- Joined
- Jul 18, 2021
- Messages
- 424
- Reaction score
- 230
Remember when J.K. Rowling said that Ron and Hermione's romance had to do with her own wish-fulfillment and nothing to do with literature?
Here's a link so we can all remember. =)
After there is distance with time, I realize that some scenes I've written probably don't serve the characters or the plot as much as they serve my fantasies. Before your imagination goes nuts, I'm talking about how I wrote a character who plays the violin expertly and sings about 3 whole songs in 20,000 words, lyrics written out and the whole 9 yards.
Author wish-fulfillment might sometimes be reader wish-fulfillment by coincidence, but probably not as often as we hope. Instead we probably have to actively help our reader want certain things for our characters. Failing to be aware of these problems can lead to regrets-- hopefully ones we can change if our MS didn't get published.
On the other hand, desires can be the genesis of our work. J.K, said, her desires helped create her series and characters in the beginning.
Looking at what is really good for my book and characters instead of what I want myself is a learning point for me. As a reader of other people's unpublished work, I always know when I'm reading someone else's desire that isn't my own and it's kind of a deal-breaker for me if it gets too self-indulgent or long.
This is how I plan to try to avoid regrets:
1. Figure out what is wish-fulfillment during or after it is written.
2. Gain some distance either through time or from critique groups so that I can know if these scenes work for the characters and the audience (everyone would love being a great violinist, right?).
3. Try to replace, if needed, the wish-scenes with scenes that serve the characters, plot and theme. Throw out scenes that don't serve the book. My audience might not want to tag along while I have my fun.
Please share your experiences with this as I am so new to being aware of this as a potential problem to watch out for. And also, did you get better at creating scenes without wish-fulfillment? Or is it still a really powerful tool in the beginning?
Here's a link so we can all remember. =)
Book News: J.K. Rowling Says She Regrets Matching Ron And Hermione
Also: a new poem by Stephen Burt; Lemony Snicket's prize for librarians; the best books coming out this week.
www.npr.org
After there is distance with time, I realize that some scenes I've written probably don't serve the characters or the plot as much as they serve my fantasies. Before your imagination goes nuts, I'm talking about how I wrote a character who plays the violin expertly and sings about 3 whole songs in 20,000 words, lyrics written out and the whole 9 yards.
Author wish-fulfillment might sometimes be reader wish-fulfillment by coincidence, but probably not as often as we hope. Instead we probably have to actively help our reader want certain things for our characters. Failing to be aware of these problems can lead to regrets-- hopefully ones we can change if our MS didn't get published.
On the other hand, desires can be the genesis of our work. J.K, said, her desires helped create her series and characters in the beginning.
Looking at what is really good for my book and characters instead of what I want myself is a learning point for me. As a reader of other people's unpublished work, I always know when I'm reading someone else's desire that isn't my own and it's kind of a deal-breaker for me if it gets too self-indulgent or long.
This is how I plan to try to avoid regrets:
1. Figure out what is wish-fulfillment during or after it is written.
2. Gain some distance either through time or from critique groups so that I can know if these scenes work for the characters and the audience (everyone would love being a great violinist, right?).
3. Try to replace, if needed, the wish-scenes with scenes that serve the characters, plot and theme. Throw out scenes that don't serve the book. My audience might not want to tag along while I have my fun.
Please share your experiences with this as I am so new to being aware of this as a potential problem to watch out for. And also, did you get better at creating scenes without wish-fulfillment? Or is it still a really powerful tool in the beginning?
Last edited: