• Basic Writing questions is not a crit forum. All crits belong in Share Your Work

Allen Guthrie's Infamous Writing Tips

editing_for_authors
Editing for authors: because every writer needs a good editor.

robertmblevins

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 4, 2008
Messages
85
Reaction score
26
Location
Seattle, Washington State
Website
www.escapevelocitymagazine.com
Allen Guthrie, an acquisition editor for Point Blank Press, wrote up a 'white paper' three years ago called 'Hunting Down the Pleonasms' that has become a cult classic. Guthrie gave Adventure Books of Seattle permission to reprint this document wherever we liked. It is a permanent download over at our main site, but I wanted to reproduce it here. It is very specific. Over at the AB site, it's been downloaded hundreds of times, and I think every writer should post this on the wall near their computer.

'Hunting Down the Pleonasms'
I can’t stress strongly enough that writing is subjective. We all strive for different goals. Consequently, we all need our own set of rules—and some of us don’t need rules at all! Personally, I like rules. If nothing else, it’s fun breaking them.

1: Avoid pleonasms. A pleonasm is a word or phrase which can be removed from a sentence without changing its meaning. For example, in “Hunting Down The Pleonasm”, ‘down’ is pleonastic. Cut it and the meaning of the sentence does not alter. Many words are used pleonastically: ‘just’, ‘that’ and ‘actually’ are three frequently-seen culprits (I actually just know that he’s the killer can be trimmed to I know he’s the killer), and phrases like ‘more or less’ and ‘in any shape or form’ are redundant.

2: Use oblique dialogue. Try to generate conflict at all times in your writing. Attempt the following experiment at home or work: spend the day refusing to answer your family and colleagues’ questions directly. Did you generate conflict? I bet you did. Apply that principle to your writing and your characters will respond likewise.

3: Use strong verbs in preference to adverbs. I won’t say avoid adverbs, period, because about once every fifty pages they’re okay! What’s not okay is to use an adverb as an excuse for failing to find the correct verb. To ‘walk slowly’ is much less effective than to ‘plod’ or ‘trudge’. To ‘connect strongly’ is much less effective than to ‘forge a connection’.

4: Cut adjectives where possible. See rule 3 (for ‘verb’ read ‘noun’).

5: Pairs of adjectives are exponentially worse than single adjectives. The ‘big, old’ man walked slowly towards the ‘tall, beautiful’ girl. When I read a sentence like that, I’m hoping he dies before he arrives at his destination. Mind you, that’s probably a cue for a ‘noisy, white’ ambulance to arrive. Wailingly, perhaps!

6: Keep speeches short. Any speech of more than three sentences should be broken up. Force your character to do something. Make him take note of his surroundings. Ground the reader. Create a sense of place.

7: If you find you’ve said the same thing more than once, choose the best and cut the rest. Frequently, I see the same idea presented several ways. It’s as if the writer is saying, “The first couple of images might not work, but the third one should do it. If not, maybe all three together will swing it.” The writer is repeating himself. Like this. This is a subtle form of pleonasm.

8: Show, don’t tell. Much vaunted advice, yet rarely heeded. An example: expressing emotion indirectly. Is your preferred reader intelligent? Yes? Then treat them accordingly. Tears were streaming down Lila’s face. She was very sad. Can the second sentence be inferred from the first? In context, let’s hope so. So cut it. If you want to engage your readers, don’t explain everything to them. Show them what’s happening and allow their intelligence to do the rest. And there’s a bonus to this approach. Because movies, of necessity, show rather than tell, this approach to your writing will help when it’s time to begin work on the screenplay adaptation of your novel!

9: Describe the environment in ways that are pertinent to the story. And try to make such descriptions active. Instead of describing a book lying on a table, have your psycho-killer protagonist pick it up, glance at it and move it to the arm of the sofa. He needs something to do to break up those long speeches, right?

10: Don’t be cute. In the above example, your protagonist should not be named Si Coe.

11: Avoid sounding ‘writerly’. Better to dirty up your prose. When you sound like a writer, your voice has crept in and authorial intrusion is always unwelcome. In the best writing, the author is invisible.

12: Fix your Point Of View (POV). Make it clear whose head you’re in as early as possible. And stay there for the duration of the scene. Unless you’re already a highly successful published novelist, in which case you can do what you like. The reality is that although most readers aren’t necessarily clued up on the finer points of POV, they know what’s confusing and what isn’t.

13: Don’t confuse the reader. If you write something you think might be unclear, it is. Big time. Change it or cut it.

14: Use ‘said’ to carry dialogue. Sid Fleischman calls ‘said’, “the invisible word.”

15: Whilst it’s good to assume your reader is intelligent, never assume they’re psychic.

16: Start scenes late and leave them early.

17: When writing a novel, start with your characters in action. Fill in any necessary backstory as you go along.

18: Give your characters clear goals. Always. Every scene. And provide obstacles to those goals. Always. Every scene. If the POV character in a scene does not have a goal, provide one or cut the scene. If there is no obstacle, add one or cut the scene.

19: Don’t allow characters who are sexually attracted to one another the opportunity to get into bed unless at least one of them has a jealous partner.

20: Torture your protagonist. It’s not enough for him to be stuck up a tree. You must throw rocks at him while he figures out how to get down.

21: Use all five senses in your descriptions. Smell and touch are too often neglected.

22: Vary your sentence lengths. I tend to write short, and it’s amazing what a difference combing [sic?] a couple of sentences can make.

23: Don’t allow your fictional characters to speak in sentences. Unless you want them to sound fictional.

24: Cut out filtering devices, wherever possible. ‘He felt’, ‘he thought’, ‘he observed’ are all filters. They distance the reader from the character.

25: Avoid unnecessary repetition of tense. For example: I’d gone to the hospital. They’d kept me waiting for hours. Eventually, I’d seen a doctor. Usually, the first sentence is sufficient to establish tense. I’d gone to the hospital. They kept me waiting for hours. Eventually, I saw a doctor.

26: When you finish your book, pinpoint the weakest scene and cut it. If necessary, replace it with a sentence or paragraph.

27: Don’t plant information. How is Donald, your son? I’m quite sure Donald’s father doesn’t need reminding who Donald is. Their relationship is mentioned purely to provide the reader with information.

28: If an opinion expressed through dialogue makes your POV character look like a jerk, allow him to think it rather than say it. He’ll express the same opinion, but seem like a lot less of a jerk.

29: Characters who smile and grin a lot come across as deranged fools. Sighing and shrugging are also actions to avoid. Eliminating smiles, sighs and shrugs is almost always an improvement. Smiling sadly is a capital offence.

30: Pronouns are big trouble for such little words. The most useful piece of information I ever encountered on the little blighters was this: pronouns refer to the nearest matching noun backwards. For example: John took the knife out of its sheath and stabbed Paul with it. Well, that’s good news for Paul. If you travel backwards from ‘it’, you’ll see that John has stabbed Paul with the sheath! Observing this rule leads to much clearer writing.

31: Spot the moment of maximum tension and hold it for as long as possible. Or as John D. MacDonald put it: “Freeze the action and shoot him later.”

32: If something works, forget about the rule that says it shouldn’t.


 
Last edited by a moderator:

gp101

Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 16, 2005
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
246
Location
New England
Great list. Most of it, I've heard before. Almost all of it has been covered by UJ. But there are a couple tidbits that are new to me. And clearly explained. Love it.
 

DanielArenson

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 26, 2008
Messages
73
Reaction score
0
You taught me a new word... "Pleonasm". I love it. I'm always telling people to avoid them; now I know what to call them. Thanks!

Daniel
DanielArenson.com
 

Kalyke

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 7, 2008
Messages
1,850
Reaction score
179
Location
New Mexico, USA
I love "Torture your Protagonist." Rule 20. Today my poor guy went through hell. I am now patting the poor fellow, trying to prepare him for the insidious hell-hole I have planned for tomorrow. He keeps shaking and mewing, and begging me for a tumbler of vodka. I can't talk sense to him
 

WriterX316

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 1, 2008
Messages
69
Reaction score
6
Location
Austin, TX
upgrade time

Hroom, edit story I must.

Thanks for the advice man. My story is guilty of three big speeches so its time to break out the scissors. Also I didn't realize the sin of adverbs and adjectives. Thesaurus is getting broken open. My story is very visual but I forgot about the senses. In general I realize how much work there is to do.


So thanks for the posting.

:Shrug:
 

Buddikins

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 31, 2008
Messages
97
Reaction score
9
Location
Australia
Thanks for the rules.
And #19 is great :D Although my MCs mightn't think so...
 

Alex667

Registered
Joined
Jun 18, 2008
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida - where there is A LOT of material
This list is great! Some of the rules I already knew. But there are many on this list I wasn't even remotely thinking about. I went back through the chapter I'm working on now and applied the rules on this list I wasn't using. The improvement is amazing. My most common faux pas is cramming loads of adjectives and adverbs into everything.
 

BfloGal

Lost in a plot hole
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 20, 2008
Messages
1,028
Reaction score
150
Location
Western NY
Website
barbearly.blogspot.com
This list is great. Unfortunately now I'm afraid to write anything!

I think I'll try to cut adjective and adverb overuse, and work on developing stronger verbs. I'll have to hit the rest in the editing process.

<deep sigh>

<Puts hand over mouth> Nobody heard that, did they?

<smiles sadly>
 

BlueLucario

Blood Elves FTW
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Dec 1, 2007
Messages
2,627
Reaction score
220
Location
South Florida

20: Torture your protagonist. It’s not enough for him to be stuck up a tree. You must throw rocks at him while he figures out how to get down.

21: Use all five senses in your descriptions. Smell and touch are too often neglected.

22: Vary your sentence lengths. I tend to write short, and it’s amazing what a difference combing a couple of sentences can make.


24: Cut out filtering devices, wherever possible. ‘He felt’, ‘he thought’, ‘he observed’ are all filters. They distance the reader from the character.


29: Characters who smile and grin a lot come across as deranged fools. Sighing and shrugging are also actions to avoid. Eliminating smiles, sighs and shrugs is almost always an improvement. Smiling sadly is a capital offence.

Confession. These are the hardest ones listed there. :(

And can you explain #2?
 

MumblingSage

Inarticulate Herb
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 15, 2008
Messages
2,302
Reaction score
347
Location
in a certain state of mind
My impression is it says 'use dialog to further complicate your characters' lives'--add tension. Which looks like a great idea in the hands of an author that can do that thing, but...I just quail at the thought. If my characters didn't solve their problems through conversation, they'd never solve problems at all.
 

tomber

Banned
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
49
Reaction score
2
Isn't the last rule the most important?

For example:

He skipped off the gunrest and looked gravely at his watcher, gathering about his legs the loose folds of his gown. The plump shadowed face and sullen oval jowl recalled a prelate, patron of the arts in the middle ages. A pleasant smile broke quietly over his lips.

An adverb, double adjectives, a smile ("a pleasant" one, too, for clarification)...

All from the first page of Joyce's Ulysses.
 
Last edited:

dawinsor

Dorothy A. Winsor
VPXI
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
2,108
Reaction score
634
Location
Amid the alien corn
It's a sign of my barbarism, but every time this thread's title pops to the main screen, I read it as Arlo Guthrie.
 

Phot's Moll

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 7, 2008
Messages
273
Reaction score
30
Location
England
Excellent advice. I understand the theory - now I 'just' need to put it into practise.
 

Featured Book