- Joined
- Aug 15, 2005
- Messages
- 262
- Reaction score
- 24
- Location
- Portland, Oregon
- Website
- www.ericfogle.com
So,
I was sitting here tonight with a very good friend of mine, a AD&D DM who helps work out some of the flaws of my world, and we got discussing names.
At this point, I should tell you that at some subconscious level, I have used names from video games. (NO Legoas, Drizzt, Aragorn, etc etc) I can honestly say it wasn't my intention of doing this...but rather one day I was reading these names and started to somewhat recognize them. (Stormwind Keep (me) / City of Stormwind (World of Warcraft), Anduin of Arloc (me) / Anduin Lightbringer (Warcraft I), City of Aresleigh (me) / Eresleigh Castle (Dark Age of Camelot))
Saying all of that, we got in this huge...and I mean HUGE discussion about originality. Obviously, I feel kinda dumb for using similar names, but I am not exactly sure how using something like a name generator is exactly original either. Isn't the story and the way its told, make something original?
I mean I have heard countless different approaches to making names, towns, river, mountains, etc etc...but they all seem no better then what I did.
For example, there was a post here several months back, that said if you want to be original - twist current words. Uh, not original...at all. I mean seriously, if a person does this...taking words that exist and alteroing them into names, I just don't see this as original at all. I do this btw.
There was also mention of name generators. Once again - in no way shape or form, is this original. I mean zero. If I go to a program...and it tells me names...then how original is that? I do this too.
That leaves making up your own names, which I also do. At the cost of sounding goofy...most made up on the spot names either mask RL names or severely lack proper annunciation mechanics to make them sound anything more than poorly made up names. I do this too.
So...you tell me. Am I looking at this all wrong? Or, does the personality of my own characters make them different enough to disregard the name? Or, should I just hack my way to all new 'original' names using a RG?
Discuss...
I was sitting here tonight with a very good friend of mine, a AD&D DM who helps work out some of the flaws of my world, and we got discussing names.
At this point, I should tell you that at some subconscious level, I have used names from video games. (NO Legoas, Drizzt, Aragorn, etc etc) I can honestly say it wasn't my intention of doing this...but rather one day I was reading these names and started to somewhat recognize them. (Stormwind Keep (me) / City of Stormwind (World of Warcraft), Anduin of Arloc (me) / Anduin Lightbringer (Warcraft I), City of Aresleigh (me) / Eresleigh Castle (Dark Age of Camelot))
Saying all of that, we got in this huge...and I mean HUGE discussion about originality. Obviously, I feel kinda dumb for using similar names, but I am not exactly sure how using something like a name generator is exactly original either. Isn't the story and the way its told, make something original?
I mean I have heard countless different approaches to making names, towns, river, mountains, etc etc...but they all seem no better then what I did.
For example, there was a post here several months back, that said if you want to be original - twist current words. Uh, not original...at all. I mean seriously, if a person does this...taking words that exist and alteroing them into names, I just don't see this as original at all. I do this btw.
There was also mention of name generators. Once again - in no way shape or form, is this original. I mean zero. If I go to a program...and it tells me names...then how original is that? I do this too.
That leaves making up your own names, which I also do. At the cost of sounding goofy...most made up on the spot names either mask RL names or severely lack proper annunciation mechanics to make them sound anything more than poorly made up names. I do this too.
So...you tell me. Am I looking at this all wrong? Or, does the personality of my own characters make them different enough to disregard the name? Or, should I just hack my way to all new 'original' names using a RG?
Discuss...