• Read this stickie before posting.

    • In order to reduce the number of new members requesting a Beta reader before they're really ready for one, we've instituted a 50 post requirement before you can start a thread seeking a Beta reader.
    • You can still volunteer to Beta for someone else; just please don't request someone to Beta for you until you're more familiar with the community and our members.

Beta readers for 120k standalone adult fantasy

Parametric

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
10,848
Reaction score
4,763
Hi there! I’m looking for general feedback on my 120,000-word standalone military fantasy with horror elements, RUTHLESS COUNTRY, with a view to querying it in the next few months. I’m a freelance editor by trade, so hopefully the writing is decent enough on a sentence level. This is my 12th novel and I’d love to make it an exciting, cinematic, action-packed story about female soldiers, necromancers and spies.

Synopsis: At 18, rural peasant Jelena Markov is conscripted by a warlord to defend a fortress of iceglass, home to the feared necromancers of the White Banner. She finds her courage in the terror of battle, killing magical soldiers who rain down from rivers of light in the night sky, but she also receives a supernatural curse—“You will never know peace”—that drives her to become a career soldier…

Snippet from the first battle sequence:

Markov knew they’d reached Icewall when she heard the first “Oh, shit!” from further up the column.

They had been marching all day. The officers had pushed them so hard they hadn’t stopped to eat, stuffing down cold rations as they trudged toward the mountains rising on the horizon. The cavalry had ranged ahead, sweeping the frozen farmland on both sides of the road, engaging enemy scouts. The bodies looked so small, crumpled in ditches.

Now a smouldering sunset cast the darkness of ancient forests across them from the left, the sea on their right. It threw their shadows across the road as they rounded the last curve and saw—

“Oh, shit!” It was Markov’s turn.

The city. A brooding presence ten times bigger than Markov had ever imagined, dominated by a fortress built into a mountain pass, fortified with massive walls of eerie iceglass… and surrounded by a seething mass of thousands of Sanjenese troops. Fires burned in their camp along a low ridge. It was such a nightmarish vision that Markov instinctively shied away. It wasn’t real. It wasn’t happening. They couldn’t be going into that.

NB: This book contains significant physical violence and horror. Characters die from war, famine, childbirth, fire, drowning, magical paratroopers, experimental necromancy and soulless undead. One child character faces physical jeopardy, but is not injured. It’s not grimdark, and there’s no sexual violence. I really want this female-dominated story to be fun and appealing for female fantasy readers in particular.

Thanks in advance for your time. ♥️
 

KitFalbo

Registered
Joined
Aug 17, 2024
Messages
3
Reaction score
2
What kind/Level of input are you looking for? While mostly acceptable which is a fine target, I see things in the snippet like possibly working on removing filter words to make it smoother. The dialog having contextually comedic aspects which I'm unsure if it is intentional juxtaposed with "nightmarish vision." I also understand it is possible to get too much input as it can be demoralizing even within a subjective container.
 

Parametric

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
10,848
Reaction score
4,763
What kind/Level of input are you looking for? While mostly acceptable which is a fine target, I see things in the snippet like possibly working on removing filter words to make it smoother. The dialog having contextually comedic aspects which I'm unsure if it is intentional juxtaposed with "nightmarish vision." I also understand it is possible to get too much input as it can be demoralizing even within a subjective container.
Hi, thanks for your reply. I'm looking for high-level feedback on the story, as I don't want to spend too much time polishing scenes that I might have to cut. So issues like whether the protagonist is reasonably engaging, if the pacing drags, does the ending feel satisfying, are there any parts you'd recommend cutting, etc.
 

Brigid Barry

Can't talk. Editing.
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jan 22, 2012
Messages
11,868
Reaction score
22,346
Location
Maine, USA
Hi Parametric, can you link to your query/opening pages (presuming you posted them on the forum)?
 

Parametric

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
10,848
Reaction score
4,763
Hi Parametric, can you link to your query/opening pages (presuming you posted them on the forum)?
The query isn't written yet, and I wasn't planning to post the opening pages. I haven't been as active on the forums and in SYW since I started my editing business (I turned in six novel-length edits this month and my brain is melted) so if there are no takers, that's unfortunate, but I'll have to live with it.