Couldn’t believe this. This is telling and double telling. In the dialogue you’ve already showed us her disbelief. I’d cut one or both sentences. “This is just an excuse, isn’t it? Your way of getting out of this relationship.”

“No! Bree, I love you. That’s why you have to take this job. I want you to be happy.” Brandon was making wild gestures with his hands. He only did that when he was upset.

Bree crossed her arms. Something she did when she was upset. “I’m happy WITH you!” I’d stay with italics and would emphasize ‘you’

Brandon ran a hand through his hair. “Maybe now, but in five years? You were already bored with your job in Indy. You were never going to go anywhere with it.” Clunky. You can do better.

Bree stared at him. She had always found Brandon attractive, had teased him about being tall, dark, and handsome. Right now, he looked terribly ugly to her. Something more specific than terribly ugly?

“I can’t believe you’re doing this.” She was not going to cry. “We’re a team. We’re Brandon and Bree. We’re that couple, the one who everyone wants to be.”

He looked like he was about to cry. Bree hated him for it, because he was the one causing all of this pain. He didn’t deserve to cry.

“Can you honestly say that we can make a long-distance relationship work?”

“We did before,” Bree said. “When I studied abroad!”

“That was for four months. It was temporary,” Brandon said. “You might never move back to Indiana.”

“You could move out here.” Even as she said it, Bree already knew the answer.

“I can’t leave. You know that. My family’s business, I love what I do. I don’t want to do anything else.”

What do you look for in a beta?:

**Regarding genre: I'm hoping potential beta readers will help me figure out the genre. The character’s age puts the book into New Adult, but, as written, the book more closely resembles adult fiction in the vein of women’s literature / chick lit.

At this point, what I most want is readers who can comment on the big picture: what works and what doesn’t about the characters (plus character motivation), pacing, and plot. My goal is to get feedback that would help determine the direction I take in the next round of revisions.

I like what I see, #40. Loved your opening. Overall, the piece flows nicely, good descriptions, plenty of tension and drama. The backstory is woven expertly in the piece. Hard to comment on the big picture with a snippet like this. I don’t read chick lit, but I enjoyed your writing.
I hope it helps.
 

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
66,692
Reaction score
28,146
Age
44
Location
Cheering you all on!
#40
I like this. The voice is good (rather chick lit-y), and it’s a good place to start the story. But if Brandon is committed to staying in Indy, I’m wondering why Bree didn’t think about these relationship issues before. I mean, she sees them getting married…but how did she imagine that working with her in LA? Did she see this move as temporary? Envisioned a long-distance marriage? Just seemed like she should have thought about these things before.

On a smaller scale…there’s an excessive number of exclamation marks, and a lot of names when you could be using he/she. Also, I think it should be “upending her world.”

I didn’t find the hook all that hook-y, though. It was pretty generic. “Exploring a new part of LA daily” is sort of blah. As well, I think it would be stronger if we actually knew what her dream job is. And her choice is portrayed as being straightforward…but is it really going to be that easy to go back to Indy and restart her relationship?
 

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
66,692
Reaction score
28,146
Age
44
Location
Cheering you all on!
Manuscript Title: 40 Days
Manuscript Genre: New Adult / Adult Fiction**
Manuscript Word Count: 85,000
Is your manuscript finished?: Y

Hook:

After moving to Los Angeles for her dream job (I’d want to know what this dream job actually is), 23-year-old Bree Rodgers finds herself unexpectedly single (Didn’t she expect that her OH might not necessarily want to commit to a long distance relationship? I’d be more inclined to say ‘...dream job, twenty-three-year-old Bree Rodgers embarks upon...). As a way of coping, Bree embarks upon a 40-Day Detox: No to talking to her ex, yes to exploring a new part of Los Angeles daily. When the job turns out to be a nightmare, Bree has two choices: stay in the city she’s growing to love and search for a better position (I’d switch these around so the job bit comes first) or give up on a lifelong dream to move home and resume her relationship with the love of her life (when you mention her ex above, you might want to give some kind of description (‘sexy’, ‘still-charming’ or whatever) so we’ll realise she didn’t really want him to be an ex and that she still has strong feelings for him).

First 750 words:

New city. New job. New apartment. (Not really excited about this as an opening paragraph.)

This was supposed to be exciting. She was 23 and moving into her very own apartment in Los Angeles. Los Angeles. Sunshine for 300 days of the year. Her dream job.

Bree Rodgers had never been more miserable in her entire life.

“You’re breaking up with me?” Bree was sitting (I’d probably say ‘Bree slumped’ to make it more active) on one of the plastic bins she had brought from Indianapolis. She was not crying. She would not cry. Brandon (I’m not too keen on both these characters' names starting with ‘Br’ – could cause me to get confused) was getting on a plane in two hours, and she would not let the last image he had of her be a tear-streaked, bright red face. “You just drove cross country with me and helped me move, and now you’re breaking up with me?”

Oh no. Her voice was doing that pre-crying quivery thing.

“Not breaking up with you. Just – ” Brandon paced. He never paced. He was the calm one in their relationship. “I think we should take a break, be willing to see other people.”

“That’s what people say when they don’t have the courage to break up with someone.” Bree pushed her fingernails into the palm of her hands to prevent tears. “Everyone knows that. It’s the new ‘it’s not me, it’s you.’”

“We’re going to be 2,200 miles apart.”

“It’s closer to two thousand.” Even as she said it, she wondered why. Like those two hundred miles would make him change his mind.

He laughed. How could he laugh? He was breaking up with her. Laughing was not allowed. (This last sentence seems a little dry to me. I’d want more emotion behind it.)

“You’re the only person in the world who could say something like that and not sound ridiculous.” Brandon knelt down (Can cut) in front of her, took her hands in his. She had always imagined he would do this someday, but it would be to propose. Not to break up.

Bree loved how their hands fit together. That’s how she had known, on their first date, that they were meant for each other. From the first time their hands connected, they had fit together like two interlocking puzzles.

She should pull her hands away, but she didn’t, because this was Brandon. Brandon, who had held her hands when she didn’t get that post-grad fellowship. When she found out her childhood dog had to be put down. For five years, his hands had been her steadying presence when her world upended. Now, even as his warm hands comforted her, he was the one upending of (Cut) her world.

“I love you, but I can’t do long distance,” Brandon said.

Bree stared at him. “You’re telling me this now?”

“If I told you back in Indianapolis, you never would have left,” Brandon said.

“Of course not!”

Brandon stood up, his hands sliding away from hers. “That’s exactly why I couldn’t tell you! Because you wouldn’t have taken your dream job!”

“Exactly! It’s a job! That’s all! Our relationship, us, it’s much more important!” Bree stood too. She couldn’t believe him. Couldn’t believe this. “This is just an excuse, isn’t it? Your way of getting out of this relationship.”

“No! Bree, I love you. That’s why you have to take this job. I want you to be happy.” (Aw) Brandon was making wild gestures with his hands. He only did that when he was upset.

Bree crossed her arms. Something she did when she (I’d italicise ‘she’) was upset. “I’m happy WITH you!”

Brandon ran a hand through his hair. “Maybe now, but in five years? You were already bored with your job in Indy. You were never going to go anywhere with it.”

Bree stared at him. She had always found Brandon attractive, had teased him about being tall, dark, and handsome. Right now, he looked terribly ugly to her.

“I can’t believe you’re doing this.” She was not going to cry. “We’re a team. We’re Brandon and Bree. We’re that couple, the one who everyone wants to be.”

He looked like he was about to cry. Bree hated him for it, because he was the one causing all of this pain. He didn’t deserve to cry.

“Can you honestly say that we can make a long-distance relationship work?”

“We did before,” Bree said. “When I studied abroad!”

“That was for four months. It was temporary,” Brandon said. “You might never move back to Indiana.”

“You could move out here.” Even as she said it, Bree already knew the answer.

“I can’t leave. You know that. My family’s business, I love what I do. I don’t want to do anything else.”

Hmm, sorry, but I’m not really sold on this as an opening. We’re having this big break-up scene, but I don’t know these characters so I’m finding it hard to care that they’re breaking up. Could you maybe start later, when she’s closing the door behind him? (Or later than that, when she’s going through the ‘anger’ stage (or whatever stage you think best) of the 5 stages of grief when she’s alone in the apartment?) You could then weave in this break-up scene later on in the book when we know Bree better and we’ll see just how devastating it was for her (& how much he really was the love of her life).

I really liked the idea of her exploring a new part of LA each day, by the way.

What do you look for in a beta?:

**Regarding genre: I'm hoping potential beta readers will help me figure out the genre. The character’s age puts the book into New Adult, but, as written, the book more closely resembles adult fiction in the vein of women’s literature / chick lit. (I’d just tailor it to the agents accordingly – you’ll be able to target more that way. Agents for women’s literature/chick lit might not say they’ll represent NA, so you wouldn’t mention the NA label when querying them, and vice versa.)

At this point, what I most want is readers who can comment on the big picture: what works and what doesn’t about the characters (plus character motivation), pacing, and plot. My goal is to get feedback that would help determine the direction I take in the next round of revisions.
 

beckethm

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 3, 2013
Messages
1,443
Reaction score
467
Location
St. Paul
I like the premise of this book, and the opening grew on me as I read, but my first impression of Bree is that she's whiny and a little childish. When we meet her, she's struggling not to cry and begging her boyfriend not to leave. It's an uncomfortable scene that makes me want to quietly sneak away and pretend I didn't hear anything.

I will say that I like her better by the end of the excerpt, as we find out enough about her history with Brandon to justify the tears. I wonder, though, whether it might be a good idea to open a little earlier in the scene, when Bree is in a more positive frame of mind. I imagine a moment where they've just moved in the last of her stuff, she's looking around the apartment, feeling excited about her new place, and then Brandon comes in and says "we need to talk." That kind of emotional roller coaster would draw me in as a reader.

All in all, though, this looks like a good story and the writing is solid. If you still need betas, PM me.
 

LAgrunion

not to be taken seriously
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
1,114
Reaction score
354
Location
Los Angeles
New city. New job. New apartment. I like the repetition.

This was supposed to be exciting. She was 23 and moving into her very own apartment in Los Angeles. Los Angeles. Sunshine for 300 days of the year. Probably more like 355 days. Heh. Her dream job.

Bree Rodgers had never been more miserable in her entire life. I like the flip.

“You’re breaking up with me?” Bree was sitting on one of the plastic bins she had brought from Indianapolis. She was not crying. She would not cry. Brandon was getting on a plane in two hours, and she would not let the last image he had of her be a tear-streaked, bright red face. “You just drove cross country with me and helped me move, and now you’re breaking up with me?”

Oh no. Her voice was doing that pre-crying quivery thing. I like this.

“Not breaking up with you. Just – ” Brandon paced. He never paced. He was the calm one in their relationship. “I think we should take a break, be willing to see other people.”

“That’s what people say when they don’t have the courage to break up with someone.” Bree pushed her fingernails into the palm of her hands to prevent tears. “Everyone knows that. It’s the new ‘it’s not me, it’s you.’” Hahaha. Funny.

“We’re going to be 2,200 miles apart.”

“It’s closer to two thousand.” Even as she said it, she wondered why. Cute. Like those two hundred miles would make him change his mind.

He laughed. How could he laugh? He was breaking up with her. Laughing was not allowed.

“You’re the only person in the world who could say something like that and not sound ridiculous.” Brandon knelt down in front of her, took her hands in his. She had always imagined he would do this someday, but it would be to propose. Not to break up.

Bree loved how their hands fit together. That’s how she had known, on their first date, that they were meant for each other. From the first time their hands connected, they had fit together like two interlocking puzzles.

She should pull her hands away, but she didn’t, because this was Brandon. Brandon, who had held her hands when she didn’t get that post-grad fellowship. When she found out her childhood dog had to be put down. For five years, his hands had been her steadying presence when her world upended. Now, even as his warm hands comforted her, he was the one upending of her world.

“I love you, but I can’t do long distance,” Brandon said.

Bree stared at him. “You’re telling me this now?”

“If I told you back in Indianapolis, you never would have left,” Brandon said.

“Of course not!”

Brandon stood up, his hands sliding away from hers. “That’s exactly why I couldn’t tell you! Because you wouldn’t have taken your dream job!”

“Exactly! It’s a job! That’s all! Our relationship, us, it’s much more important!” Bree stood too. She couldn’t believe him. Couldn’t believe this. “This is just an excuse, isn’t it? Your way of getting out of this relationship.”

“No! Bree, I love you. That’s why you have to take this job. I want you to be happy.” Brandon was making wild gestures with his hands. He only did that when he was upset.

Bree crossed her arms. Something she did when she was upset. “I’m happy WITH you!” Okay, I'm not a big fan of "Thou shalt not use exclamation marks in your novel or else the Literary Deity will smite your arse." But eight exclamations in the last few lines!?! This is gross malfeasance involving the exclamation! :D Use it; don’t abuse it.

Brandon ran a hand through his hair. “Maybe now, but in five years? You were already bored with your job in Indy. You were never going to go anywhere with it.”

Bree stared at him. She had always found Brandon attractive, had teased him about being tall, dark, and handsome. Right now, he looked terribly ugly to her.

“I can’t believe you’re doing this.” She was not going to cry. “We’re a team. We’re Brandon and Bree. We’re that couple, the one who everyone wants to be.”

He I'd probably italicize "he," cuz I like the emphasis to contrast from her determination not to cry in the previous line. looked like he was about to cry. Bree hated him for it, because he was the one causing all of this pain. He didn’t deserve to cry.

“Can you honestly say that we can make a long-distance relationship work?”

“We did before,” Bree said. “When I studied abroad!”

“That was for four months. It was temporary,” Brandon said. “You might never move back to Indiana.”

“You could move out here.” Even as she said it, Bree already knew the answer.

“I can’t leave. You know that. My family’s business, I love what I do. I don’t want to do anything else.”

At first I didn't care to read this because it's NA, and NA seems to be all (or at least overwhelmingly) romance, and I don't really like romance that much. But the exploring-LA part caught my attention since I live there.

But as I began to skim it, I liked it. So I restarted to read it more carefully. It has a chick-lit feel. 750 words is so short, and there's no way to judge a story based on 750. (I think you need the whole book before judging the story.) But that length does give good hints about the quality of the writing, which I think is good here. The sentences are short and snappy. I hate long sentences. It's third-person, but very close--another plus. I can see a hint of cute humor in the voice, which is also a plus. So, overall, I likes it.

Probably the only content-based complaint I have is that the opening is about a breakup because he doesn't want a long-distance relationship. That's not too exciting, since it's a pretty common cause of breakup. I'd prefer an inciting event that's, um, more differenter. But like I said, this is too soon to judge. I see enough potential to read more.

I've read a fair amount of women's fic in recent years as my MS is WF. I might be able to beta for you in the near future should you need one. So, feel free to PM me and we can talk and stuff.

That's all the gibberish I gots for now.

ETA: You should consider Beckethm's offer to beta your stuff. I don't know what kind of feedback she gives, but she's sharp and her writing is nice.
 
Last edited: