I'm usually a purist and like things in original form - but having recently watched the original Long, Hot Summer with Paul Newman, I have to say I preferred the remake. Sure, it had Don Johnson - and compared to Paul Newman, well, there's no comparison.
But aside from Paul Newman, the original had no one who could ACT worth a tinker's darn.
And for some reason, The Long, Hot Summer (remake) struck a cord with me when I saw it and it stuck. (it was a long, hot summer and my bare skin was stuck to the leather couch while I watched).